Benchwarmers Bagels

$ • Breakfast, Coffee Shops

Menu Order Online

About Benchwarmers Bagels

Benchwarmers Bagels serves delicious bagels that hit the mark. The service is generally good, with knowledgeable staff, although there may be some minor issues with training. The atmosphere can be loud inside, but the outside seating is fine. Popular items include the Bagel sandwich, Grit bagel, and Zaa'tar & Sea Salt bagel, paired with tasty cream cheese options like vegan cream cheese and honey cream cheese. Customers appreciate the cool atmosphere and often return for the bagels, which many consider to be the best in the triangle. While some have noted that the prices can be steep—like 25 dollars for two bagels—many agree the food is good enough to make it worth it. Additionally, Benchwarmers doubles as a pizza shop after 5 PM, adding to the unique experience. However, be cautious of burnt bagels, as some customers have experienced this issue.