Captain Cookie & the Milk Man

500 E Davie St, Raleigh
(919) 909-6965

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Edible Cookie Dough Large
Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich
Assorted Half Dozen
Ice Cream Sandwich

Featured items
Assorted Half Dozen
Please specify your selection of cookies Reheat Instructions:  Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel
Assorted Baker's Dozen
Please specify your selection of 13 cookies Reheat Instructions:  Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel
Ice Cream Sandwich
Ice Cream Sandwich. Please choose what you want your top and bottom cookies to be.
Edible Cookie Dough (small)
Our ready-to-eat dough is made with pasteurized eggs and heat treated flour so it's not only delicious, but crafted to be eaten straight out of the 4oz jar!
Cookies & Milk
One bottle of milk plus two cookies of your choice. Reheat Instructions:  Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel
Milkshake
Ice Cream
Ice cream from a local creamery
Milk
Soda Float
Our delicious local ice cream plus your favorite fizzy drink!
Edible Cookie Dough (large)
Our ready-to-eat dough is made with pasteurized eggs and heat treated flour so it's not only delicious, but crafted to be eaten straight out of the 8oz jar!

Most Popular
Milkshake
Assorted Half Dozen
Please specify your selection of 6 cookies Reheat Instructions:  Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel
Assorted Baker's Dozen
Please specify your selection of 13 cookies Reheat Instructions:  Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel
Ice Cream Sandwich
Ice Cream Sandwich. Please choose what you want your top and bottom cookies to be.

The Captain's Cookies
Assorted Half Dozen
Please specify your selection of cookies Reheat Instructions:  Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel
Assorted Baker's Dozen
Please specify your selection of cookies Reheat Instructions:  Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel

Local Ice Cream Sandwiches
Ice Cream Sandwich
Ice Cream Sandwich. Please choose what you want your top and bottom cookies to be.

Tasty Drinks
Milkshake
Milk
Soda Float
Our delicious local ice cream plus your favorite fizzy drink!
Soda

Ice Cream
Ice Cream
Ice cream from a local creamery

Cookies & Milk
Cookies & Milk
One bottle of milk plus two cookies of your choice. Reheat Instructions:  Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel

Family Style Meals
Assorted Baker's Dozen
Please specify your selection of 13 cookies Reheat Instructions:  Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel
Assorted Half Dozen
Please specify your selection of 6 cookies Reheat Instructions:  Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel

Edible Cookie Dough
Edible Cookie Dough (small)
Our ready-to-eat dough is made with pasteurized eggs and heat treated flour so it's not only delicious, but crafted to be eaten straight out of the 4oz jar!
Edible Cookie Dough (large)
Our ready-to-eat dough is made with pasteurized eggs and heat treated flour so it's not only delicious, but crafted to be eaten straight out of the 8oz jar!

Bake at Home Kits
Two Dozen to Bake
Our dough kits are a fun way to have straight out of the oven cookies at Captain Cookie quality at home. We'll send you everything you need!
Bake a Dozen
Our dough kits are a fun way to have straight out of the oven cookies at Captain Cookie quality at home. We'll send you everything you need!

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+50 photos
Photo credit: google
+49 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

The ice cream and cookies were delicious! We got the cookies and cream and chocolate chip cookie and the strawberry ice cream with confetti cookie. They were both delicious. Will definitely be coming back!
May 2025
Cookies are good but ice cream is not. Some of the flavors we got tasted too artificial. Ice cream cookie sandwich is over priced and melted quite quickly. Would come back for cookies only and add my own favorite ice-cream at home to make a cookie sandwich!
March 2025
We came just because the name of this place. The cookies are soft and delicious and so is the ice cream. I got 2 scoops in the cup and couldn't finish. Highly recommend and will be going back
January 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Dank Burrito - 500 E Davie St
Tacos, Fast Food, Asian Fusion, Vegan
ALIMENTARI AT LEFT BANK - 500 E Davie St #136
Butcher, Pasta Shops
Mama Crow's Burger & Salad Shop - 500 E Davie St STE 116
Hamburger, Burgers, Salad, Vegan

Captain Cookie & the Milk Man

500 E Davie St, Raleigh, NC 27601
(919) 909-6965