I Love NY Pizza

28 N Front St, Wilmington
(910) 762-7628

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Emily Walton

10/10 every time we stumble through this way 😂 always helpful at the front and the pizza is 🔥 when you need something in your stomach

Alexis Thurston

Love the pizza sucks you can’t eat inside anymore your options are bring it home or sit on the side wall with people walking by in the hot sun

Brandice Ward

Downtown, you can never go wrong here

Dennis Anikin

Great place, good prices, pizza really looks like NY style!

M. Aybenot

A staple of downtown Wilmington. This is a fantastic spot for a good slice after doing some bar hopping. Be patient though, there's bound to be a line.

Nakala Mitchell

Went today June 7th and right before I tried to order I observed the pizza thru the window before the cashier went to take order he walked away so I looked thru the window and the pizza was covered with flies they were just resting on the pizza and they were still selling it to kids!! Immediately I walked away angry because the amount of flies almost made me throw up and i really like their pizza I was going to report it to the health department Monday morning because I guarantee eggs was being laid! The cashier had no care in the world and kept serving it! Go to slice of life for safety if my comment gets deleted i will repost for other’s safety!!!

kindall walker

Rude older people working. I've order mushroom pizza for my 6 year old weekly if not multiple times a week. Today they said they weren't going to because they were busy. It's simple to throw mushroom on the slice before it goes back into he oven to reheat.

Lori McEnroe

Love this pizza. Best in Wilmington!!!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Deric Holman

Take out only and parking in the city can be difficult but the pizza is good almost like actual New York pizza

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Slice of Pepperoni & Sausage Pizza

Jessica Valentin

My son’s favorite pizza spot. Always delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Original NY Cheese Pizza, Delicious Pizza, Pepperoni Slice

jeremy Winquist

Awesome pizza ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Scholl

Great staff and great pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Slice

Tyler Jackson

I've been coming here for years and I definitely have to say the way that their dough and bread are there definitely hard to beat. I've tried all the places around Wilmington, and I always go back to this place because of their ingredients, and the way they're dough is the best around

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

genaro cerrato lopez

Not bad. This pizza was highly praised by a friend, and while it is pretty good, it did not live up to the expectations he built.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Beau Arceneaux

Always been my favorite Wilmington pizza spot, up until today. Something has gone wrong either ingredients are being swapped out for less expensive cheaper versions or people aren't putting the pieces together correctly I ordered two slices one of them came extremely burnt so they threw a cold piece in there for free. Margarita and barbecue chicken, never have I had such horrible Pizza especially from here. The cheese is definitely different, generic, not tasty at all. Hardly any chicken, BBQ sauce was off.
I hate to leave these comments because this is always been a treat to me to get pizza from here. Whatever y'all have changed you need to change it back

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Loading...