6 Best Italian Restaurants in Grand Island

“Amazing food and great service.“

“We chose New York Pizza to cater my son's graduation and they did an outstanding job! The staff is always friendly and the food was AMAZING! They packed it up for a beautiful display and all the guests had rave reviews. I'm so grateful for them and I will recommend them to anyone! Thank you, New York Pizza!“

“My sister and I stopped for dinner in GI expecting a long wait time given the amount of cars in the parking lot. The staff at the front desk greeted us when we walked in and sat us immediately. Our server, Sheri, was the most attentive and knowledgeable we’ve had at any restaurant hands-down. She knew the menu like she had been born with it, was as attentive as a personal butler, and was as friendly and personable as if she was our best friend we’d brought with us. I ordered the five cheese ziti al forno and my sister ordered ravioli carbonara with meatballs. We asked for the salad with several exclusions and all of our dishes came out perfect. Sheri checked in on us several times, refilling drinks and bringing more breadsticks (because what is an Olive Garden meal without breadsticks) and making sure we were enjoying our meals, spaced out enough that we didn’t feel ignored or annoyed. The facilities were clean and the music was the perfect volume where you could hear those around you but also enjoy the music. Highly recommend this location and if you’re stopping, ask for Sheri!“

“We chose New York Pizza to cater my son's graduation and they did an outstanding job! The staff is always friendly and the food was AMAZING! They packed it up for a beautiful display and all the guests had rave reviews. I'm so grateful for them and I will recommend them to anyone! Thank you, New York Pizza!“

“Fantastic Italian restaurant. The atmosphere is very relaxing and the service was great. Our waitress (Daysi) was very attentive to our drinks and friendly. She was also bilingual which was amazing.The food was amazing.“

“Went to Valentinos for Mother's Day brunch and they were very busy. The young lady at the register was working her butt off. She was literally running to try to keep up and smiling the entire time. Food was always full, hot and delicious. I can't say enough positive about our experience.“