17 Best Pizza Restaurants in Grand Island

“We chose New York Pizza to cater my son's graduation and they did an outstanding job! The staff is always friendly and the food was AMAZING! They packed it up for a beautiful display and all the guests had rave reviews. I'm so grateful for them and I will recommend them to anyone! Thank you, New York Pizza!“

“Alicia was great server took good care of me and my date last night pizza breadsticks were amazing as usual definitely would come here for a date night again“

“Shout out to my delivery dude who knew we were watching Dumb and Dumber by sound. 😂“

“Ordered carry out and it did not disappoint! Godfathers has some of the best pizza in town!“

“I love to eat here. They have everything any one can ask for. From breakfast to dinner or a late night snack. I always get their chicken tenders, they are amazing. My husband loves their burgers and pizza too. You can never go wrong with Casey's.“

“Fantastic Italian restaurant. The atmosphere is very relaxing and the service was great. Our waitress (Daysi) was very attentive to our drinks and friendly. She was also bilingual which was amazing.The food was amazing.“

“The size states 14 inch for a large. Nope, not true, just about 10 inches. The pizza is slimy and gooey, absolutely disgusting. Save your money, will never purchase again. I do not recommend this pizza.🤮“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Great food and great service every time! Everything was fresh and delicious, and the staff was friendly and welcoming. The chocolate chip cookie dessert is a must — warm, gooey, and absolutely amazing. We’ll definitely be back! 🍪🍕“

“Ordered piza for delivery tonight we usually pick up but both under the weather. It was here on time and delicious. The delivery drive was very friendly.“

“My second favorite Casey's. However, they're complicated with getting people in and out. They had two people working at 2:30 on a Saturday. It was busy. Only one was checking people out. Not sure what the other guy was doing, but too bad he didn't help. The person was overwhelmed with customers. I think a manager should've been there. It would've helped.“

“Went to Valentinos for Mother's Day brunch and they were very busy. The young lady at the register was working her butt off. She was literally running to try to keep up and smiling the entire time. Food was always full, hot and delicious. I can't say enough positive about our experience.“

“We chose New York Pizza to cater my son's graduation and they did an outstanding job! The staff is always friendly and the food was AMAZING! They packed it up for a beautiful display and all the guests had rave reviews. I'm so grateful for them and I will recommend them to anyone! Thank you, New York Pizza!“

“Looks from the outside are deceiving. But the inside is worth the stop good service and great food. Enjoyed the stop!“

“The person taking our order came across very rude, everyone looked like they hated being there. Only plus size was the pizza was good.

Edit: The manager jade reached out and completely fixed the situation, she is a one and million manager who knows customer service and bringing the customer back! Everyone should follow jades example. Thank you so much Jade for making it right!“

“Trystan and Michael B are top notch employees. I hope anyone who comes by gets helped by them. Food was hot, fresh, and cooked exact to order. Prices were spot on and the app rewards make it worth it when paying for a big group. Inside is clean: floors, tables and utensils. The AC was nice on this hot day. Service was fast. I couldnt have been happier with the visit I had with my big family tonight.“