12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Grand Island

“We ordered for the first time today and really enjoyed your pizza. I lived in NYC for 10 years and I have eaten NYC style pizza all over the US. I don't care how much Yanks, Mets, Jets and Giants gear you got on your walls, it don't make you a NYC pizza joint. Your pizza was the best NYC style pizza I've had since leaving NYC in 2011... we will definitely be ordering again, thank you! 10⭐️“

“This place is definitely a hidden gem and I would recommend yo anyone passing through Grand Island, Nebraska. It's 16 mins from the I-80 but we'll worth the time. The service from Kari was excellent and the food was really good. My sister and I were originally intrigued by the place because the menu used olelo Hawaii (Hawaiian language) and being Kanaka Oiwi (native Hawaiian) we wondered how a restaurant in the middle of Nebraska used olelo Hawaii. The atmosphere was fun and chill and the vibe suggested that a surfer owned the place. It was a good place I'd visit again. The pizza was delicious (we created a personal vegetarian) and the wings and garlic mushrooms were ono (delicious). Kari, our server, suggested a local sour and a laget from a local brewing company in Lincoln ( I believe) called Zipline Brewing Co. We tried the Pickle Time Lager which was actually really good.“

“Shout out to the crew on S Locust. Thank you for helping me win the bet.
Reviewer's: i bet I could get a pizza delivered in a random location before the guys got the food on the grill. Husband said they'd never deliver to a place with no address. 15 minutes later I dropped 2 pizzas and a 2 liter of Pepsi down on the picnic table and yelled, "I win!"
You guys are awesome for taking up the challenge and having fun with it. Well played!“

“Stopped in for dinner while visiting the area. Quickly seated at a nicely appointed table and were attended to promptly by our waitress. Ordered our entrées and received delicious freshly baked rolls to hold us over until our meals arrived. Do yourself a favor and definitely get the oil for the bread when offered! So incredibly delicious, with little red pepper flakes, and was the perfect addition to the rolls; we nearly liked the plates that oil was so good! Hubby had Lasagna, while I had the Manicoti; both served piping hot and were delicious!The only negative to share is every time a customer entered/exited via the front door, an arctic blast of freezing cold air swept in and we were in direct line of the chill it brought. Considered asking to be moved to another table, but we stayed where we were. Just a side note for future patrons to take into consideration if they're sensitive to the cold. We will definitely be back next time we drive through.“

“So I did carry out and I went to the store right after I ordered my pizza so I knew I was gonna have to wait which is fine. I pulled up to the window and Striker helped me( sorry if I didn’t spell his name right). May I just say he was the nicest person ever. He came outside and let me know ever step of what was going on. 100% will be going back. Did call the manager to let her know that he was amazing and that what he is doing is amazing and to keep up the hard work.“

“Top notch! I love Pizza Ranch wherever I go. Grand Island is the 116th different location the Legendary Pizza Ranch Guest ever visited.“

“Ordered carry out and it did not disappoint! Godfathers has some of the best pizza in town!“

“Patrick has to be hands down the best delivery driver I’ve seen in my 20 years of living here. He alone is why I’m leaving this review. Have had dominos pry too many times in life ? but my experience with him instantly made me pull my phone and leave a review! They should have him training the drivers! Just knows how to do his job with a smile on his face!“

“This is where I fuels my car and buy my coffee.. they have the best coffee that money can buy but recently they installed tire air machine it is very irritating the machine works sometimes sometimes not like today I fuel and go to the air to inflate I pay money and doesn't work...late for work. Air should be perfect every time..not about the money but time .“

“My second favorite Casey's. However, they're complicated with getting people in and out. They had two people working at 2:30 on a Saturday. It was busy. Only one was checking people out. Not sure what the other guy was doing, but too bad he didn't help. The person was overwhelmed with customers. I think a manager should've been there. It would've helped.“