7 Best Sandwich Shops in Grand Island

“I was struggling to decide what I wanted for lunch when Jasmin M. stepped in and helped me choose. She made my sub with impressive speed and efficiency, all while working alone. She was friendly, helpful, and made the whole experience a great one. She definitely deserves recognition for going above and beyond. Employee of the year“

“Okay serious note, im picky and get a completely custom sandwitch. Idk his last name but BEN dark curly hair. Give that man a raise. The ratios of all my veggies was perfect and i didnt have to ask for less or extra at all, perfect amount of mayo, strong amount of meat and cheese. GIVE BEN A RAISE!!!!!“

“Just so u guys know. For the ones working on monday Oct. 23 at 730pm off of south locust i give you guys a 5 star + plus... because of the menu i had the monster foot long and that s.o.b was amazing... thank u for letting me try that! Good sandwich and i like the positive vibes i got from each of u. I ordered the 3 ultimate bmts but instead replaced one with the monster. Good decision.“

“I've been eating at Jimmy johns for years now and today 8/17/26 @1pm was the best sandwich yet. They definitely understood the assignment. Plus I like everyone that works there at the Grand island Ne south Locust location & they no me by name.Aiden is always super friendly and polite 😀“

“Everything was great except for the employee standing at the cash register eating ice out of a Styrofoam cup with her fingers for 5 minutes before going back to the line. Hope there's a hand washing sink back there, and that she made use of it 🥴 pretty gross to leave *hoping* for that outcome.“

“Favorite sandwich shop in town. I’ve been here 10+ times since the store opened. I love the quality of the meat and the breads. I’ve only done pick up orders never eaten in the restaurant. Staff at the register is typically uninterested or rude.“

“A little worried about it being in a gas station with no reviews but it’s a nice clean place, professional employees and carbonara sandwich came out out fast crunchy and loaded so I’m super happy. Even stayed around to eat in their eating area.“