Papa Jay's Pizzeria
$ • Pizza Book a table: 7:00 PM 7:15 PM 7:30 PM MoreAbout Papa Jay's Pizzeria
Customers' Favorites
Pepperoni Special Pizza
Teriyaki Steak Tip Sub
Fried Dough Ball Bites
BBQ Roast Beef Sub
John's BBQ Burger
Mozzarella Sticks
Spinocoli Pizza
Boneless Wings
Chicken Wings
Shaved Steak
Papa Jay's Pizzeria Reviews
193 ratings
Share your opinion about Papa Jay's Pizzeria
Love Papa Jays- they are fast, great fresh sandwiches and always deliver. Highly recommend.
Amazing pizza, some of the best Hawaiin we have had, in particular. Tater skins are awesome. Not really space to eat there, but amazing takeout location. Highly recommend.
the girl working is friendly and i enjoyed
my slice
my slice
Hours
| Monday | 9:30AM - 11PM |
| Tuesday | 9:30AM - 11PM |
| Wednesday | 9:30AM - 11PM |
| Thursday | 9:30AM - 11PM |
| Friday | 9:30AM - 11PM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 11PM |
| Sunday | 10AM - 11PM |
Papa Jay's Pizzeria offers delicious pizza and great service, according to a customer from MA who ordered 9 pizzas for a gathering. The pizzeria is also noted for its rib-eye steak and cheese sub, which a customer described as one of the best they've had in a long time, with perfectly melted cheese mixed in with the shaved steak. Another customer praised the teriyaki steak tip sub and garlic roll as the best they've had in five states. A local resident considers it the best pizza in the Rochester area, highlighting the "dank" cheese and "amazing" fried dough bites.
Some customers feel the pizza is good but could be better, mentioning that while the dough and cheese are great, the sauce was a little bland. They found that using the sauce from the mozzarella sticks made the pizza taste much better. The hamburgers and ham sandwiches are also highlighted as really good, making them go-to orders. The onion rings and fries are noted as tasty, though some customers believe they would be better if picked up directly instead of through delivery services. Overall, Papa Jay's is appreciated for its solid offerings and friendly service, making customers eager to continue ordering from them.