11 Best Pizza Restaurants near Hinsdale

“Always a great meal ! Tried the ziti tonight and it was amazing !!! 5 stars !“

“Absolutely love this place—it’s hands down one of our favorite pizza spots in the area. Everything is excellent, no matter what you order. Some of our family favorites include the classic cheese or pepperoni pizza, the chicken and eggplant parmesan grinders, personal cheese pizzas for the kids, and their baklava for dessert.

The staff is incredibly friendly, and you can often see the owners working alongside their team, taking real pride in the quality of their food. From pizza to grinders, pasta, and salads, everything is top-notch. Highly recommend stopping in for some great food!

Vegetarian options: Plenty of veggie options on pizza or grinders

Kid-friendliness: Pizza and pasta are always a hit with the kids!“

“We sat in the space off on the right which was a little quieter than the bar side and was excellent for the two of us. The pizza was fantastic, the wine recommendations were spot on, and the staff was knowledgable, kind, and caring. Would recommend in a heartbeat and wish I could go more often! Well done, Martocci's - glad you're here in Brattleboro. :)“

“I really love their pizza which is why I keep going back but their customer service is awful. every time I go in there's like 5 employees standing around and they don't even acknowledge me.. then when they do they act like im bothering them.. eye rolls, aloof attitude.. I thought it was just me so I've never complained but my boyfriend just reported the same thing“

“Hillside pizza literally saved our wedding this past weekend. When our family was hit with covid the week before our wedding we had to pivot and make a plan b. If we didn’t cancel our planned catering by a certain time we would risk losing a large amount of money if we ends up with covid. We decided to call hillside which was close to our venue and see if they could help. Daniel was awesome and super accommodating. We were able to order 39 various pizzas all of which were awesome and salad for 105 people. They also accommodated a few of our guests with gluten and dairy intolerance by creating special meals for them. They were able to give us until 8 pm the night before to cancel as we continued to covid test to be sure we were clear. When the pizza arrived it was sent with hot bags tongs for the salad which was so fresh and delicious. All of the dressings and pizzas came with awesome labels. The guests were very satisfied and the food was delicious! Thank you so very much Daniel and hillside pizza!!“

“Either I’m starving or this is the BEST pizza ever!“

“first time going here on June 15, 2024 and I will be going back. this place was so delicious!!!!! I recommend eating here“

“We came for lunch because my mom wanted pizza and beer, and I wasn't execting much to be honest. But right when we walked in we were greeted by the friendly lady at the to-go counter and she seated us quickly. The bartender was our server and he was also very friendly, and a quick walker. It's nice to get a server who hustles even when it's not too busy. He recommended a good beer, we ordered, and our food came out quickly. It looked and tasted great. Our server stopped by our table several times to check on us. I was happy with our experience, we would come again.“

“First time customer for this location, and it was a very good experience. Phone order went smoothly, delivery was prompt and friendly, and the food order, just right. We’re very pleased.“

“This gas station and convenience store offers a well-rounded experience with a variety of options for customers. Their drink selection is extensive, and they stock a good range of craft beer and wine. The attached pizza/deli restaurant is a standout feature, serving delicious pizza, grinders, appetizers, and more, making it a convenient stop for a quick meal. Their morning breakfast sandwiches are particularly enjoyable—fresh and a great way to start the day.

The gas prices can be a bit of a downside, especially for mid-grade and premium fuels, which are usually higher than those found in Keene/Brat. However, the regular gas prices are more comparable to other locations.

One charming aspect of this place is the morning crowd of old-timers enjoying their coffee and catching up, adding a touch of local flavor and community feel.

For tobacco enthusiasts, they have a decent selection of cigarettes and cigars.

Overall, this is a solid spot for grabbing a quick meal, picking up drinks, and fueling up, though it's worth keeping an eye on gas prices, especially for higher-grade fuel.“

“Large Pepperoni, bacon, sausage, black olives.Large spinach, peppers, onions, black olives.Big hit with the kids. A little pricey but not garbage pizza. They didn't skimp on the toppings. Cheese was good quality. Veggies were fresh. Meats aren't too salty“