Smithville Peanut Butter Company
615 E Moss Mill Rd #55, Smithville
(609) 652-3928
Menu
Photos
+31 photos
+30 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
They have a variety of fresh peanut butter flavors. Butterscotch peanut butter is one of their best. Also good are chocolate peanut butter, and honey roasted peanut butter. They also have some cookies, and drinks. The shop is in a village (Historic Smithville) of other shops, all the buildings brought in from different parts of NJ. There is a train, a carousel, a pond with a foot bridge. Its a nice place to visit if you are in the area.
I’ve gone here for a couple years alway great peanut butter. Love the small batch’s they have. Cookies are always great. Though a couple weeks ago I went with my mom and sister. We entered and the older woman behind the counter while nice just reeked of smoke. It is unfortunately displeasing and we didn’t want any cookies if she was going to be handling them. There was no one else in the store either and the smell was strong when we got to counter. I don’t like leaving...
The staff were friendly, the butterscotch peanut butter is next-level amazing. The shop smelled of baking cookies. We bought a chocolate chip cookie to eat later and it was so delicious that I was sad I only bought one. I highly recommend making time to stop here when visiting Smithville Shoppes!
You May Also Like
The Smithville Inn - 1 N New York Rd
![]()
American, Venues & Event Spaces, Bar, Vegetarian, New American
Costello's Pizzeria & Wings - 615 E Moss Mill Rd
![]()
Pizza, Chicken Wings, Vegetarian, Pet Friendly
Lakeside Grill - 615 E Moss Mill Rd
![]()
American, Wraps, Vegetarian, Pet Friendly