Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop

Very unique flavors all made in house. Highlights were the cheesecake guava and the earl grey.

Our favorite family ice cream spot! They have the best (most unique) flavors around and the cutest touches for kids. Our girls love the mermaid and princess sprinkles! Totally worth the wait every time. A must-visit for a sweet family treat!

Best ice cream in town

I enjoyed my experience with this ice cream shop, I would say out of a lot of places that serve ice cream in Asbury park I can actually say this is the only ice cream shop that doesn’t make me feel sick from the sugar, the ice cream is made perfectly balanced, the flavors actually taste how they are when you read the label. Like it doesn’t taste like pure sugar or overwhelming milk it tasted what they are suppose to taste like. I am definitely coming back!

Up there with the best ice cream in the area. Would definitely come back and try other flavors

My favorite

Ice cream is incredible, but for the price the scoops are incredibly small.

100000/10. Still dreaming about this ice cream.

Have loved Milk Sugar Love in Jersey City for years. So glad they have this second location is Asbury! Ice cream was delicious and staff were super friendly and helpful.

Portion sizes are really small, especially for the price, but the ice cream was absolutely exceptional- especially if you like a malted flavor in hard ice cream!

Fantastic staff
Fantastic owner
Fantastic ice cream. Most likely unlike anything you've ever had.
Worth any drive and return visits

First time going to this place and I would honestly go back. $13 for 3 scoops and one topping sounds pricey but for the quality of product I will for sure treat myself to this. I love that you can get samples of the ice cream before trying. They sell coffee! All the flavors are unique and I can’t wait to go back and try more of the flavors. I really like the flavors I got. Matcha flavor was so very good!!! Big fan of also how they sell ice cream sandwiches in freezer to go! The service was friendly, plenty of seating, and the flavors I got were so good and the brownie topping were huge and soft!

Honestly very good ice cream. And I was so excited to see it opened up down the street. I had the malted cookie and my wife had the blueberry crunch. Both were really good.

I just could not possibly justify going to this place ever again. $6 for literally one scoop is absurd. Maybe it makes sense in Jersey city. But we’re only a few miles from Beach Plum in Bradley and Hoffmans in Spring Lake. It’s a bit ridiculous that a brand new ice cream shop, across the street from a Title I high school is charging double (not exaggerating) the price of Hoffman’s, arguably one of the most celebrated ice cream shops in the Northeast and the price leader in the area.

I wish them the best.

Delicious, different, chill and 😎 cool

So happy to have this new gem in town. Great location and the staff is very welcoming and professional. Lots of really unique offerings- it's obvious that a lot of thought goes into the creations-it's not just the same old same old. You can tell that they use top notch ingredients and that they take pride in their offerings. I tried the matcha cookie ice cream and salted caramel. Both insanely delicious. They also offer really unique toppings. Well priced and really cute place. Tables and a counter as well as grab and go pre-packed pints. Definitely stop in after hitting the beach and/or Galley (it's right next door) I'd post a picture but the ice cream didn't stand a chance!