Mutiny BBQ Company

808 Fifth Avenue, Asbury Park
(732) 366-9985

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

The Beast from the East Sandwich
Brisket Chili and Fried Pickles
Pulled Pork Sandwich Special
Sliced Brisket Combo Plate
Pulled Pork Combo Plate
Smoke Fried Wings - 12
Mac and Cheese - pt
Cornbread Casserole
Texas Style Sausage
Homemade Pickles

Menu

Combo Plates
Sliced Brisket Combo Plate
Half a pound of sliced brisket, your choice of two sides, pickles, onions, and a roll.
Chopped Brisket Combo Plate
Half a pound of chopped brisket, your choice of two sides, pickles, onions, and a roll.
Pulled Pork Combo Plate
Half a pound of pulled pork, your choice of two sides, pickles, onions, and a roll.
Half Rack Ribs Combo Plate
Half a rack of St. Louis ribs (5-6 bones on average), your choice of two sides, pickles, onions, and a roll.
Texas Style Sausage Combo Plate
Two Texas style sausage links, your choice of two sides, pickles, onions, and a roll.

Sandwiches
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Our Eastern Carolina style pulled pork piled high on a huge "Big Marty" Martin's Potato Roll and topped with housemade vinegar cole slaw and housemade pickles. Finished with a drizzle of our house signature BBQ sauce. Served with a side of handcut french fries.
Brisket Sandwich
Our signature brisket is piled high on a "Big Marty" Martin's Potato Roll and topped with housemade pickles and pickled red onions. Finished with a drizzle of our signature BBQ sauce. Served with a side of handcut fries.
The Beast from the East Sandwich
A tribute to one of Asbury Park's favorite sons, the late great professional wrestling superstar Bam Bam Bigelow, this sandwich features a quarter pound of pulled pork, a quarter pound of chopped brisket, a whole Texas sausage link, cole slaw, pickles, pickled red onion, and our house BBQ sauce piled high on a seeded Martin's "Big Marty" Potato Roll. It doesn't come with a side, but trust us. You won't need one.
Smoke Fried Chicken Thigh Sandwich
Boneless, skinless chicken thigh dusted with house dry rub, smoked, and then deep fried. Tossed in your choice of wing sauce or house dry rub and topped with housemade pickles. Served on a potato bun with a side of handcut fries.

Specials
Brunswick Stew - Pt.
Brunswick Stew is a cold weather dish native to Virginia, the Carolinas, and Georgia. It's traditionally made with wild-caught small game, but since we couldn't find any squirrels or rabbits we decided to use our delicious pulled pork. San Marzano tomatoes, diced potatoes, and corn round out this hearty and filling meal.
Brunswick Stew - Qt.
Brunswick Stew is a cold weather dish native to Virginia, the Carolinas, and Georgia. It's traditionally made with wild-caught small game, but since we couldn't find any squirrels or rabbits we decided to use our delicious pulled pork. San Marzano tomatoes, diced potatoes, and corn round out this hearty and filling meal.

Meats
Sliced Brisket - Quarter Pound
The Holy Grail of BBQ. Dusted with a simple rub of kosher salt and course ground black pepper and injected with a secret flavor booster, our brisket is sliced to order. Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and one Martin's Potato Roll.
Sliced Brisket - Half Pound
The Holy Grail of BBQ. Dusted with a simple rub of kosher salt and course ground black pepper and injected with a secret flavor booster, our brisket is sliced to order. Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and two Martin's Potato Rolls.
Sliced Brisket - 3/4 Pound
The Holy Grail of BBQ. Dusted with a simple rub of kosher salt and course ground black pepper and injected with a secret flavor booster, our brisket is sliced to order. Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and three Martin's Potato Rolls.
Sliced Brisket - One Pound
The Holy Grail of BBQ. Dusted with a simple rub of kosher salt and course ground black pepper and injected with a secret flavor booster, our brisket is sliced to order. Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and four Martin's Potato Rolls.
Chopped Brisket - Quarter Pound
Our signature brisket is roughly chopped and tossed with our housemade BBQ sauce. Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and one Martin's Potato Roll.
Chopped Brisket - Half Pound
Our signature brisket is roughly chopped and tossed with our housemade BBQ sauce. Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and two Martin's Potato Rolls.
Chopped Brisket - 3/4 Pound
Our signature brisket is roughly chopped and tossed with our housemade BBQ sauce. Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and three Martin's Potato Rolls.
Chopped Brisket - One Pound
Our signature brisket is roughly chopped and tossed with our housemade BBQ sauce. Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and four Martin's Potato Rolls.
Pulled Pork - Quarter Pound
Bone-in pork butt is coated in house dry rub and injected with a secret flavor booster. Hand-pulled and finished with our Eastern Carolina-inspired house hot vinegar. Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and one Martin's Potato Roll.
Pulled Pork - Half Pound
Bone-in pork butt is coated in house dry rub and injected with a secret flavor booster. Hand-pulled and finished with our Eastern Carolina-inspired house hot vinegar. Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and two Martin's Potato Rolls.
Pulled Pork - 3/4 Pound
Bone-in pork butt is coated in house dry rub and injected with a secret flavor booster. Hand-pulled and finished with our Eastern Carolina-inspired house hot vinegar. Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and three Martin's Potato Rolls.
Pulled Pork - One Pound
Bone-in pork butt is coated in house dry rub and injected with a secret flavor booster. Hand-pulled and finished with our Eastern Carolina-inspired house hot vinegar. Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and four Martin's Potato Rolls.
St. Louis Ribs - Half Rack
St. Louis-cut pork spare ribs coated in our house dry rub and smoked for several hours before being basted in Mutiny's signature BBQ sauce.
Smoke Fried Wings - 12
Jumbo wings dry-brined overnight and smoked before being finished with a quick deep fry to ensure perfect crunch. Available in our housemade Buffalo or honey BBQ sauce. Served with bleu cheese and celery.
Smoke Fried Wings - 6
Jumbo wings dry-brined overnight and smoked before being finished with a quick deep fry to ensure perfect crunch. Available in our housemade Buffalo or honey BBQ sauce. Served with bleu cheese and celery.
Texas Style Sausage
Often referred to as a "hot gut" or "hot link," these peppery, European-inspired links come to us from Southside Market in the heart of Central Texas. Served with housemade pickles, pickled red onion, and a Martin's Potato Roll.

Sides
Cornbread Casserole
Our warm, scoopable cornbread pudding is baked fresh daily.
Fries
Our hand cut Austin fries are a specialty of the house. Tossed in a secret "magic" seasoning. Servred with a side of our Mutiny Sauce, a Cajun Dijon aioli.
Mac and Cheese - 1/2 Pint
Smoked Beans - 1/2 Pint
Collard Greens - 1/2 Pint
Texas Carolina Potato Salad - 1/2 Pint
Vinegar Cole Slaw - 1/2 Pint
Pickles - 1/2 Pint
Mac and Cheese - Pint
Smoked Beans - Pint
Collard Greens - Pint
Texas Carolina Potato Salad - Pint
Vinegar Cole Slaw - Pint
Pickles - Pint
Mac and Cheese - Quart
Smoked Beans - Quart
Collard Greens - Quart
Texas Carolina Potato Salad - Quart
Vinegar Cole Slaw - Quart
Pickles - Quart

Desserts
Bourbon Foster Banana Pudding
Banana pudding is essential to the BBQ eating experience at great smokehouses throughout Texas. We add a bit of New Orleans flair to ours with bourbon-brouleéd cinnamon and brown sugar bananas. It's topped (of course) with Nilla Wafer cookies.
Whoopie Pies
Rich, dark chocolate cakes with a delicious whipped marshmallow filling sandwiched between them and then dusted with powdered sugar. Two per order.

Extras
Side of Blue Cheese
Extra Rolls - Two
Extra Onions
Bottled Sauce
An 8-ounce squeeze bottle of our signature housemade BBQ sauce.
Martin's Potato Rolls (12)

Half Pint Sides
Mac and Cheese - 1/2 Pt.
Our spin on a classic home-cooked side. Freshly-grated sharp cheddar and gruyere, pasta shells, and a Cheez-It cracker crust.
Smoked Beans - 1/2 Pt.
These are not your average, overly sweetened baked beans. Red kidney beans are tossed with sautéed onions and peppers, dusted with house dry rub, and tossed in a signature sauce.
Collard Greens - 1/2 Pt.
A traditional take on the southern staple. Freshly chopped greens, slow-braised in a garlic, onion, and red pepper chicken stock with chopped bacon. Finished with our housemade vinegar sauce.
Texas Carolina Potato Salad - 1/2 Pt.
A classic Texas BBQ joint style potato salad with flavors of the Carolinas. Russet potatoes, diced egg, relish, and pimentos in a mustard dressing.
Vinegar Cole Slaw - 1/2 Pt.
Our house slaw has no mayo and was designed to be a fresh, tangy complement to our rich BBQ. Confetti cabbage and carrots tossed lightly in an apple cider and dijon vinaigrette.
House Pickles - 1/2 Pt.
These housemade garlic and dill pickles pair perfectly with our craft-smoked meats. Order extra, they are highly addictive and store well.

Pint Sides
Mac and Cheese - Pt.
Our spin on a classic home-cooked side. Freshly-grated sharp cheddar and gruyere, pasta shells, and a Cheez-It cracker crust.
Smoked Beans - Pt.
These are not your average, overly sweetened baked beans. Red kidney beans are tossed with sautéed onions and peppers, dusted with house dry rub, and tossed in a signature sauce.
Collard Greens - Pt.
A traditional take on the southern staple. Freshly chopped greens, slow-braised in a garlic, onion, and red pepper chicken stock with chopped bacon. Finished with our housemade vinegar sauce.
Texas Carolina Potato Salad - Pt.
A classic Texas BBQ joint style potato salad with flavors of the Carolinas. Russet potatoes, diced egg, relish, and pimentos in a mustard dressing.
Vinegar Cole Slaw - Pt.
Our house slaw has no mayo and was designed to be a fresh, tangy complement to our rich BBQ. Confetti cabbage and carrots tossed lightly in an apple cider and dijon vinaigrette.

Quart Sides
Mac and Cheese - Qt.
Our spin on a classic home-cooked side. Freshly-grated sharp cheddar and gruyere, pasta shells, and a Cheez-It cracker crust.
Collard Greens - Qt.
A traditional take on the southern staple. Freshly chopped greens, slow-braised in a garlic, onion, and red pepper chicken stock with chopped bacon. Finished with our housemade vinegar sauce.
Texas Carolina Potato Salad - Qt.
A classic Texas BBQ joint style potato salad with flavors of the Carolinas. Russet potatoes, diced egg, relish, and pimentos in a mustard dressing.
Vinegar Cole Slaw - Qt.
Our house slaw has no mayo and was designed to be a fresh, tangy complement to our rich BBQ. Confetti cabbage and carrots tossed lightly in an apple cider and dijon vinaigrette.

Beverages
Poland Spring
Topo Chico Mineral Water
Boylan Orange Soda
Boylan Root Beer
Coke
Diet Coke
Diet Coke
Boylan Grape Soda
Tropicana Apple Juice
Liquid Death Berry
Liquid Death Lime

Beverages
Poland Spring
Topo Chico Mineral Water
Boylan Orange Soda
Boylan Root Beer
Coke
Diet Coke
Boylan Grape Soda
Tropicana Apple Juice
Liquid Death Berry
Liquid Death Lime
Boylan's Ginger Ale
Joe Lemonade
Joe Unsweetened Tea
Boylan Creme Soda
Joe Sweet Tea
Sprite

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+39 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+38 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Unfortunately I did not find this to live up to the original location at all. The macaroni had clearly been out and reheated all day, I couldn’t order a plate of bbq, the sandwich I got had dry bread and the menu is small and a touch off beat. Great service, and I love the original restaurant I just did not feel like I got what I was looking for out of bbq here.
August 2026
Absolutely iconic bbq spot. Staff was super helpful in coaching us on how much to order for “family style” platter. I will be recommending this place to anyone who is traveling to the Jersey Shore this summer!
June 2026
Neighborhood BBQ joint. Very friendly staff. Delicious brisket! Nice outdoor backyard— like hanging out at your neighbor’s house for BBQ— but, they have a smoker! The cornbread side was really good!
May 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Georgies - 810 Fifth Avenue
Gay Bar, Karaoke
Cameo Love Market - 1213 Main Street
Grocery, Cheese Shops, Cafe, Specialty Food
Bridal Cleanse - 805 4th Ave
Juice

Mutiny BBQ Company

808 Fifth Avenue, Asbury Park, NJ 07712
(732) 366-9985