Tim McLoone's Supper Club

Terrible service, food and management. We're locals who've been supporting Tim for years, but after receiving harassing emails from some of the staff, we won't be returning. Creepy & extremely unprofessional.

Absolutely the worst establishment. The management, especially the corporate management is over the top rude and they do not care about their customers. We have been loyal customers since 2020, and they completely destroyed an event we held there. Instead of apologizing, we received a series of nasty emails from both the company liaison as well as the COO. Instead of rectifying the situation, we were told that the points we had accumulated were gone and that we were not allowed to return. We are currently owed to 40 dollars in McLoone's reward points that we plan to redeem. One way or another we will get our points, is it illegal to steal from people. Clearly they were very upset about my husband's negative review which was left in honesty. It's unfortunate that the mcloones restaurants have gotten SO bad, but I imagine it will only get worse over the summer.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

This is an event hall. Booked reservations on Open Table, when we arrived it was "Stephanie's Bat mitzva" Why would you allow people to book a table at a private venue? We ended up with no where to eat bc it was a weekend in the summer, and everyone else was booked. All McLoone's establishments are starting to crash and burn. New management perhaps, possibly new people at corporate, no idea. They are no longer concerned with the quality of the service or food, only with the dollar signs. Disappointing but typical for McLoone's now unfortunately. Do better.

Had my wedding here in March and the experience was amazing! The food the venue the service and the team were all great!

My son, Jeremy, and daughter in law, Lindsay, just got married and had both the wedding and reception at McLoones Super Club. They were blessed to have such an awesome venue for both the wedding and reception. The evening/night atmosphere overlooking the Asbury Park boardwalk, beach and Convention Hall is both beautiful and unique. The staff was pleasant, accommodating and professional. The food and service was excellent and offered flexibility in chooses. The outdoor balcony was used to setup the cocktail hour appetizers. Thank you to the McLoone Family and their staff for an awesome celebration.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had our wedding here a few weeks ago and it was an absolutely amazing experience. The venue worked with us on every aspect of our wedding and was there to help us the entire way. On the day of, all of the DOCs were so helpful to guide everything and I felt like I did not need to worry about a single thing. The day was everything I dreamed of and the food was absolutely amazing. Literally everyone I talked to raved abut how amazing the food was. And at the end of the day we had so many people coming to us to tell us that it was such an impressive venue and asking how we found it. We could not be happier with the service they provided and we are so happy we found them!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I’ve been coming to McLoone's Pier House for about two years now, mainly for the Tuesday karaoke nights, which I’ve always enjoyed. Unfortunately, my experience on April 14, 2026 completely changed how I view this place.
Around 8:45 PM, I went to order food and drinks, and the bartender’s attitude was immediately off. He responded in a rude and dismissive tone and even rolled his eyes at me while I was placing my order. When I calmly asked if there was any inconvenience, his behavior didn’t improve—it just felt more uncomfortable.
What made the situation worse is that I was the only Black customer there at the time, and I couldn’t ignore the difference in how he treated others. He appeared charming, friendly, and engaged with other guests, but with me, it was the complete opposite. It felt discriminatory, whether intentional or not.
I’ve supported this place consistently for years, so this was especially disappointing. No customer should feel singled out or disrespected like that. I truly hope management takes this seriously, and I would honestly advise minorities to be cautious with the bartender working Tuesday nights, especially around that time, until something is addressed.
Did you like this feature?

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

Great spot for events

We had our wedding there a few weeks ago. Simply the best. The food, the service, the ambience, everything was perfect. Our guests were so impressed and we could not imagine one thing that could have been better or done differently. And the Event Coordinators team is amazing. Aly, Vicki and Libby were patient and provided expert guidance every step of the way. We cannot speak more highly of them. If you’re planning a wedding or any kind of special occasion event, you owe it to yourself to check out the Supper Club. You will not be disappointed!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amazing bartender on 3/16 for HH made our anniversary so wonderful! Give her a raise! Best Moscow Mules!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Had our wedding for 140 people in October 2025 and it was perfect. Libby and Victoria were exceptionally easy to work with. Communication was excellent, and everything that was communicated was well executed. Food was good, band was experienced working with the venue's techs, bartenders were attentive. Everyone had a great time.

Really 10/10 experience, would get married here again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We attended a performance of Pat Benatar tribute band All Fired Up (which was outstanding) and had drinks and dinner. It was on the 2nd floor. A beautiful room with booths and tables. We ordered appetizers which we split amongst us. Drinks were very good. Our waiter was outstanding.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We had our daughter Brittany's bridal shower here! Absolutely fabulous., from the service to the view to the food ! Highly recommend them . Very accommodating so lovely to work with ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

We had our wedding here in September 2025 & we can't recommend them enough! The food and service was amazing. Multiple guests continue to rave about the food quality, quantity, and overall service during our wedding. Libby, Aly, and Victoria were all amazing in ensuring our day and planning process went smoothly and are very detail oriented.

We chose Tim McLoone’s as our wedding venue and we had such an amazing experience, our dream wedding. Everything turned out absolutely perfect, and we can’t thank their team enough for their attention to detail. Everything looked so beautiful, even better than I could have imagined, and of course the food was amazing, as always. Every time we are in the area we always make it a point to come back. Thank you for making our wedding day go so smoothly, it was the perfect day!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5