1st Cup Coffee

96 First Avenue, Atlantic Highlands
(732) 291-2000

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Pumpkin Crumb Muffin
Iced Latte

Menu

Hot
Latte
Also available decaf let us know.
Drip Brew Dark Roast
Drip Brew Decaf
Truly the best decaf you will ever try.
Drip Brew Medium Roast
Individual Pour Over
Cappuccino
Also available decaf let us know.
Americano
Espresso with hot water-same great espresso taste but less intense. Also available decaf let us know.
Caffe Mocha
Espresso and steamed hot chocolate.Mmmm. Also available decaflet us know.
Caffe Borgia
Espresso, steamed hot chocolate,orange zest and nutmeg. Also available decaf let us know.
Chai Latte
Espresso
Smooth and intense one of italy's gifts to the world. Also available decaf let us know.
Twinings Tea
Let us know your choice english breakfast, english breakfast decaf, Green tea, wild berry, peppermint.
Matcha Japanese Tea
The rich green tea from Japan.
Matcha Latte
Hot Chocolate

Cold
Cold Brew (16 oz)
Sinfully smooth and rich. Also available in decaf let us know.
1st Cup Shake (16 oz)
Blended cold brew and frozen banana. Also available decaf let us know.
Iced Latte (16 oz)
Does anything say summer more. Also available decaf let us know.
Iced Matcha (16 oz)
Iced Matcha Latte (16 oz)
House Ice Tea (16 oz)
Iced Chai (16 oz)

Smoothies
Berry Banana (16 oz)
Strawberry, blueberry, and banana. Our smoothies are made from frozen fruit and your choice of liquid base. No syrups, powders, or chemicals.
The Classic (16 oz)
Strawberries, banana. Our smoothies are made from frozen fruit and your choice of liquid base. No syrups, powders, or chemicals.
Pineapple Cocolata (16 oz)
Pineapple, banana, coconut flakes. Our smoothies are made from frozen fruit and your choice of liquid base. No syrups, powders, or chemicals.
Tropica (16 oz)
Mango, orange pineapple. Our smoothies are made from frozen fruit and your choice of liquid base. No syrups, powders, or chemicals.

Eats
Oatmeal Cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Banana Chocolate Chip Bread
Pumpkin Bread
Blueberry Muffin
Glenda's Chocolate Chip Cookies
Glutten-free.
Jonesbar
Pb and j, banana, chocolate chip, peanut butter, chocolate, peanutbutter, coconut, and mango. let us know your preference, locally made.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+43 photos
Photo credit: foursquare
+42 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Best cafe in town. The Sumatra Dark roast is my favorite and they have toppings like cinnamon and cocoa powder, as well as honey and agave.
Also, you must try to homemade muffins. (The banana chocolate chip is my favorite.)
I’m a local and I come here every weekend because it’s so great.
They also do live music events which is awesome.
October 2026
Great spot for your caffeine fix. I was down in Atlantic Highlands area and was in need of some coffee. The barista was friendly and professional. I just ordered my usual cold brew. Very satisfying. Give them a visit!
September 2026
A MUST!! This is the sweetest, simple coffee shop with the most lovely staff. They are always so welcoming, will explain their seasonal menu, they allow customization for shakes, coffees and teas. Cafe is easily accessible for those walking, biking or driving by, street parking is always available. Their baked goods are from another local business, I've tried the various muffins (pumpkin, zucchini, blueberry etc) all have been delicious, as well as the oatmeal Raisin and...
December 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Nicholas Creamery - 84 First Avenue
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Ice Cream, Vegan
STRADA - 91 First Avenue
Italian, Pizza
Kunya Siam Thai - 99 First Avenue
Thai, Asian, Vegetarian

1st Cup Coffee

96 First Avenue, Atlantic Highlands, NJ 07716
(732) 291-2000