Yet another great bakery one of the few left in the area. It's well worth the trip. A little out of the way but the town parking lot across the street always has spots.
Hutch Martin
This is an iconic bakery on the Jersey Shore well worth your time & taste buds. You will certainly find many choices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Robbin Ann
Shipping charges were outrageous preventing me from reordering
Bess Frankel
Mueller’s Bakery gave us the wedding cake of our dreams. For our beach-themed cake, we wanted something unique, with a sense of humor, but still a bit romantic. So we sent them reference photos of my and my husband’s real-life bathing suits, and on top of our delicious two-tier cake, our toppers were two beach chairs and our little bathing suits made of fondant. (The joke was that our topper bride and groom ditched the cake and ran off skinny dipping.) They even put little footprints in the cookie-crumble sand on the top of the cake. We couldn’t have been more thrilled with how it turned out, and how it tasted!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Christopher Denotaris
Best buttercream birthday cake. ? and of course, crumb
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Irene Insignares
They have a great variety.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bob S.
Been thinking about the best places to eat in Monmouth and Ocean County recently and any list without Mueller's is completely invalid. In my opinion at least. People (capital L) Love the crumbcake and it doesn't even make my top list for the best bakery around: the donuts are top notch, apple turnovers are a must, and the range of danishes are out of this world. My father in law from North Carolina insists on this as a stop to get their bear claws. Go early, go often - Bay Head's finest!
Michael I.
Awesome ! Bakery goods excellent I have never been disappointed in their bakery products.
Ellen Kruse
ordered crumb cake online & it was hard when received.
Food: 1
Kelly Bischoff
Our family has been a big fan of Mueller's for years so decided to use them for our wedding last September. Katie was a joy to work with for the tasting, and they captured our request perfectly, not to mention delicious!
Great bakery, always fresh and delicious. Our favorite place to visit when we are down the shore.
Orlando Mansur, Jr.
A charming local establishment, offering a delightful array of baked goods and coffee that generally impress. Their selection of cookies, a major highlight, ranges from classic to inventive. While most of their cookies receive high marks for flavor and texture, those adorned with frosting tend to fall short, lacking the same appeal as their unfrosted counterparts.The bakery also serves a nice breakfast selection, which holds its own in terms of quality and taste. The options are varied enough to suit different preferences, and each baked good is prepared with care, ensuring a satisfying morning meal. Delectable danishes and turnovers to name a few.However, the service at Mueller's Bakery, particularly when ordering, could use some improvement. The interactions tend to be somewhat dry and lack the warmth you might expect in a cozy bakery setting. This aspect, while not detrimental to the overall experience, does leave room for enhancement.In summary, Mueller's Bakery is a solid choice for anyone seeking quality baked goods and a pleasant breakfast option. Their coffee pairs wonderfully with their selection of treats, making it a go-to spot for both locals and visitors. With a bit more attention to the customer service experience, this bakery could truly excel.Kid-friendliness: Kids Love It. Lots of options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Everything
Maryellen Small
I love Muellers. The cakes and baked goods are excellent. The staff is always pleasant. Highly recommend. My literal only note would be to please get boxes that fit your custom cakes. I've ordered several a year for the past few years and they never fit in the box causing them almost always to get dinged up in transit. Other than that absolutely the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aaron Dirodrico
This has been a long time favorite bakery of my family and mine this was actually the first time actually going there in person myself everything was great the only one complained that I had was the fact that they had a white cake with buttercream frosting ... The whole tray was cut slices of this cake unfortunately I don't know how long that cake was there for but when I got home after dinner to eat the cake the cake was hard as a rock there was a very small piece on the inside of the cake that was soft and tasted good but I can't recommend these sliced cakes as they sit there all day in the are just completely destroys the quality of the cake. Other than that the place is immaculate the atmosphere is great the service was phenomenal I would just recommend either cutting nose and wrapping them so they're are air tight or slicing what is needed when ordered. I can't be the only person that will most likely never buy that again due to the quality. Other than that I would still recommend this bakery
Yet another great bakery one of the few left in the area. It's well worth the trip. A little out of the way but the town parking lot across the street always has spots.
This is an iconic bakery on the Jersey Shore well worth your time & taste buds. You will certainly find many choices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Shipping charges were outrageous preventing me from reordering
Mueller’s Bakery gave us the wedding cake of our dreams. For our beach-themed cake, we wanted something unique, with a sense of humor, but still a bit romantic. So we sent them reference photos of my and my husband’s real-life bathing suits, and on top of our delicious two-tier cake, our toppers were two beach chairs and our little bathing suits made of fondant. (The joke was that our topper bride and groom ditched the cake and ran off skinny dipping.) They even put little footprints in the cookie-crumble sand on the top of the cake. We couldn’t have been more thrilled with how it turned out, and how it tasted!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Best buttercream birthday cake. ? and of course, crumb
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
They have a great variety.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Been thinking about the best places to eat in Monmouth and Ocean County recently and any list without Mueller's is completely invalid. In my opinion at least. People (capital L) Love the crumbcake and it doesn't even make my top list for the best bakery around: the donuts are top notch, apple turnovers are a must, and the range of danishes are out of this world. My father in law from North Carolina insists on this as a stop to get their bear claws. Go early, go often - Bay Head's finest!
Awesome ! Bakery goods excellent I have never been disappointed in their bakery products.
ordered crumb cake online & it was hard when received.
Food: 1
Our family has been a big fan of Mueller's for years so decided to use them for our wedding last September. Katie was a joy to work with for the tasting, and they captured our request perfectly, not to mention delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Quaint shop. Fresh baked
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Apple
Great bakery, always fresh and delicious. Our favorite place to visit when we are down the shore.
A charming local establishment, offering a delightful array of baked goods and coffee that generally impress. Their selection of cookies, a major highlight, ranges from classic to inventive. While most of their cookies receive high marks for flavor and texture, those adorned with frosting tend to fall short, lacking the same appeal as their unfrosted counterparts.The bakery also serves a nice breakfast selection, which holds its own in terms of quality and taste. The options are varied enough to suit different preferences, and each baked good is prepared with care, ensuring a satisfying morning meal. Delectable danishes and turnovers to name a few.However, the service at Mueller's Bakery, particularly when ordering, could use some improvement. The interactions tend to be somewhat dry and lack the warmth you might expect in a cozy bakery setting. This aspect, while not detrimental to the overall experience, does leave room for enhancement.In summary, Mueller's Bakery is a solid choice for anyone seeking quality baked goods and a pleasant breakfast option. Their coffee pairs wonderfully with their selection of treats, making it a go-to spot for both locals and visitors. With a bit more attention to the customer service experience, this bakery could truly excel.Kid-friendliness: Kids Love It. Lots of options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Everything
I love Muellers. The cakes and baked goods are excellent. The staff is always pleasant. Highly recommend. My literal only note would be to please get boxes that fit your custom cakes. I've ordered several a year for the past few years and they never fit in the box causing them almost always to get dinged up in transit. Other than that absolutely the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This has been a long time favorite bakery of my family and mine this was actually the first time actually going there in person myself everything was great the only one complained that I had was the fact that they had a white cake with buttercream frosting ... The whole tray was cut slices of this cake unfortunately I don't know how long that cake was there for but when I got home after dinner to eat the cake the cake was hard as a rock there was a very small piece on the inside of the cake that was soft and tasted good but I can't recommend these sliced cakes as they sit there all day in the are just completely destroys the quality of the cake. Other than that the place is immaculate the atmosphere is great the service was phenomenal I would just recommend either cutting nose and wrapping them so they're are air tight or slicing what is needed when ordered. I can't be the only person that will most likely never buy that again due to the quality. Other than that I would still recommend this bakery
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5