Mueller's Bakery
80 Bridge Avenue, Bay Head
(732) 892-0442
Customers' Favorites
Blueberry Pound Cake
Go Bay Head Cookies
Irish Soda Bread
Blueberry Crumb
Raspberry Crumb
Sunflower Cake
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Everything
Hard Rolls
Menu
Photos
+75 photos
+74 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We hired Mueller’s to create our clients wedding cake! They exceeded our expectations!!! The coloring, the floral placement and when the cake slide after delivery, they had all hands on deck to fix it and make it whole again! I can’t wait to work with again in the future!!! Xx Fitz and Fab Event Planning
I’ve gone to this bakery my whole life. Now that I’m watching what I eat I don’t want to gain weight so stop myself from going but it’s very difficult. I’m actually going soon to get a coffee. Let’s see if I can control myself. lol.
You May Also Like
Charlies of Bay Head - 72 Bridge Avenue
![]()
American, Bar, New American, Vegetarian
Playa Bowls - 68 Bridge Avenue
![]()
Health Food, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Acai Bowls
Staff was super friendly and pleasant, as ours helped me pick out for an older acquaintance.
Prices are very reasonable, and the selection is very nice.
With a small seating area inside and benches out front to enjoy your special goodies you picked out for yourself, before you bringing the remainder home to the rest of the family to devour.
Lines can get long so be patient as they tend to each customer...