Mueller's Bakery

80 Bridge Ave, Bay Head
(732) 892-0442

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Blueberry Pound Cake

Irish Soda Bread

Blueberry Crumb

Raspberry Crumb

Sunflower Cake

Birthday Cake

Wedding Cake

Everything

Hard Rolls

Crumb Cake

Photos

+75 photos

+74 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Muellersbakery

Recent Reviews

We hired Mueller’s to create our clients wedding cake! They exceeded our expectations!!! The coloring, the floral placement and when the cake slide after delivery, they had all hands on deck to fix it and make it whole again! I can’t wait to work with again in the future!!! Xx Fitz and Fab Event Planning

August 2026

I’ve gone to this bakery my whole life. Now that I’m watching what I eat I don’t want to gain weight so stop myself from going but it’s very difficult. I’m actually going soon to get a coffee. Let’s see if I can control myself. lol.

August 2026

I will start off by saying i LOVE this place. However, the last 3x in a row I have visited, all within 2 months, I have left with such a bad taste in my mouth due to the extremely poor customer service from 1 worker, Vanessa, in particular. Once with me, rushing me and huffing and puffing because I did not get my order to her quick enough item by item, and 2x with other customers. Seeing someone speak down to and get nasty with an elderly man who is clearly confused and overwhelmed....that...

June 2026

More Reviews

Restaurants in Bay Head, NJ

Mueller's Bakery

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Mueller's Bakery