Mueller's Bakery

80 Bridge Ave, Bay Head
(732) 892-0442

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Blueberry Pound Cake

Irish Soda Bread

Blueberry Crumb

Raspberry Crumb

Sunflower Cake

Birthday Cake

Wedding Cake

Everything

Hard Rolls

Crumb Cake

Photos

+75 photos

+74 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Muellersbakery

Recent Reviews

I will start off by saying i LOVE this place. However, the last 3x in a row I have visited, all within 2 months, I have left with such a bad taste in my mouth due to the extremely poor customer service from 1 worker, Vanessa, in particular. Once with me, rushing me and huffing and puffing because I did not get my order to her quick enough item by item, and 2x with other customers. Seeing someone speak down to and get nasty with an elderly man who is clearly confused and overwhelmed....that...

June 2026

We couldn’t have been happier with Mueller’s Bakery for our wedding cake and favors. Katie and the whole team were so easy to work with from start to finish and made the entire process feel fun and completely stress-free. The tasting was also such a highlight of wedding planning!

Our wedding cake turned out beautifully and tasted amazing. We got so many compliments on it, and it felt like part of the decor before we finally cut into it. We...

June 2026

Hands down the best bakery in the area. The crumb cake is outstanding. My favorite is the blueberry with powdered sugar on top. The apple cake is a second favorite. I like that it tastes fresh and not canned fruit topping. Also don't sleep on the cookies either. The butter cookies are the best I've ever had. They're very buttery and they hold up so they won't crumble in the first bite. They can be a little pricey but you're paying for quality. And service...

May 2026

More Reviews

Restaurants in Bay Head, NJ

Mueller's Bakery

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Mueller's Bakery