Mueller's Bakery

80 Bridge Ave, Bay Head
(732) 892-0442

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Blueberry Pound Cake

Irish Soda Bread

Blueberry Crumb

Sunflower Cake

Birthday Cake

Wedding Cake

Irish Soda

Crumb Cake

Everything

Crumb Bun

Photos

+69 photos

+68 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Muellersbakery

Recent Reviews

I wanna thank the organization for making my father's 100th birthday cake. Thanks for delivery it to the shrimp box. The people who absolutely loved the cake were in the food business and the cake was outstanding.

July 2025

All the food was awesome from the donuts and the bagels, but don't get me started on the crumb cake! Every bite was to die for! But besides the food they provided absolutely amazing service! There was a beautiful young lady in front helped me right away and kept the over crowding place moving. The atmosphere is okay, the place is cute but the only issue is the amount of people crowding this place on the week of 4th of July. Another reason why I give the atmosphere a 3/5 is...

July 2025

What a step back in time when there were bakeries like this that served homemade breads, rolls, specialty cakes, donuts, variety if ethnic pastries, vegan bakery and gluten free bakery , hot beverages. Also variety of take home and premade gift-able bags. Now Muellers is the only TRUE BAKERY IN A 30 mile radius. And it so worth the trip. When you see the long line of customers each spending a large amout of money and two full bags of items, you know the food is AWESOME. Lovely...

January 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Bay Head, NJ

Mueller's Bakery

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Mueller's Bakery