Mueller's Bakery

80 Bridge Ave, Bay Head
(732) 892-0442

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Blueberry Pound Cake

Irish Soda Bread

Blueberry Crumb

Raspberry Crumb

Sunflower Cake

Birthday Cake

Wedding Cake

Everything

Hard Rolls

Crumb Cake

Photos

+71 photos

+70 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Muellersbakery

Recent Reviews

You better come here with a sweet tooth and a few extra bucks than your used to spending. Can't selection of sweet treats but not without the price tag. Great place overall, personal opinion is its jam packed and the ordering system is a number by ticket. When I was there, may not always be the case I couldn't hear nor visually see what number they were on. That and the price for a cookie ($4 buck and above) seems to be a little high. (Personal opinion)

Other...

October 2025

Update to Below review on crumbcake: Lately not sure what's happened to their best-ever brownies, but the size has experienced some shrinkflation! They appear to be about half the size of what they once were. Not only is the actual size smaller, but the icing on top is about 1/2 as thick. Maybe I just hit it on a bad day. (this is Sept 2025).

Crumb cake lover? Mueller's has the BEST ever. Their birthday cakes and other bakery items are all freshly...

September 2025

Drove down from Bergen County the other day. Let me tell you, it was worth the trip. The coffee cake just melts in your mouth. Many other delights in this bakery. The brownies looked amazing. They also have a nice selection of gluten free items

September 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Bay Head, NJ

Mueller's Bakery

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Mueller's Bakery