Bagel Shack
Customers' Favorites
Lox Ona Bagel w Onion Tomato & Cream Cheese
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Bacon Egg and Cheese
French Toast Bagel
Plain Bagel
Sandwich
Menu
Mains
-
Bagel with Cream Cheese $1.75
-
Bagel with Specialty Cream Cheese $3.50
-
Bagel with Butter $1.50
-
Lox on a Bagel with Onion, Tomato, and Cream Cheese $9.50
-
Bagel with Peanut Butter and Jelly $3.25
-
Bagel with Cinnamon Sugar Butter $1.75
Breakfast
-
Hash Browns $1.50
-
Omelette $8.00
3 eggs, meat, and cheese.
Pastries
-
Cinnamon Sticks $2.99
-
Apple Turnover $2.99
-
Cheese Danish $2.99
-
Cinnamon Bun $3.99
-
Raspberry Danish $2.99
Chips
-
Bagel Chips $4.00
Lunch and Dinner Sandwiches
-
Cheese Steak Sandwich $7.50
-
Steak Sandwich $6.99
-
Chicken Steak Sandwich $6.99
-
Hamburger Sandwich $6.99
-
Hot Dog Sandwich $3.99
-
Chicken Cheese Steak Sandwich $7.50
-
Cheeseburger Sandwich $7.50
Lunch and Dinner
-
Chicken Salad $6.99
-
Chicken Fingers $6.99
-
Chicken Caesar Wrap $8.99
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, croutons, and dressing.
-
Chicken Ranch $8.99
-
BLT $5.99
-
Roast Beef $7.99
-
Clab $8.50
Served with lettuce, tomato, Swiss, and onions.
-
Tuna Salad $6.99
-
Chicken Parm $8.99
-
Chicken Quesadilla $8.99
Salads
-
Caesar Salad $6.99
Sides
-
Fries $1.99
-
Mozzarella Sticks $4.99
-
Onion Rings $2.99
Authentic Mexican
-
Burritos (12") $8.99
Served with 12" flour tortilla, rice, beans, melted monterey cheese, lettuce, and tomatoes.
-
Quesadilla $8.99
Green peppers, onions, side lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream, and salsa.
-
Veggie Burrito (12") $8.99
Served with 12" flour tortilla, green peppers, onion, mushrooms, broccoli, spinach, yellow squash, and monterey cheese.
-
Soft Tacos $8.99
Corn tortilla with cilantro, onions, and Carlos sauce.
Beverages
-
Tea $1.50
-
Hot Chocolate $1.50
-
Nesquik Chocolate Milk $2.00
-
Water (Spring) $2.00
-
Red Bull $3.00
Recent Reviews
Love this place but my family and I are cracking up over their AI generated menu… the worm peppers… the perfectly circular meat… just take a picture of your own food!
July 2026
Best bagels on the island, worth any wait. I recommend getting there early or waiting until lunch time. All of their bagels are fresh and my personal favorite is the cinnamon raisin. Their customization are also incredible.
March 2026
Really good bagels! I got an everything bagel with chive cream cheese, and my husband got a plain bagel with bacon, egg, and cheese. The bagels were fresh and had a nice chewy texture, and the chive cream cheese had great flavor. The bacon, egg, and cheese was warm, satisfying, and not greasy. Overall, everything tasted great, and I’d definitely come back. It’s such a small, cute little bagel shop
October 2025