Outstanding food as well as service! I had a few questions so I decided to call and mind you it was prime time for lunch around 12:30pm on a Thursday. My call was missed so I figure okay I'll call back in a few because they're understandably busy with the lunch rush. Less than a minute later I get a call back from Maria and she apologized for missing my call(that's rare these days that a business cares enough to return a missed call) she answered all of my questions in a patient tone(also rare these days) so helpful, kind and welcoming. My husband ordered the Ruthies Scooter with broccoli rabe added & I got the Butchie Boy on rye...EVERYTHING WAS DELICIOUS as well as FRESH!! I haven't had Mastriano's in over 20yrs since moving out of the area and it's just as good as I remember. I'll definitely be back many times and I obviously highly recommend anyone and everyone else to give it a try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leo Licciardello
I love grabbing lunch here! Fantastic food, great staff and conveniently located!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
jorge martinez
Easily the best place in the area with amazing customer service due to their great staff….
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nathan Olynyk
It’s hard to find a regular sandwich in the Montclair area that isn’t $20… this place has been exactly what I was looking for. the sandwiches are truly picture perfect and the folks that work there are so lovely. couldn’t ask for anything more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ken A.
Everything is good . From the sandwiches to the meats . Have an awesome catering menu.
Ken A.
The new owners are doing a great job! We ordered our usual #5 ,#31 and a chicken soup . Everything tasted great . I'm glad the new owners kept the same menu and ingredients. I hope they still have a catering menu. Love the penne vodka .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
kingbiscuit28
I have bought 3 briskets here. Each one was really well marbled and you can get special cuts like the point/nose and they trim it really well before you buy it. I smoked 2 of them and even with my amateur skill level they turned out really good and juicy. Their hot pastrami sandwiches are also solid. Nice staff and good service as well.
Annie K.
The best subs!!! Friendly staff and delivery drivers, and they use Boar's Head meats and cheeses... so very yummy!!!
Jennifer L.
Great sandwiches. The macaroni salad is my absolute favorite! The people are so nice and have great customer service. Love that we have them here in town.
Nicholas Petine
Delicious everything!Sandwiches, Prepared Foods, Meats, Great Dinner Packages.... this place has it all.Fresh Stromboli is a personal favorite of mine, whenever we have a party or get together.Great place with great food and great people. Highly recommended!
New Jersey has a reputation for good delis, but this beats any I have ever been to and I’ve lived here my entire life. The sandwiches are worth every penny and have beyond generous portions. Folks are as nice as can be also. Calling ahead certainly helps as it is a popular spot (for good reason!)
Vivian Jao
Amazing customer service. I called at closing time and asked if it was possible for them to get in a special order for the next day. They made sure the cut was exactly what I needed and then they stayed late to call around to source it. It was packed and ready for me when I went to pick it up. Cannot ask for better service than that.
Vivian J.
Amazing customer service. I called at closing time and asked if it was possible for them to get in a special order for the next day. They made sure the cut was exactly what I needed and then they stayed late to call around to source it. It was packed and ready for me when I went to pick it up. Cannot ask for better service than that.
Heidi M.
My husband and I drove 20 minutes to get a sandwich based on the reviews. We walked in and there was not a single person physically in the store. Before we were even able to order we were told the wait would be 15-20 minutes because they were 'backed up with phone orders'. I own a business and have always served and attended to the people standing physically in front of me. We did not order 10 sandwiches in which case I would have understood. We were there for 1-2 cold subs. In my opinion poor customer service. We walked out. I have never written a yelp review r er but this was upsetting.
Kim C.
This tasted so so good. It had chicken cutlet, mozzarella, roasted red pepper, hot pepper, prosciutto on a roll. I added my own balsamic glaze which made it worthy of a *chefs kiss*. Recommend bringing cash to the place and checking out their variety of meats, perogies, and italian desserts. Didn't have a chance to try it out but I'll be going there again at some point, this sandwich was amazing.
Outstanding food as well as service! I had a few questions so I decided to call and mind you it was prime time for lunch around 12:30pm on a Thursday. My call was missed so I figure okay I'll call back in a few because they're understandably busy with the lunch rush. Less than a minute later I get a call back from Maria and she apologized for missing my call(that's rare these days that a business cares enough to return a missed call) she answered all of my questions in a patient tone(also rare these days) so helpful, kind and welcoming. My husband ordered the Ruthies Scooter with broccoli rabe added & I got the Butchie Boy on rye...EVERYTHING WAS DELICIOUS as well as FRESH!! I haven't had Mastriano's in over 20yrs since moving out of the area and it's just as good as I remember. I'll definitely be back many times and I obviously highly recommend anyone and everyone else to give it a try.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love grabbing lunch here! Fantastic food, great staff and conveniently located!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Easily the best place in the area with amazing customer service due to their great staff….
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It’s hard to find a regular sandwich in the Montclair area that isn’t $20… this place has been exactly what I was looking for. the sandwiches are truly picture perfect and the folks that work there are so lovely. couldn’t ask for anything more.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything is good . From the sandwiches to the meats . Have an awesome catering menu.
The new owners are doing a great job! We ordered our usual #5 ,#31 and a chicken soup . Everything tasted great . I'm glad the new owners kept the same menu and ingredients. I hope they still have a catering menu. Love the penne vodka .
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have bought 3 briskets here. Each one was really well marbled and you can get special cuts like the point/nose and they trim it really well before you buy it. I smoked 2 of them and even with my amateur skill level they turned out really good and juicy. Their hot pastrami sandwiches are also solid. Nice staff and good service as well.
The best subs!!! Friendly staff and delivery drivers, and they use Boar's Head meats and cheeses... so very yummy!!!
Great sandwiches. The macaroni salad is my absolute favorite! The people are so nice and have great customer service. Love that we have them here in town.
Delicious everything!Sandwiches, Prepared Foods, Meats, Great Dinner Packages.... this place has it all.Fresh Stromboli is a personal favorite of mine, whenever we have a party or get together.Great place with great food and great people. Highly recommended!
Restaurantji Recommends
New Jersey has a reputation for good delis, but this beats any I have ever been to and I’ve lived here my entire life. The sandwiches are worth every penny and have beyond generous portions. Folks are as nice as can be also. Calling ahead certainly helps as it is a popular spot (for good reason!)
Amazing customer service. I called at closing time and asked if it was possible for them to get in a special order for the next day. They made sure the cut was exactly what I needed and then they stayed late to call around to source it. It was packed and ready for me when I went to pick it up. Cannot ask for better service than that.
Amazing customer service. I called at closing time and asked if it was possible for them to get in a special order for the next day. They made sure the cut was exactly what I needed and then they stayed late to call around to source it. It was packed and ready for me when I went to pick it up. Cannot ask for better service than that.
My husband and I drove 20 minutes to get a sandwich based on the reviews. We walked in and there was not a single person physically in the store. Before we were even able to order we were told the wait would be 15-20 minutes because they were 'backed up with phone orders'. I own a business and have always served and attended to the people standing physically in front of me. We did not order 10 sandwiches in which case I would have understood. We were there for 1-2 cold subs. In my opinion poor customer service. We walked out. I have never written a yelp review r er but this was upsetting.
This tasted so so good. It had chicken cutlet, mozzarella, roasted red pepper, hot pepper, prosciutto on a roll. I added my own balsamic glaze which made it worthy of a *chefs kiss*. Recommend bringing cash to the place and checking out their variety of meats, perogies, and italian desserts. Didn't have a chance to try it out but I'll be going there again at some point, this sandwich was amazing.