Reservoir Tavern
$$ • Italian, Pizza, VegetarianAbout Reservoir Tavern
Customers' Favorites
Chicken Franchise over Capellini
Stuffed Mushrooms Full
Half Sausage Well Done
Clam and Garlic Pizza
Stuffed Long Hots
Stuffed Artichoke
Shrimp Calabrese
Chicken Marsala
Bolognese Sauce
Slice of Pizza
Reservoir Tavern Reviews
338 ratings
Share your opinion about Reservoir Tavern
I highly recommend this restaurant.
Service and food are excellent.
Service and food are excellent.
Great place for lunch. Never disappointed 👍🏻
Have been to Reservoir twice this past week. First visit, ordered a plain cheese bar pie to go, and thought it was great. 2nd visit was this evening, and placed an order for 6 large pies to go. Order was placed in my brother's name, and when he made the call, he asked for 2 plain, 2 pepperoni, and 2 sausage pies. The person taking the order repeated back, "2 plain, 2 'roni, 2 sausage pies". What happened from that point is anyone's guess, as what I picked up was 2 plain, 2 pepperoni,...read full review
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Reservoir Tavern is known for its generous food portions and freshly prepared, wonderfully cooked meals. It is a family-run Italian establishment that has been in operation since 1936, making it a true Jersey gem. The restaurant is popular for its great food, including pizza, pasta, and fried clam strips that are not greasy at all. A large pizza pie, often ordered half plain and half sausage, is a favorite among guests. The staff, including the owner and longtime employees, create an authentic and welcoming atmosphere, with the hostess going out of her way to make guests feel at home. The fully stocked bar offers a good place to watch sports. Reservoir Tavern is busy, especially after 5 pm, so reservations are recommended. It is a great spot for families, dates, groups, and business meals. Although it gets crowded, visitors enjoy relaxing, having a great meal, and leaving happy. Overall, Reservoir Tavern offers excellent food, strong drinks, and a warm, friendly environment that has kept it a local favorite for nearly 80 years.