22 Best Pizza Restaurants near Branchville

“Decent pizza joint. We usually order the lunch specials for pickup. Orders are usually ready in 15 minutes. The chicken parm with fries is good. The meatballs on the meatball parm are too big for my liking, but my husband enjoys them. The pepperoni Stromboli is tasty but very greasy.“

“Arturo's food is delicious. The turkey panini is my favorite. The garlic knots are fresh and delicious. The pizza is cooked to perfection. Our family visits often and the menu offers a great variety for all of us. The owners are kind and personable and we highly recommend Arturo's.“

“Waitress/bartender was all alone except for one other worker serving tables occasionally. They did an awesome job serving tables with how busy it was tonight 8/6. I was not in a rush to go anywhere so I was patient with the service, as she had a packed house to deal with. Ordered the Flatbrook Wings and the Little Flatbrook Burger. The little burger is perfect if you don’t want to eat too much. They have a bigger version too which is 1/2 pound. It was cooked to a perfect Medium Rare and everything else was perfect. My second visit here. Worth it. Thank you, Flatbrook Tap House!“

“Last week I ordered pizza and salad for a surprise party today for my sister in Newton for 50 people. I asked for delivery between 12 and 12:15. They arrived at 12 on the dot. Sal helped me figure out what to order and it was perfect. Everyone was very happy and loved the delicious pizza. Price was reasonable. I am so happy! Throwing a surprise 60th birthday party in Newton NJ from Waipahu HI was stressful and Sal made it smooth. Highly recommend these folks and I send Sal and his team much warm aloha!!!“

“Fantastic food and dinner specials! Everything from pizza your way to full course dinners. Always dinner specials to please everyone. Homemade soups for the cold days, and great hot and cold sandwiches. Great salads and a couple desserts. Great staff and they deliver.“

“Our family ordered 2 pizzas. They were cooked perfectly and the toppings were fresh and delicious. I had the cavatelli and broccoli. The pasta was Al dente and the broccoli was not soggy. Our service was excellent. I'm sorry I didn't get the young lady's name.“

“I am never in a hurry when I order from Candy’s, they are so busy because their food is very good! The owners are very sweet and they never failed to deliver on a great meal. I’m very happy that they are in the area. Keep up the good work!Parking: It’s a huge parking lot, there’s always a space“

“Ordered two sandwich platters as a light lunch for the bridal parties before an evening wedding we held at a nearby venue. Jonathan was excellent to work with — polite, professional, accommodating. The platters were delivered precisely on time and were delicious. Sandwiches were made exactly to order and were fresh and flavorful. Highly recommended.“

“Was very please with my food. I built my own pizza with cauliflower crusted. I ordered a white pizza with spinach and grilled chicken. I was not disappointed. The crust was crispy and the flavor was great. Staff were friendly and over atmosphere was good! Prices weren't that bad either.I would definately recommend this place and will be returning.“

“I had the best meatballs today at the store! The sauce they have with it is delicious!! I never had a sauce as good. The pastrami sandwich is also super good. Will definitely be coming back all the time. The owners are so friendly and welcoming and serve you from their heart“

“Uncle Sal's Pizza in Sparta, NJ, is my go-to spot for a delicious meal every time. Their commitment to using fresh ingredients shines through in every bite, making their pizzas truly outstanding. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, the quality of their food remains consistently excellent.Moreover, the service at Uncle Sal's Pizza is second to none. Even when ordering takeout, the staff ensures that every detail is taken care of, from ensuring accurate orders to providing friendly and efficient service.If you're craving authentic, mouthwatering pizza made with fresh ingredients and accompanied by top-notch service, look no further than Uncle Sal's Pizza. They never disappoint!"“

“Celebrated our son's birthday there this past Saturday night. Was our family's first time there. He picked the restaurant. We all like to try new places.Boy we were glad he picked Bella Italia!!!From the moment we walked in, with cake in hand, to the moment we left with full bellys it was a pleasure.Our server, Carly, was friendly and fast. Our drinks were very well poured. All of our orders were 100% accurate. The food was AMAZING!!!!Every dish was delicious. Portions were a good size. Prices were surprisingly reasonable. Our cake was brought out to sing, whisked away and brought back perfectly sliced for us. I'm looking forward to dinning there again. Saw the bar area on our way out. Next visit will be in there. Looked nice. Have to check it out.Highly recommend dining here to anyone.“

“Just stumbled upon this restaurant on my way back to Pennsylvania. Thought it was going to be a regular pizzeria, turned out to be a nice restaurant. I enjoyed the pizza, better than any I've had in the Poconos. Nice waiters , nice place , nice variety on the menu . If I'm in the area I would stop by again .“

“Excellent all around convince store with VERY GOOD food! Pizza as well. Very generous portions. Delicious breakfast , lunch and dinner sandwiches plus more. Well worth the trip to this well located establishment. You won't be disappointed. Oh don't forget their numerous ice cream flavors in the spring and summer!“

“Really nice and clean location, everyone working was super friendly. The specialty slices are really good, I recommend the Buffalo chicken slice. The regular plain slice was nothing to write home about, (expected better on that, since I been to a few other locations). Good place to stop for lunch.Parking: Small lot“

“This local tavern seems to have transformed itself during the pandemic! The food is amazing! I was surprised at the prices however. We intended to stop in for a few beers and burgers, it was not a special night out but it wound up costing as much as if it were. The noise levels tend to get pretty high in the bar, so you may prefer to sit in the back dining area. Go and support locally owned establishments!“

“Experienced their food for the first time last night. Pizza, Chicken Parm, Penne Vodka & salad. Excellent! Enjoyed it so much ordered a Jersey Sloppy Joe today. Can't say enough. Food, service & atmosphere. Feel bad for those with less than desirable experiences. Give them a second chance. You will be pleased. “

“Amato's Pizza is absolutely fantastic. We knew their pizza was good, so we decided to order a wrap and a burger last night. My daughter said the wrap was one of the best she has ever had, and the Amato's Burger was absolutely fantastic, as well as cooked to perfection. When I called in the order they told me the driver was busy so it would be about 40 minutes, and the food arrived in exactly 20 minutes. The gentleman doing the delivery was beyond pleasant and polite. These are good people running a good local business. Please support them, and try that Amato's Burger.“

“Food is delicious and the inside is clean and cozy. A classic NJ pizza place vibe. Best spot for a quick lunch. The owners are so kind, great service. And the new Mexican menu is amazing just like the pizza is. Great food and better service. Highly recommend.“

“So hubby and I have now come here 4/5 times. It's become our Sunday after Church tradition. And pick up once lol (This has been broken up over time) The food is incredible! Things we've had and loved are the Sicilian slices, pepperoni, Penne vodka slice, plain slice, Margherita slice. We also loved the fried ravioli, Chicken Parm panini, Cheesesteak Panini, Ziti and Brocolli with Chicken. Penne and vodka sauce pasta. Chicken Florentine was ok, not my favorite but still good. Mozzarella sticks and wings delicious! Honestly love this place!! DELICIOUS FOOD!!“

“The food is always cooked to perfection whenever i order & the service is warm,friendly & inviting. I order from there weekly & am never disappointed from the quality of the items to the very generous pricing for everything on the menu & the wait time that is almost always pleasantly earlier then expected. The deliver driver with the painted finger nails is also always to my door in a reasonable time & without making my order look trashed & a very respectable young man. Would highly recommend this place if your ever in the area & down for a great slice or two !“

“I highly recommend coming into Villa Capri if you have any availability. Prices are amazing, food is always fresh and hot when served no matter if it’s pickup carry out or delivery. They always make sure you are left satisfied, and never unhappy with your order. It’s something you won’t regret.Parking: Multiple spots available, very big parking lot and never have to struggle finding a spot or walking far.Wheelchair accessibility: Much room in the dining room and near counter for there to be no problem with anyone in a wheelchair.“