50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Jefferson

“We stopped in to get a cheese pie on the way to the drive in and it was so good. Perfect ratio of cheese and bread. Some small shops have cheese sliding off but not this one! It was just done perfectly. Will be our go to when we go to the drive in!“

“Ordered the margarita pizza and it was horrible. Never had raw garlic on a pizza and the tomato was just clumped on and not even cut open. It was also burned and I ended up throwing it away. What a waste of 16. - never again“

“one of the best Calamari I've had, also Veal Sorento excellent. Huge portions. Definitely will be going back..Matty our server was great..“

“I highly recommend Anthony’s pizzeria and family restaurant. If you’re looking for delicious food friendly atmosphere great service Anthony’s place is it. It is the number one restaurant to go to and enjoy your dinner. Also they have the best pizza.“

“WOWSA! Thank you Jesus for bringing a great pizza place to Roxbury FINALLY! Having lived in Brooklyn and having missed our pizza tremendously since moving out here in 2013. We are SO happy and thrilled to have Mamma’s as our new pizza joint. DELICIOUS pizza! This is how it’s done Jersey!“

“There is a very good reason why they have so many 5 star reviews, the pizza and food is great,owners and staff are super friendly and you feel so welcome there! We follow a nj pizza facebook pace and will drive pretty far to try the recommended spots but a lot do not live up to the hype but this place does! If you like old school style pizza please try it you won't be disappointed“

“the new business here is better than all the previous combined . please note that the 1 star reviews are from when A&G was here, and their pizza was lame. Arturo’s is very good pizza i’m glad to have a local spot with good slices , finally.“

“We love Jimmy Tomato's. My husband and I are vegan and they will make all the Indian vegetarian pies vegan. The veggies are exceptionally good crisp and perfect. I can't stand what veggies past their prime. I will not eat and never go back. The freshness of the veggies is top notch. Be forewarned the Indian pies are very spicy! Kids love their traditional pies. I have had them as well and they are good Roman pizza pies.“

“Great little spot we came across after shopping at Costco. Currently undergoing a renovation, but service and food were excellent. Quick service, friendly staff. Worth a stop. Got a fantastic panini and calzone. Prices very reasonable. Great carrot cake.“

“The food here is always amazing. Ordered catering and pizza from here last couple parties i hosted. The staff are very friendly also.“

“3 kids all loving and asking for Kraves Pizza! Great salads & sandwiches& pasta too.“

“Everything’s absolutely amazing every time I go there. I’ll keep going back every weekend. The pasta is always cooked perfect the pizza is nice and light with the perfect sauce and crust. I tell everyone about this place.“

“I own a luncheonette right up the road from Dominick's and at the end of the day, after cooking all day, when I head home, I often stop for dinner. GREAT owner. And the food is good. I had a Sicilian slice tonight that was so good. Haven't had a good slice of Sicilian in a long time. The crust is amazing. Soft, THICK, yet light and crispy too!! Flavor also amazing. Also had a meatball on top of spaghetti all covered in sauce!! I honestly would have eaten the meatball if it had rolled off on the floor! Not just because how good it tastes, but because the place is VERY clean!!! 5 stars for sure!!“

“Have ordered from Anthony Francos many times and everything was delicious. their grilled chicken and vergetables is outstanding and my family orders it every time we cater. Great pizza, great eggplant. Have never had anything from them that was not the best! Love this place!“

“excellent food especially the pizza and deserts. Generous portions, and they give you extra items for FREE! Very friendly staff...an all-around great place to eat (reasonable prices too!).“

“Ordered form catering menu. Very happy. Food was delicious. Delivered on time definitely recommend for your catering needs.“

“Very nice and great food they are super friendly“

“just ordered a cheese pie, to go, and it is DELISH!!“

“My daughter and her friends had their secret Santa lunch at Vinny’s right before the holidays and everything was delicious!!! Also always had great friendly service then and when we frequently get take out“

“This restaurant is AMAZING!! The food is fantastic. Large portions and excellent sauces. The sandwiches are to die for and the chicken parmesan is superior. Highly recommend!!“

“We had my daughter's sweet 16 catered by RJ's. The food was absolutely delicious, I mean all of it. There wasn't one dish that wasn't amazing. Everyone at the party raced about the food. I highly recommend RJ's to cater your party“

“Terrific food and staff. The family specials are a huge hit in our house. Great pizza too.“

“My daughter recently moved to Rockaway and I live in Bergen County. It is the BEST pizza. Made exactly as ordered. Crust is unbelievably crisp and delicious. Honestly, I have not ordered a pizza around where I live since I’ve had yours!!“

“As recent transplants from Brooklyn my family and I have been on a quest to find a place that captures New York pizza.After trying out several local spots, we finally stumbled upon this gem.It is fresh and tastes great.This is NOT "Pizza By Alfredo" -this is "Alfredo's Pizza Cafe"!“

“Great pizza and salad !! Delivery was quick !“

“while visiting our daughter near Oak Ridge, I called and placed a take out for my wife , myself, daughter and 3 grandkids. I had the Chicken Parm dinner and my wife had a large Arugula salad. My 2 pieces of chicken were tender and delicious along with choice of pasta and fresh bread. My wife said the salad was excellent; very tasty and delicious. We will stop in again on future trips!“

“Let me say I am cooker and I don't eat out, I had a taste for pizza Joe's a place I've pass everyday for many years half chicken & half everything and like a 3 course meal I ate with a fork good it was that will be my only out eating recommended to all my eat outers.“

“My husband and I celebrated our daughter's baptism party at Brick46 and it was INCREDIBLE. Our families are still talking about how delicious the food was and how amazing the staff was! We could not have asked for a better day and cannot thank Brick46 enough!“

“First time there last night after a recommendation, I think the wood fired pizza was the best I’ve ever had in almost 70 years. The thin crust was crisp but not burnt, the sauce was exceptional and it had the right amount of cheese. The onions and sausage on my half were excellent. If you like thin crust pizza, i don’t think you can beat it. This is now my default pizza.“

“We recently had our Cross Country banquet and the food was from Anthony Franco’s. It was delicious! The kids devoured the pizza and the salad was very fresh. Thank you so much!“

“The food here is outstanding & delicious! You must try the Sicilian Grandma's Pizza. The crust was amazing as is how they make a Sicilian slice of pizza. It's the right balance of crust and fresh ingredients without it being overpowered with dough. The salad we had was delicious too. Everything so far we had here is just phenomenal as is the customer service, staff & owner. Definitely go and check it out!“

“Thank you, George and staff Always aiming to make things right.“

“Really great pizza! Nice folks, too! Made my day.“

“I slept on this place for 4 years. I moved to the area 4 years ago and I never gave it a shot. I went every where else in the area including another place called Tjs. Recently one of my colleagues ordered a Pie from TJs. I was skeptical. I was wrong. It was fantastic. The sauce on the pie is something in itself different. Would highly recommend to anyone looking for pizza in the North Morris County/West Milford area.“

“Definitely a hidden gem. Came in on a whim because I saw good reviews and was on the hunt for a good slice to go. There were several pizza options in the display and ready to order which I love about a pizza spot. I ordered a Sicilian sausage/red pepper, pepperoni hot honey and a white slice. I would have stayed to eat at one of the few small tables but the baby was in the car. The pizza looked so amazing I ate some right in the parking lot it did not disappoint. The crust on the Sicilians was perfect and flavor was delicious. White pie was also simple and perfect. Can’t wait to try the cheese!

It was great to meet and interact directly with the owner, Paul. He explained how he bought the business from his parents and has been in his family for decades with roots in Brooklyn and Italy. He even threw in a free cheese slice because he knew I was a new customer! Nice guy and love to see the passion for a small family business. In my short time there, Monday afternoon, several people came in to order to sit and for takeout which said to me they have a good customer base which is a good sign.

Moving to Roxbury from Bergen County a few years ago we still haven’t quite settled on our favorite pizza spot yet. I’d say this is in the running for our favorites and we will be back!!

Vegetarian options: The owner seemed he would be very accommodating“

“Used this restaurant for catering. Everyone raved about food. Absolutely delicious and nothing left afterwards. I will definitely go here first for our next party and I do recommend for others. The delivery was promptly on time. The trays were setup up quickly. Food can be the most stressful part of a party. Everything was so easy and I am completely thankful.“

“So my husband and I went here for a dinner date night the other night. We have gotten take out pizza before but never dine-in. We were seated and our waitress, Isabella, was amazing. When we got bread for the table there was more than enough butter pats included in the basket, which seems like a small detail but it’s a pet peeve when u get half a baguette and not nearly enough butter and have to keep asking for more. We love calamari but I have not had it in years because I am allergic to shellfish (developed later in life) and restaurants always fry the calamari in the same oil as shellfish since it is seafood. My husband ordered it for himself but asked if they fried it in the same oil as shrimp. Isabella started that they did but they had no problem frying it in another fryer this time as they have 3. I actually broke down crying and thanked her profusely as no restaurant has ever offered to do that. I then got to have the most delicious and melt in your mouth calamari I have ever had in my life with no reaction. I ordered a Stromboli and extra dipping sauce. I was not expecting the HUGE bowl of sauce I got (pictured). All food was amazing. Isabella was amazing.“

“Amazing food. Very friendly and great people. Highly recommend.“

“The best in the county! Great service!! A must!!“

“Awesome food & great service!! ❤️“

“Absolutely love it here! We come very often and always enjoy.“

“ordered a tomato pie and Italian sub, the pizza was fantastic and the sub had fresh quality meats and the roll was terrific. I would highly recommend this place to any one who enjoys authentic Italian food. Nice job.“

“I truly am so excited about this restaurant. Me and my fiancé moved over a year ago and we kept trying pizza places and kept getting disappointed. I saw a post about this place and was skeptical because of all of our previous experiences with food in this area. PAISANOS DID NOT DISAPPOINT. This is the best take out in this area hands down. Thank you so much for putting so much love in your food.“

“Have been dealing with Delizia for well over 10 years now…chicken Francaise is out of this world and $1.00 a slice for pizza isn’t too bad at all for a quick snack !“

“It was amazing they give you a genororous big slice and a hand full of peperoni. The service was great the owner a very holsome man i am defenitly going to recomend him to my friendo and try the chikenwings they were nice and crisp. I Will defenitly come again also need a good pasta for a party go here trust me also fast “

“Best pizza, great service, and affordable pricing. We love Denville Pizza!!“

“We had the most amazing catering from La Gratella. We had 6 different dishes and it was all good. The people at our get together were raving about how great everything was. I highly recommend.“

“loved it! thank you. Exactly what I wanted and tasted great.“

“8-28-24
Ordered two pies and Sweet BBQ chicken bites.
Everything was hot and ready for pickup when I arrived.
Tasted fantastic. Best Domino’s location in the area!
Most of all the gentleman that handled my order was the nicest I’ve had the pleasure of interacting with. Just wish I got his name. Hopefully he will read this. Wonderful experience“

“Pepperoni pizza is a flavorful masterpiece, with a perfect balance of toppings on a deliciously crispy crust. The service is friendly and efficient, making every visit a pleasure. Whether you're a local or a visitor, this pizzeria is a must-try for authentic Italian pizza lovers.“