Cape May Peanut Butter Co.
516 Carpenters Ln, Cape May
(609) 898-4444
Customers' Favorites
Peanut Butter Malted Milk Balls
Jalapeno Peach Pecan Preserves
Peanut Butter & Chocolate
Peanut Butter Cannoli
Peanut Butter Cup Pie
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Fresh Baked Goods
Natural Sunflower
Butter Scotch
Honey Roast
Nut Butters
Butter Scotch
Our butterscotch peanut butter is made with roasted peanuts and butterscotch pieces. Try spreading this on top of a piece of pound cake for a tasty snack. Ingredients: dry roasted peanuts, butterscotch drops, brown sugar, natural flavor, soybean oil. Serving size - two tablespoons. 8 oz - 0.80 lbs., 16 oz - (1.25 lb), 32 oz - 2.45 lbs. Choose from several freshly ground varieties of delicious nut butter. Honey roast, natural, organic, butterscotch, chocolate, cappuccino, almond, cashew, and sunflower.
Maple Vanilla Small Batch Peanut Butter 8 oz - 0.65 Lbs.
You'll love this deliciously creamy maple vanilla peanut butter these limited edition small batch butter are only around for a limited time so do not delay and order yours today. Choose from several freshly ground varieties of delicious nut butter. Honey roast, organic, butterscotch, chocolate, cappuccino, almond, cashew, and sunflower.
Honey Roast
Choose from several freshly ground varieties of delicious nut butter. Honey roast, organic, butterscotch, chocolate, cappuccino, almond, cashew, and sunflower.
Choc Choc
Choose from several freshly ground varieties of delicious nut butter. Honey roast, organic, butterscotch, chocolate, cappuccino, almond, cashew, and sunflower.
Mini PB and J Pack
This mini band pack makes a great sandwich and a great gift. Choose between 4 great nut butter and 3 jams. Choose from several freshly ground varieties of delicious nut butter. Honey roast, organic, butterscotch, chocolate, cappuccino, almond, cashew, and sunflower.
Natural Cashew (8 oz) (0.80 lb)
Natural cashew. Ingredients: roasted cashews, and salt. Serving size - 2 tablespoons. Choose from several freshly ground varieties of delicious nut butter. Honey roast, organic, butterscotch, chocolate, cappuccino, almond, cashew, and sunflower.
Natural Sunflower (8 oz) (0.80 lb)
Natural sunflower. Ingredients: roasted sunflower kernels, sunflower oil (sunflower oil, citric acid), and salt. Choose from several freshly ground varieties of delicious nut butter. Honey roast, organic, butterscotch, chocolate, cappuccino, almond, cashew, and sunflower.
Peanut Butter Party Box
It's party time at cape may peanut butter company. You'll love our party box filled with 5 great nut butter. Honey roast, butterscotch, cap cino, choc, and natural peanut. Plus, it comes with a handy PB spreader. This party box also makes a great gift for the PB lover in your life. Five 3 oz. Jars. 2.0 lbs. Choose from several freshly ground varieties of delicious nut butter. Honey roast, organic, butterscotch, chocolate, cappuccino, almond, cashew, and sunflower.
CapuCino
Ingredients: roasted peanuts, butterscotch drops, cinnamon drops, non-GMO canola oil, dextrose, coffee, dutch cocoa powder, natural flavorings. Serving size - 2 tablespoons. 8 oz - 0.80 lbs., 16 oz - (1.25 lb), 32 oz - 2.45 lbs. Choose from several freshly ground varieties of delicious nut butter. Honey roast, natural, organic, butterscotch, chocolate, cappuccino, almond, cashew, and sunflower.
Natural Almond
Our almond butter is made with nothing other than roasted almonds. Ingredients: dry roasted almonds. Serving size - 2 tablespoons. 8 oz - 0.80 lbs., 16 oz - (1.25 lb), 32 oz - 2.45 lbs. Choose from several freshly ground varieties of delicious nut butter. Honey roast, natural, organic, butterscotch, chocolate, cappuccino, almond, cashew, and sunflower.
Natural Peanut
Our natural peanut butter is made with dry roasted peanuts and salt. Great for baking, smoothies, and much more. Ingredients: dry roasted peanuts, salt. Serving size - 2 tablespoons. 8 oz - 0.80 lbs., 16 oz - (1.25 lb), 32 oz - 2.45 lbs. Choose from several freshly ground varieties of delicious nut butter. Honey roast, natural, organic, butterscotch, chocolate, cappuccino, almond, cashew, and sunflower.
Organic Peanut
Ingredients: dry roasted organic peanuts. Serving size - 2 tablespoons. (8 oz) (0.75 lb), 16 oz - (1.25 lb), 32 oz - 2.35 lbs. Choose from several freshly ground varieties of delicious nut butter. Honey roast, natural, organic, butterscotch, chocolate, cappuccino, almond, cashew, and sunflower.
Powdered Peanut Butter
Butter Scotch Powdered Peanut Butter 0.8 oz - 0.10 Lbs.
Butterscotch powdered peanut butter is the perfect on-the-go snack.
Natural Peanut Powdered Peanut Butter 0.8 oz - 0.10 Lbs.
Natural peanut powdered peanut butter is the perfect on-the-go snack.
Choc Choc Powdered Peanut Butter 0.8 oz - 0.10 Lbs.
Choc powdered peanut butter is the perfect on-the-go snack.
Jellies and Jams
Apricot Pecan Preserves (1 lb)
Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Jalapeno Peach Pecan Preserves (1 lb)
Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Apricot Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lb)
Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Blackberry Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lb)
Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Lingonberry Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lb)
Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Strawberry Rhubarb Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lb)
Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Apple Butter by Brooklyn Whatever (0.90 lb)
This is a highly concentrated form of apple sauce. It's made by long, slow cooking of apples till caramelized. It's spreadable and so good on crackers, fruit, or right out of the jar with a spoon. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Blazing Blueberry Jam by Brooklyn Whatever (0.90 lb)
Smooth, spreadable blazing blueberry jam. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Brooklyn Whatever Jam (0.80 lb)
Brooklyn whatever jams. Great flavors include apple butter, rockin' raspberry, cherry jalapeno, hot pepper, peppery peach, jalapeno, and Blazin blueberry. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Carrot Cake Jam (1 lb)
Potlicker jam - carrot cake. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Cherry Pecan Preserves
Cherries and jalapenos blended into a jam. So unique and delicious. Not too spicy, not too sweet, this one's just right. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Elderberry Jam by Mrs. Miller's 18 oz- (1.25 lb)
Ingredients: sugar, elderberries, water, pectin, lemon juice, citric acid. All-natural, no corn syrup. Hand scooped in Ohio's Amish country. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Hot Pepper Jam by Brooklyn Whatever (0.90 lb)
A mix of hot peppers and sugar to form a spread that will wake up everything you put on. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Mini PBandJ Pack
This mini band pack makes a great sandwich and a great gift. Choose between 4 great nut butter and 3 jams. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Peppery Peach Jam by Brooklyn Whatever (0.90 lb)
Smooth, spreadable peppery peach. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Red Raspberry Jam by Mrs. Miller's (18 oz) (1.25 lb)
Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Strawberry Jam Sugarless by Mrs. Miller's (18 oz) (1.25 lb)
Ingredients: red raspberries, white grape juice concentrate and-or apple juice, pectin, citric acid, vinegar. Naturally sweet - no granulated sugar added. Hand scooped in Ohio's Amish country. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Cranberry Chili Pecan Preserves (1 lb)
Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Peach Pecan Amaretto Preserves (1 lb)
Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Black Currant Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lb)
Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Boysenberry Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lb)
Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Raspberry Rhubarb Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lb)
Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Wild Blueberry Fruit Spread - Scandinavian Delights (1.25 lb)
Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Blackberry Jam Seedless by Mrs. Miller's (18 oz) (1.25 lb)
Made from the plumpest, most delicious blackberries, Mrs. Miller's homemade seedless blackberry jam is a delicious combo of sweetness and tartness. One of the most historically familiar flavors of jam, this can be used as a pie filling, a glaze for your meats, or as a topping on your toast, muffin, or biscuit. Hand scooped in Ohio's Amish country. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Blueberry Bourbon Jam (1 lb)
Whole Maine blueberries and brown sugar with a touch of bourbon give this jam a rich flavor. Spoon over ice cream, fill cakes or perk up your morning toast. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Bumbleberry Jam by Mrs. Miller's (18 oz) (1.25 lb)
Made from a combination of 3 of everyone's favorite fruits: strawberries, blueberries, and red raspberries, Mrs. Miller's homemade bumbleberry jam is bursting with flavor. Try it out on your next muffin or toast or use it to create the best PB and j sandwich you have ever tasted. Hand scooped in Ohio's Amish country. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Cherry Jalapeno Jam (0.9 lb)
Cherries and jalapenos blended into a jam. So unique and delicious. Not too spicy, not too sweet, this one's just right. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Dutch Apple Jam by Mrs. Miller's (8 oz) (0.75 lb)
Cooked with delicious apples and pure cane sugar, Mrs. Miller's homemade dutch apple jam reminds everyone of homemade apple pie. Get a real taste of Amish country when you scoop this onto your next slice of homemade bread or use it as filling or glaze for your pies. Hand scooped in Ohio's Amish country. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
F.R.O.G. Jam by Mrs. Miller's (8 oz) (0.75 lb)
Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Jalapeno Jam (0.9 lb)
Smooth, spreadable jalapeno jam for those who like it hot. Great on sandwiches or as a dip. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Mango Jam by Mrs. Miller's (8 oz) (0.75 lb)
Made with sweet tropical mango fruit, Mrs. Miller's homemade mango jam is a tasty tropical jam. The mango fruit is known as the king of fruits and originates in southeast Asia. It is known for its sweet luscious taste and nutritional qualities. Mangoes are rich in vitamins and antioxidants. Most importantly though, they result in a delicious jam that will give you a wonderful spread on your toast without requiring a journey to southeast Asia to harvest them. Hand scooped in Ohio's Amish country. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Peach Jam Sugarles by Mrs. Miller's (18 oz) (1.25 lb)
Ingredients: peaches, white grape juice concentrate and/or apple juice, pectin, citric acid, vinegar. Naturally sweet - no granulated sugar added. Hand scooped in Ohio's Amish country. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Raspberry Smoked Maple Jam (1 lb)
Raspberry jam sweetened with pure maple syrup, tapped and infused with hardwood smoke in landgrave, vt. A favorite in our kitchen, this jam is equally at home in sweet, and savory applications, from cakes to funky cheese plates. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Rockin' Raspberry Jam by Brooklyn Whatever (0.9 lb)
Smooth, spreadable rockin' raspberry jam. Check out our wide variety of delicious jams, jellies, and preserves. Great flavors like apricot, apricot jalapeno, black currant, blackberry, boysenberry, cranberry butter, cranberry jalapeno, habanero lingonberry, mint, mango plum ginger, orange, pineapple jalapeno, pumpkin butter, strawberry, raspberry jalapeno, raspberry rhubarb, strawberry rhubarb, sweet onion jalapeno, sweet wine, tangerine, and more.
Candy
Peanut Butter Malted Milk Balls (0.46 lb)
Peanut butter malted milk balls.
Cocoa Dusted Chocolate Cashews (3 oz) (0.30 lb)
Seriously, you'll love these delicious cocoa dusted chocolate cashews so much you won't want to share. You may even hide these from loved ones. And that's okay by us, we don't judge.
Gourmet Candy Covered Pretzels (1.1 lb)
Peanut Butter Cup (1.1 lb)
You'll love these colossal peanut butter cups from the cape may peanut butter company.
Zippy's Almond and Apricot Bar (1.4 oz) (0.09 lb)
In honor of our furry friend that visits the shop at cape may peanut butter co., we proudly present zippy's nutbar. A great blend of puffed rice, oats, almonds, dried apricots, CNBC peanut butter, butter, sugar, honey, salt, and vanilla.
Peanut Butter Candy Straws (0.45 lb)
Peanut Butter Non-Pareils (0.55 lb)
You'll love these delicious PB nonpareils so much you may not want to share.
Dream Box (7 oz) (1 lb)
The dream box contains 3 of our most popular candies. Pb chocolate clusters, PB nonpareils, and candied coconut peanuts.
Peanut Butter Cookie Dough (1.1 lb)
It's here. Peanut butter cookie dough. Eat it, don't bake it.
Peanut Clusters (0.4 lb)
6 delicious oz. Of peanut butter and chocolate-covered peanut clusters.
Zippy's Nut Bar with Cranberries (1.4 oz) (0.09 lb)
In honor of our furry friend that visits the shop at cape may peanut butter co., we proudly present zippy's nutbar. A great blend of puffed rice, oats, peanuts, cranberries, coconut, CNBC peanut butter, butter, sugar, molasses, honey, and vanilla.
Peanuts and Snacks
Blister Fried Bertie County Peanuts
Blister fried Bertie county peanuts. (10 oz) (0.80 lb), 30 oz. - 2.00 lbs.
Honey Roasted Bertie County Peanuts (10 oz) (0.80 lb)
Honey roasted Bertie county peanuts.
Virginia Dill Pickle Peanuts (1 lb)
Virginia Diner Sweet Onion Peanuts (1 lb)
Peanut Butter Cookie Dough (1.1 lb)
It's here. Peanut butter cookie dough. Eat it, don't bake it.
Zippy's Almond and Apricot Bar (1.4 oz) (0.09 lb)
Cape May Curry Peanut Soup Mix (0.50 lb)
In honor of our furry friend that visits the shop at cape may peanut butter co., we proudly present zippy's nutbar. A great blend of puffed rice, oats, almonds, dried apricots, CNBC peanut butter, butter, sugar, honey, salt, and vanilla.
Weeping Mary's Ghost Pepper Bertie County Peanuts
A hearty blend of peanut flour, vegetables, and spices. Just add stock and heat.
Sea Salt and Black Pepper Bertie County Peanuts
Virginia Diner Maple and Bacon Peanuts (1 lb)
Mrs. Miller's Peanut Butter Marshmallow Spread (0.85 lb)
Thai Peanut Sauce and Dip (1.1 lb)
Zippy's Nut Bar with Cranberries (1.4 oz) (0.09 lb)
In honor of our furry friend that visits the shop at cape may peanut butter co., we proudly present zippy's nutbar. A great blend of puffed rice, oats, peanuts, cranberries, coconut, CNBC peanut butter, butter, sugar, molasses, honey, and vanilla.
Southern Peanut Soup Mix (0.50 lb)
A hearty blend of peanut flour, vegetables, and spices. Just add stock, cream, and heat.
Coffee, Tea, and Cocoa
Cape May Breakfast Blend Coffee - Whole Bean (0.75 lb)
Whole bean. Cape may breakfast blend from crescent moon coffee company.
Chocolate Hazelnut Coffee by Crescent Moon (0.75 lb)
Chocolate hazelnut coffee by the crescent moon.
Harvest Tea by Crescent Moon (1.1 lb)
Mango Amazon Tea by Crescent Moon (1.10 lbs.)
Peanut Butter Cup Hot Cocoa (1 lb)
You'll love our peanut butter cup hot cocoa.
Vanilla Hazelnut Coffee by Crescent Moon (0.75 lb)
Cape May Breakfast Blend Ground Coffee (0.75 lb)
Cape may breakfast blend from crescent moon coffee company.
Coconut Vanilla Black Tea by Crescent Moon (1.1 lb)
Moroccan Mint Tea by Crescent Moon (1.1 lb)
Moroccan mint tea by the crescent moon.
Snickers Coffee by Crescent Moon (0.75 lb)
White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Coffee by Crescent Moon (0.75 lb)
Photos
+67 photos
+66 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
It's a store devoted to Peanut Butter, could there BE anything better than this? I think not! Service was fantastic, selection was great & even better, you can ask to sample pretty much anything. Prices were very reasonable, a lovely unexpected sweet treat store!
September 2025
This is a great place to visit! We sampled so many great peanut butters and came out with a bag of delicious goodies. The service was warm and friendly and the prices were reasonable for the area and the product you get. We will definitely visit again on our next trip.
September 2025
This was a fun place to stop in Cape May. The staff knowledgeable of all the products very well, sizeable samples offered, and very friendly store. I bought gifts, great peanut butter unique flavor choices.
September 2025
You May Also Like
Freda's Cafe - 210 Ocean St Apartment 1
![]()
Cafe, Vegetarian
A Ca Mia Ristorante/Bakery - 524 Washington St Mall
![]()
Italian, Soup, Vegan, Vegetarian
Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard - 512 Washington St
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Ice Cream