Fine Fellows Creamery
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
313 Beach Ave, Cape May
(609) 854-7902
About Fine Fellows Creamery
Fine Fellows Creamery Reviews
Our favorite place to get ice cream! Great staff, great vibes and great ice cream💖
My favorite Cape May ice cream shop! We've been stopping in every summer since they first opened. The ice cream is delicious (try the cherry vanilla) and it's even better in their homemade waffle cone. Besides having terrific ice cream, the service is always friendly and pleasant even when it's really busy.
I am allergic to nuts. The staff here always goes out of their way to accommodate me and my allergy issues. I really appreciate them for that. And, the ice cream is great! So if you have allergies like me, this is your go to place!
Menu
People in Cape May Also Viewed
Fine Fellows Creamery is a gay-owned business known for outstanding customer service. The shop offers delicious hot fudge sundaes and a large selection of ice cream flavors. Customers can enjoy their treats inside the shop, which is located on Beach Ave, opposite the beach. The ice cream is described as having bold and creamy flavors, with an old-school ice cream shop vibe. Staff are very allergy conscious, taking steps to accommodate customers with dietary restrictions such as nut allergies, making it a safe and friendly place for everyone. Many visitors say it’s their favorite Cape May ice cream spot, especially during busy holiday weekends when lines may form. The shop also features over six vegan ice cream options, appealing to a variety of dietary preferences. Overall, the combination of good service, friendly staff, and tasty ice cream makes Fine Fellows Creamery a top choice in the area.