Went with my family this evening the host was very pleasant and our server was great. I however ordered the 12oz NY strip which I would have rather cut myself vs being served that way. The temp was as ordered but the cut had a lot of fat and tasted blah as did the mashed potatoes and the 1/2 roasted asparagus had zero taste. I was not happy with my experience with fins this evening.
Mary Ball
Food was excellent! Atmosphere was great. Went twice during vacation , was the best place we went to for dinner!
Katherine Oldham
Always great service and the food is delicious and reasonably priced. Portion sizes are good also. My youngest loves to sit inside near the big fish tank in the center of the restaurant, there is another fish tank in the back as well. We eat here at least once on every visit to Cape May. No reservations but if there is a long wait plan to put your name in first and then walk the shops along Washington Street Mall. They will text you when your table is ready! Enjoy!
Herr Starr
Wife & I had a late lunch here with our 1 year old. Everyone was very kind & accommodating even when it came to our kid throwing stuff on the floor. We would go to pick it up but half the time a member of the staff would beat us to it, always with a smile. Fish tacos and Greek salad were both great!
Youssef Sultan
Had the baked fish tacos and the fish was very fresh and moist paired with the flavor abundant sauce. Food took an average amount of time to come out due to its quality. Would definitely come back.
Joe J
Wait was long but that is due to being in season and we were a party of 7. Service was great, staff is super friendly! The food was ok. Salmon was nicely cooked but could have had a bit more flavor. Mostly salt which I did not add.
Liv Stenger
My boyfriend and I came here for lunch the day before my uncle's wedding. It was beautiful and quiet and we were greeted immediately by a very courteous hostess. She brought us right to a table outside and the view was so nice. Just when I thought it couldn't get any better we had the sweetest and most bubbly waitress ever who made sure we got exactly what we wanted (she even got me a ginger beer most restaurants don't ever have it I was so excited!) She told us a bunch of cool facts about cape May and the owners and how she loves working at Fin's. She made both of us smile and brightened our days and then THANKED US for making her day. Super sweet staff this place is a must visit for your trip to cape May I promise you won't be disappointed! Don't even get me started on the food, they got it out right away and it was probably the best food we've had in a while for a decent price. Thank you so much to Harliegh our server and everyone else at Fin's for the phenomenal experience 12/10. Definitely coming again :)
Matthew Bernard
Food was great, service was good. What was remarkable was that even the kids entrees were delicious l. I never thought fried shrimp off a kids menu could taste so good.Would definitely recommend for families with little ones.
Frank
Great location in Jefferson mall. Plenty of outdoor and indoor seating. The service was great. Food and drinks were brought to our table incredibly fast. We ordered the fried fish tacos and the fish and chips. The fried fish tacos were maybe a 3/5, the fish was good, but the tortillas were mediocre. The fish and chips was a definitive 5/5. The fish was fried perfectly, with a crisp airy batter on the outside and incredibly flaky juicy fish inside. I'd highly recommend the fish and chips and getting one of their cocktails.
Ronnie T.
A nice atmosphere and it’s right on the main walking area. Parking can be tough, I suggest getting a spot in the meter pay lots provided a block over. It’s a three hour parking limit, so plan accordingly. The place itself was very cool with the blue light theme and the fish tank in the middle. Our waitress, Amanda was very friendly and efficient. I had the fish of the day, which was Tilefish, and it was really tasty. We got a few beverages that were also delicious! This is one of those places you have to check out when your down in Cape May.
Absolutely love the environment here. The lighting is incredible and the fish tanks are a great touch. My bf and I shared a meal here and was very impressed. Their crab cakes are incredible and we enjoyed all of the appetizers we got. Can be slightly more on the pricey side but is a great spot. Their drinks are also very delicious.
Went with my family this evening the host was very pleasant and our server was great. I however ordered the 12oz NY strip which I would have rather cut myself vs being served that way. The temp was as ordered but the cut had a lot of fat and tasted blah as did the mashed potatoes and the 1/2 roasted asparagus had zero taste. I was not happy with my experience with fins this evening.
Food was excellent! Atmosphere was great. Went twice during vacation , was the best place we went to for dinner!
Always great service and the food is delicious and reasonably priced. Portion sizes are good also. My youngest loves to sit inside near the big fish tank in the center of the restaurant, there is another fish tank in the back as well. We eat here at least once on every visit to Cape May. No reservations but if there is a long wait plan to put your name in first and then walk the shops along Washington Street Mall. They will text you when your table is ready! Enjoy!
Wife & I had a late lunch here with our 1 year old. Everyone was very kind & accommodating even when it came to our kid throwing stuff on the floor. We would go to pick it up but half the time a member of the staff would beat us to it, always with a smile. Fish tacos and Greek salad were both great!
Had the baked fish tacos and the fish was very fresh and moist paired with the flavor abundant sauce. Food took an average amount of time to come out due to its quality. Would definitely come back.
Wait was long but that is due to being in season and we were a party of 7. Service was great, staff is super friendly! The food was ok. Salmon was nicely cooked but could have had a bit more flavor. Mostly salt which I did not add.
My boyfriend and I came here for lunch the day before my uncle's wedding. It was beautiful and quiet and we were greeted immediately by a very courteous hostess. She brought us right to a table outside and the view was so nice. Just when I thought it couldn't get any better we had the sweetest and most bubbly waitress ever who made sure we got exactly what we wanted (she even got me a ginger beer most restaurants don't ever have it I was so excited!) She told us a bunch of cool facts about cape May and the owners and how she loves working at Fin's. She made both of us smile and brightened our days and then THANKED US for making her day. Super sweet staff this place is a must visit for your trip to cape May I promise you won't be disappointed! Don't even get me started on the food, they got it out right away and it was probably the best food we've had in a while for a decent price. Thank you so much to Harliegh our server and everyone else at Fin's for the phenomenal experience 12/10. Definitely coming again :)
Food was great, service was good. What was remarkable was that even the kids entrees were delicious l. I never thought fried shrimp off a kids menu could taste so good.Would definitely recommend for families with little ones.
Great location in Jefferson mall. Plenty of outdoor and indoor seating. The service was great. Food and drinks were brought to our table incredibly fast. We ordered the fried fish tacos and the fish and chips. The fried fish tacos were maybe a 3/5, the fish was good, but the tortillas were mediocre. The fish and chips was a definitive 5/5. The fish was fried perfectly, with a crisp airy batter on the outside and incredibly flaky juicy fish inside. I'd highly recommend the fish and chips and getting one of their cocktails.
A nice atmosphere and it’s right on the main walking area. Parking can be tough, I suggest getting a spot in the meter pay lots provided a block over. It’s a three hour parking limit, so plan accordingly. The place itself was very cool with the blue light theme and the fish tank in the middle. Our waitress, Amanda was very friendly and efficient. I had the fish of the day, which was Tilefish, and it was really tasty. We got a few beverages that were also delicious! This is one of those places you have to check out when your down in Cape May.
Restaurantji Recommends
Absolutely love the environment here. The lighting is incredible and the fish tanks are a great touch. My bf and I shared a meal here and was very impressed. Their crab cakes are incredible and we enjoyed all of the appetizers we got. Can be slightly more on the pricey side but is a great spot. Their drinks are also very delicious.
Delicious flats and really cute atmosphere!!