Shout out to Caitlin for the most INCREDIBLE customer service. She was willing to get a (very expensive) parking ticket to make sure we had the best experience at the bakery. Caitlin was so nice and patient as we decided what to order and gave us great recommendations. The cinnamon bites were delicious and I’ll be thinking about that sticky bun for weeks to come!
JT Weber
Great cakes down in Cape May. Beautiful cake for a friend who loves sunflowers. It was a bit expensive for the size but made up with great taste.
Sapan P.
Not sure what the hype is about. It was good, but nothing special. Sticky buns, coffee and latte, can I find it elsewhere? Yes. Was this better than anywhere else? No.
Dee M.
Is it sticky buns you want? Then come here. They won't share the longtime family recipe with you, but can you blame them?Pastries you say? They have the best. Donuts- they have won local awards for them. So why aren't you here? I know parking can be a challenge, but if you take a short walk, you can justify the calories you just consumed.In all seriousness, family run bakeries are for the most part a thing of the past that many of us miss. You'd be doing yourself a favor by supporting this mom and Pop operation.
David A.
A place that calls itself "The Best Bakery in South Jersey" better have a pretty damn solid proof.Can't vouch for South Jersey as this was the first time I'd been to Cape May and the lower half of the Jersey Shore. But by god if it's not "The Best Bakery in Cape May."Lemme explain.Cape May, we love you but you're kinda sucky when it comes to two very critical things: bagels and pizza.However, you more than make up for it in ice cream and donuts. Everything in balance.Well, the donuts at Madison's for sure. And the chocolate croissants were The Best I've Ever Tasted and I've Been to Old Hapsburg Cities in Europe Where That Kinda Pastry Is Practically A Religion.My sister absolutely loved the gluten free choc chip muffins; she just wished there were more GF choices...And the service was fantastic! Very friendly and fast. I also got there at a great time. For some inexplicable reason (must be that Cape May magic) I was up really early the entire week and headed over to Madison's just about every morning. So it wasn't too crowded and crazy, which I noticed started around after 8:30.So def see you next summer, now that Cape May has officially become a family tradition!
Kevin K.
Incredible buns! Sticky I mean!! Excellent bakery and three locations make it that much easier to get them! Do not pass on the sticky bun parfait! Got one fresh and they are epic!
Dara Z.
The most amazing sticky buns! I made a point to get them on my visit. The service was super nice and the store is so cute. Please go and get one!
Steven D.
Had the ice cream filled donut, filled with cinnamon bun ice cream. Warm doughnut with cold ice cream. Awesome!
Maggie Effinger
I've had better donuts.
53gregp
Great choices! Good donuts on donut day! Gluten free options are great. Perfect treats! Donuts were fresh and tasty. Would get treats from there again
Stopped by on a whim as we were walking for a coffee and a donut. I tried the chocolate sprinkle donut. Customer service was nice and quick! Coffee was decent and the donut was perfectly fluffy! We spent $5 so everything was reasonably priced as well!
Beach Barn Candle Company
best family owned bakery EVER!
Sheila R.
We stopped in Sunday, the last day of the season before closing. Grabbed a couple of very fresh donuts and 2 lattes. Service was fast and efficient. Latte was hot...a bit too hot. Could have easily burnt my mouth. Took awhile with lid off in 40 degree weather for me to be able to drink it. Donuts were super fresh and delicious.
mpevahouse
Not open
William Low
Best sticky buns ever but goes fast so get here early
Shout out to Caitlin for the most INCREDIBLE customer service. She was willing to get a (very expensive) parking ticket to make sure we had the best experience at the bakery. Caitlin was so nice and patient as we decided what to order and gave us great recommendations. The cinnamon bites were delicious and I’ll be thinking about that sticky bun for weeks to come!
Great cakes down in Cape May. Beautiful cake for a friend who loves sunflowers. It was a bit expensive for the size but made up with great taste.
Not sure what the hype is about. It was good, but nothing special. Sticky buns, coffee and latte, can I find it elsewhere? Yes. Was this better than anywhere else? No.
Is it sticky buns you want? Then come here. They won't share the longtime family recipe with you, but can you blame them?Pastries you say? They have the best. Donuts- they have won local awards for them. So why aren't you here? I know parking can be a challenge, but if you take a short walk, you can justify the calories you just consumed.In all seriousness, family run bakeries are for the most part a thing of the past that many of us miss. You'd be doing yourself a favor by supporting this mom and Pop operation.
A place that calls itself "The Best Bakery in South Jersey" better have a pretty damn solid proof.Can't vouch for South Jersey as this was the first time I'd been to Cape May and the lower half of the Jersey Shore. But by god if it's not "The Best Bakery in Cape May."Lemme explain.Cape May, we love you but you're kinda sucky when it comes to two very critical things: bagels and pizza.However, you more than make up for it in ice cream and donuts. Everything in balance.Well, the donuts at Madison's for sure. And the chocolate croissants were The Best I've Ever Tasted and I've Been to Old Hapsburg Cities in Europe Where That Kinda Pastry Is Practically A Religion.My sister absolutely loved the gluten free choc chip muffins; she just wished there were more GF choices...And the service was fantastic! Very friendly and fast. I also got there at a great time. For some inexplicable reason (must be that Cape May magic) I was up really early the entire week and headed over to Madison's just about every morning. So it wasn't too crowded and crazy, which I noticed started around after 8:30.So def see you next summer, now that Cape May has officially become a family tradition!
Incredible buns! Sticky I mean!! Excellent bakery and three locations make it that much easier to get them! Do not pass on the sticky bun parfait! Got one fresh and they are epic!
The most amazing sticky buns! I made a point to get them on my visit. The service was super nice and the store is so cute. Please go and get one!
Had the ice cream filled donut, filled with cinnamon bun ice cream. Warm doughnut with cold ice cream. Awesome!
I've had better donuts.
Great choices! Good donuts on donut day! Gluten free options are great. Perfect treats! Donuts were fresh and tasty. Would get treats from there again
Restaurantji Recommends
Stopped by on a whim as we were walking for a coffee and a donut. I tried the chocolate sprinkle donut. Customer service was nice and quick! Coffee was decent and the donut was perfectly fluffy! We spent $5 so everything was reasonably priced as well!
best family owned bakery EVER!
We stopped in Sunday, the last day of the season before closing. Grabbed a couple of very fresh donuts and 2 lattes. Service was fast and efficient. Latte was hot...a bit too hot. Could have easily burnt my mouth. Took awhile with lid off in 40 degree weather for me to be able to drink it. Donuts were super fresh and delicious.
Not open
Best sticky buns ever but goes fast so get here early