My 1st time at Peace Pie. I surely was missing out. Such a cute place and so vibrant and colorful. Love the peace signs in the front. The large flavor sign made it easy to pick a flavor and I love how every pie is $8. You can't beat one set price ! I definitely recommend the salted caramel brownie ice cream sandwich ! It was so sweet and the brownie was so gooey and delicious!
Suzanne LaGrange
Very cute little ice cream sandwich place with knowledgeable and helpful staff??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwiches
Leo Sherman
Delicious, and, more importantly, open on January 2nd!
Some really good ice cream sandwiches from a cute little stand right off the main shopping strip in Cape May. Friendly patrons and darned good ice cream sandwiches. Their chocolate cookies surrounding the ice cream are yum and the peace signs are a cute touch. Best $8 you'll spend on ice cream. Bring the kids elsewhere unless you want to drain your wallet.
Ava H
Chocolate & banana my fave combo!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwiches
Amanda “Mandi” Vavala
Phenomenal! Went to Cape May in 2022 and the filing station restaurant sold them. I had the strawberry shortcake one and it was the best ice cream sandwich I’ve ever eaten, bar none!
Diane P.
Great little ice cream place. There are so many flavors to choose from. The ice cream sandwich was a nice size for the prize ($8). The guy at the counter was really nice.
Deb P.
Delicious, unique ice cream sandwiches!!! A lovely October stay in Cape May , and among our discoveries was Peace Pie ! Their pecan pie flavor is awesome & made my evening! Everything about our experience there was exceptional! Check it out you will not be disappointed !
Mandi Vavala
Phenomenal! Went to Cape May in 2022 and the filing station restaurant sold them. I had the strawberry shortcake one and it was the best ice cream sandwich I’ve ever eaten, bar none!
Great flavor combos. We tried not to, but came back for seconds! A bit pricey, but really yummy!
Eric McDermott
We had salted caramel brownie and peanut butter cookie dough. Both were awesome.
Mario B.
While the ice cream is quite good, the service tonight was led by the most miserable human being I have encountered in a long time. Surly would be a compliment for the young woman who attended to us. My thought for the owner: friendly and attentive employees bring back business; miserable and dark employees drive it away.
Emily C.
Fun spot for a cold and sweet treat! The exterior is colorful and fun. There are a ton of flavors to choose from, maybe too many -- it is hard to know what each flavor's name actually indicates. Separating out the menu by type of cookie, or otherwise indicating the type of cookie used on each peace pie (like color coding) could be an improvement.During our time in Cape May, we tried the blueberry lemon drop, peanut butter blondie, and caramel coffee toffee. The blueberry lemon drop was incredible and I was thoroughly impressed. I thought the other two were just OK and wouldn't order again; the chocolate cookie on the caramel coffee toffee tasted old and/or burnt.Definitely overpriced for what you get, but still a fun treat!
Crystal Whitfield
Peace Pie of Cape May made some good looking and delicious tasting ice cream sandwiches. The exceptional cookie crust was crispy and buttery. The pecan pie filling has me wondering if I could concoct an at-home ice cream topping this delicious. The vanilla ice cream was better than grocery store grade, but not quite as good as my favorite parlor. Overall I'd say 4.5, rounded to 5, because the cookies themselves are binge-worthy and the server was a nice young man.
My 1st time at Peace Pie. I surely was missing out. Such a cute place and so vibrant and colorful. Love the peace signs in the front. The large flavor sign made it easy to pick a flavor and I love how every pie is $8. You can't beat one set price ! I definitely recommend the salted caramel brownie ice cream sandwich ! It was so sweet and the brownie was so gooey and delicious!
Very cute little ice cream sandwich place with knowledgeable and helpful staff??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwiches
Delicious, and, more importantly, open on January 2nd!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwiches, Salted Caramel Brownie
The best hand crafted ice cream sandwiches!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwiches
Some really good ice cream sandwiches from a cute little stand right off the main shopping strip in Cape May. Friendly patrons and darned good ice cream sandwiches. Their chocolate cookies surrounding the ice cream are yum and the peace signs are a cute touch. Best $8 you'll spend on ice cream. Bring the kids elsewhere unless you want to drain your wallet.
Chocolate & banana my fave combo!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Sandwiches
Phenomenal! Went to Cape May in 2022 and the filing station restaurant sold them. I had the strawberry shortcake one and it was the best ice cream sandwich I’ve ever eaten, bar none!
Great little ice cream place. There are so many flavors to choose from. The ice cream sandwich was a nice size for the prize ($8). The guy at the counter was really nice.
Delicious, unique ice cream sandwiches!!! A lovely October stay in Cape May , and among our discoveries was Peace Pie ! Their pecan pie flavor is awesome & made my evening! Everything about our experience there was exceptional! Check it out you will not be disappointed !
Phenomenal! Went to Cape May in 2022 and the filing station restaurant sold them. I had the strawberry shortcake one and it was the best ice cream sandwich I’ve ever eaten, bar none!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great flavor combos. We tried not to, but came back for seconds! A bit pricey, but really yummy!
We had salted caramel brownie and peanut butter cookie dough. Both were awesome.
While the ice cream is quite good, the service tonight was led by the most miserable human being I have encountered in a long time. Surly would be a compliment for the young woman who attended to us. My thought for the owner: friendly and attentive employees bring back business; miserable and dark employees drive it away.
Fun spot for a cold and sweet treat! The exterior is colorful and fun. There are a ton of flavors to choose from, maybe too many -- it is hard to know what each flavor's name actually indicates. Separating out the menu by type of cookie, or otherwise indicating the type of cookie used on each peace pie (like color coding) could be an improvement.During our time in Cape May, we tried the blueberry lemon drop, peanut butter blondie, and caramel coffee toffee. The blueberry lemon drop was incredible and I was thoroughly impressed. I thought the other two were just OK and wouldn't order again; the chocolate cookie on the caramel coffee toffee tasted old and/or burnt.Definitely overpriced for what you get, but still a fun treat!
Peace Pie of Cape May made some good looking and delicious tasting ice cream sandwiches. The exceptional cookie crust was crispy and buttery. The pecan pie filling has me wondering if I could concoct an at-home ice cream topping this delicious. The vanilla ice cream was better than grocery store grade, but not quite as good as my favorite parlor. Overall I'd say 4.5, rounded to 5, because the cookies themselves are binge-worthy and the server was a nice young man.