Peace Pie

Customers' Favorites

Photos

+81 photos
+80 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

The ice cream sandwiches here are amazing artisanal productions. They are nothing like the ice cream sandwiches you buy in a supermarket. There is a full scoop of ice cream with toppings squashed between two cookies and frozen rock hard. This is a good thing. Because in the summer the ice cream stays in the sandwich and doesn't melt all over your hands. You will definitely have time to eat the whole sandwich before the ice cream starts oozing out.

There...
Stopped at Peace Pie for the first time and it was super good! I got the Pecan Pie flavor, which came with buttery shortbread cookies on the top and bottom, ice cream in the middle, and pecan pie on top. I definitely could’ve used a little more pie for the price, but everything was delicious. The customer service was friendly, too. I’d definitely go back and try another flavor.
It’s a must stop (multiple times per week) for me while vacationing in Cape May. The Coconut Cream Pie and Pecan Pie sandwiches were my favorite - any of the “pie” ones really. I love the shortbread or graham ones the most.

More Reviews