Peace Pie

326 Carpenters Ln, Cape May
(609) 435-5321

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Peanut Butter Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich
S’Mores Ice Cream Sandwich
Salted Caramel Brownie
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Chocolate Chip
Coffee Toffee
Key Lime Pie
Jersey Devil
Blueberry

Menu

Specialty Packages
Chocolate Lovers (12 pk)
Includes salted caramel brownie, cookie dough, the Elvis, peanut butter cup, chocolate-covered strawberry, cookies and cream, s'mores, candy bar, chocolate mint, triple chocolate brownie, and 2 molten chocolate.
Vanilla and Chocolate Twist (12 pk)
Includes 2 of each: cookies and cream, triple chocolate brownie cookie dough, Boston cream, molten chocolate, and triple vanilla.
Summer Treats (12 pk)
Includes 4 of each: key lime pie, coconut cream, strawberry shortcake, and banana cream.
Peanut Butter Fanatics (12 pk)
Includes 4 of each: peanut butter cup, the Elvis, candy bar, and peanut butter brownie.
The Classics (12 pk)
Includes 1 of each: salted caramel brownie, pecan pie, cookies and cream, strawberry shortcake, banana cream, coconut cream, boston cream, key lime pie, salted caramel apple, molten chocolate, peanut butter cup, and chocolate mint.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: nextdoor
Photo credit: nextdoor
+79 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+78 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We had heard so much about this place and were excited to try it. It was very disappointing to find out that they were all premade ice cream sandwiches and not made to order. You can tell that some sandwiches that were not so popular had been sitting in the freezer too long. My son‘s sandwich ice cream had ice crystals and the cookie tasted stale. He ended up throwing it out. Overall, not worth the hype!!
June 2026
Delicious icecream sandwich, I had the blueberry pie and it tasted just like a fresh pie, with real blueberries in it! My parter had the Carmel brownie, which is there biggest seller, and loved it as well. The icecream is very solid and takes a while to soften, but makes it less messy overall.
June 2026
The ice cream cookie sandwiches are delicious but definitely overpriced for what they are. They were much smaller than I thought they would be from the pictures. I expected a made to order, fresh (not frozen) cookie with ice cream and toppings as described. I was surprised when she pulled out a premade ice cream/cookie sandwich. It was still tasty but the price should reflect this business model.
May 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

La Doña Restaurante Mexicano - 31 Perry St
Mexican, Vegetarian
Tisha's Fine Dining - 322 Washington St
American, Seafood, Italian, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian
Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls - 320 Washington St
Seafood, Salad, Soup, Pet Friendly

Peace Pie

326 Carpenters Ln, Cape May, NJ 08204
(609) 435-5321