Peace Pie

326 Carpenters Ln, Cape May
(609) 435-5321

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Peanut Butter Brownie Ice Cream Sandwich
S’Mores Ice Cream Sandwich
Salted Caramel Brownie
Ice Cream Sandwiches
Chocolate Chip
Coffee Toffee
Key Lime Pie
Jersey Devil
Blueberry

Menu

Specialty Packages
Chocolate Lovers (12 pk)
Includes salted caramel brownie, cookie dough, the Elvis, peanut butter cup, chocolate-covered strawberry, cookies and cream, s'mores, candy bar, chocolate mint, triple chocolate brownie, and 2 molten chocolate.
Vanilla and Chocolate Twist (12 pk)
Includes 2 of each: cookies and cream, triple chocolate brownie cookie dough, Boston cream, molten chocolate, and triple vanilla.
Summer Treats (12 pk)
Includes 4 of each: key lime pie, coconut cream, strawberry shortcake, and banana cream.
Peanut Butter Fanatics (12 pk)
Includes 4 of each: peanut butter cup, the Elvis, candy bar, and peanut butter brownie.
The Classics (12 pk)
Includes 1 of each: salted caramel brownie, pecan pie, cookies and cream, strawberry shortcake, banana cream, coconut cream, boston cream, key lime pie, salted caramel apple, molten chocolate, peanut butter cup, and chocolate mint.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: nextdoor
Photo credit: nextdoor
+78 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+77 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I tried the chocolate peanut butter cookie dough and it was delicious. I would definitely return and recommend stopping!

Update: it’s December and 38 degrees and I stopped here for a second time today. It’s delicious. I tried the Elvis the second time.
December 2025
Part of me wishes this place were closer, but the other half of me is glad that it's not. I could eat this three times a day. Great little shop, I love the little window setup. Great staff and amazing ice cream flavors.
November 2025
Peace Pie in Cape May is a delightful treasure for anyone with a sweet tooth. My wife and I tried their Peanut Butter Brownie ice cream sandwich, and it was absolutely delicious. While I prefer a softer cookie, the crunchy ones they use held up well and still tasted fantastic.

I was impressed by the huge range of flavor options they offer. It’s clear they’ve put thought into creativity and quality. The shop is charming, the service was friendly and efficient,...
September 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Tisha's Fine Dining - 322 Washington St
American, Seafood, Italian, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian
Crepe May - 306 Washington St
Waffles, Creperies, Juice Bar & Smoothies
Magic Brain Cafe - 31 Perry St
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Internet Cafe, Coffee, Vegan

Peace Pie

326 Carpenters Ln, Cape May, NJ 08204
(609) 435-5321