Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant

Name: Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant
Address: 1301 Beach Ave, Cape May, New Jersey, 08204, US
Telephone: (609) 884-9090
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.5

$$$ • Seafood, American

Hours:
1301 Beach Ave, Cape May
(609) 884-9090

Menu Reserve

About Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant

Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant offers a beautiful setting, with some minor issues like lack of air circulation on the porch. The service can be sparse but decent, with food delivery being a bit disconnected. The food portions are generous, with the filet being a bit overcooked, but the sticky toffee pudding stands out as a must-try dessert. The overall dining experience is rated highly, especially during Restaurant Week where the pre fixe menu offers good value.

The restaurant provides an exquisite experience from start to finish. The beef with foie gras add-on is very satisfying, and the appetizers and desserts are perfection. The ambiance is relaxing and elegant, making for a great meal and experience. The venue is gorgeous, especially with spectacular fall decorations outside. The staff is knowledgeable, kind, and works well together, creating a smooth and attentive service. A pianist enhances the atmosphere, taking requests via text and playing many favorite songs, including a wedding song, which adds to the special occasion feeling. The food is top notch, with delicious options like the cavatelli, short rib special, and fresh tomato salad. The wine list is well-curated and reasonably priced, with only a $40 corkage fee for two bottles. The peanut butter and jelly dessert is insanely good, offering wonderful flavors. Overall, Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant is one of Cape May’s finest dining experiences, with exceptional, refined, and flavorful food that is beautifully plated.