34 Best Ice Cream Shops near Clayton

“My Mom has Been enjoying Twin Kiss since she was 16 years old ! She and my dad have been taking our family here since we were born !!! We simply LOVE Twin Kiss!! It’s a family Tradition !!“

“Dolce Vita is amazing! Highly recommend 🫶“

“Beautiful and wonderful place“

“such a great little place with great prices and delicious ice cream“

“The best ice cream, the apple pie sundae is my favorite.🍦“

“My new favorite place this summer!“

“They're always great and nice...love the ice cream everything is amazing!!“

“We went after a show at the theater. It was very busy, but we were at the register in under 5 minutes. The staff working today (5:30pm) were all so friendly, and kept the line moving efficiently. My daughter loved her ice cream!“

“The customer service is welcoming and top-tier. The icecream is delicious! I got the banana pudding sundae—comes with banana pudding icecream, cookie wafers, marshmallow topping, whipped cream and a cherry. My husband got the banana pudding milkshake! We will def be back!“

“Really good homemade coffee ice cream 🍦. Creamy, coffee taste is outrageous!“

“Always greeted with a smile and yummy selections!“

“After driving by Elmer Twist for years, I was in the mood for a milkshake and stopped by. I had the BEST strawberry banana milkshake I EVER had!!! It was rich and full of flavor and hit the stop on a cold day. The perfect mix of strawberries and banana. I ordered my mom and brother shakes as well that were delicious. Elmer Twist thank you! Service was friendly and provided with a smile. I highly recommend and can’t wait to go back!“

“One of my favorite places for ice cream. Nice size portions with a delicious flavor.“

“Very friendly employees and quick service with a smile“

“Local Main Street "Hallmark" flare where it's always a family friendly welcome while serving the best Water Ice in the area. For example, the cherry or root beer water ice has a home made taste without the excessive sugar those other corporate locations add on.

Parking: A parking lot is part of the property and street parking directly in front of the shop is available unless there is a special event on Main Street where parking may be blocked off.“

“Friendly staff“

“I enjoy going to Serene Custard. It has been a tradition in my family for years. As an adult I treat my mom to her favorite flavor every year. Unfortunately,I developed an intolerance for dairy and could not enjoy the treat. Today I found out that they have dairy free(vegan options) I was SUPER excited only to be completely disappointed 😞 The non-dairy cookie and cream taste horrible, has no cookie & doesn't melt?!😩 Please replace the flavor. Mom tried the Strawberry 🍓 and says it was good.“

“Loved this place. We were driving along & we were looking for a place to get some ice cream. I found this place, the line was long, I was sure if I should stop & wait in line, but I did & I'm glad I did. The ice cream was delicious. I definitely recommend this place, especially with being an out of town person. Definitely take the trip to Toni's Treats.“

“Best Banana split I've ever had took me a half hour to finish it ... Very good!!!“

“Order your birthday cake from here! I had been eyeing a pretty intricate vintage cake design for a while. I decided i’d get one for my birthday. These cakes run super expensive from many bakeries over $100. I saw on tik tok that Baskin Robbins could make them but quality of the design was different from location to location. I decided i’d go for it. I called and shared what i wanted. The associate had me send photos and said she would contact me a few day later. She reach back out with a quote that was half the price of other places and to make things better my cake would be half ice cream and vanilla cake. She was very thorough with asking me what i wanted, shades of colors, size of pearls, etc. I was very happy with the customer service and felt very confident. but that was just the beginning. when i picked up my cake i was floored. the associate shared that she had worked to try to color match/ mix the colors as well as possible. the cake was so freaking gorgeous and you can tell love was put into it. It was my perfect birthday cake. everyone loved it and i got so many compliment. and of course its baskin robbin’s so the flavor was great. I am so so so happy with my cake. For reference the last photo is what i ask for. any change from original photo was communicated with me. I’m so happy with this cake and will be ordering from
here again! Thanks again Glassboro BR!

Adding an update on 3/4/26 and new photos of another great cake these ladies made for me for my birthday this year! I can only do one review but once again they hit the raspberry topped heart shape cake on the nail and all my friends loved it! You ladies are the bestttt!“

“Stopped to get the kids & their dad gelatos & ice-cream for me, the girls there were super nice & had excellent customer service skills. They were very helpful as well since I honestly didn't know what to get they made some suggestions & I finally settled on their new unicorn ice cream cone which was super good I must say & a great choice for me! Definitely will be going back next time I'm in town 😊“

“Cheesecake Frozen custard w/ Black Cherry Water ice. Cotton Candy Frozen Custard“

“We don’t have any Rita’s where we live in Massachusetts. We hope that will someday change. We are willing to travel to support our “Rita’s addiction”. It’s never a disappointment and always 5-star. No matter which location we stop at - and we’ve visited quite a few - their desserts and specialty foods are always a huge treat.“

“Drove thru for Father’s Day. Everyone loved their flavors: choc pb, pistachio,mint chocolate chip, butter pecan and a blue icee. All delicious. And staff was friendly and smiling. Great job everyone keep up the good work!“

“Cookie butter icecream yum!!“

“Aine was such a great employee! Would definitely be back!“

“This is the o ly place I know that sells crunch coat. It is good on all of their ice cream. When we travel back to the midwest, we always take some with us! If you are in South Jersey make sure you stop here. They are open even during the winter season!“

“I normally recommend this place. Normally all the desserts I get so not disappoint. This past visit, I ordered the galaxy brownie cookie and the cookies and cream cheesecake that I’ve been looking forward too for a year. The cheesecake has good flavor but over baked so it’s gummy and chewy and not silky and smooth.“

“Love the drinks and a nice atmosphere to chill.“

“I ordered a birthday cake via Uber eats from St. Louis Missouri to be delivered to a friend in Sicklerville and I want to reach out to tell your staff how grateful I am for preparing this cake for this special day. I appreciate your service. Great job. Thank you so much.“

“Best experience at a Friendly’s in a long time. Fast, friendly service. Very clean. Excellent customer service.“

“Everything was perfect the only downside of the whole experience was my friend had gotten a poorly washed cup for his coke (had chocolate sauce inside the rim) and I got a dirty spoon but once we told the waiter it was promptly corrected for us and my friend got a free refill for the error“

“Great ice cream! Love the Reese Blizzard ❤️“

“My sister and I went for her birthday. A few families came in at the same time so it was pretty busy. We sat for a while looking at the menu but we didn’t mind the wait. I forget a waitress’ name but I think it was Nikki. She was very very nice and friendly and made the experience so much better. She was serving everyone but always made sure we were good and if we needed anything. She made my sisters birthday special and the ice cream was delicious. Haven’t been here since I was a kid but it was very nostalgic.“