50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Clayton

“My Favorite place to eat. know the owner since he bought the place from Papi.“

“just had a hoagie with long hot ...omg, soooo good. you need to put long hots as an option on your pizza. you will love it“

“Little Jim’s has been our go-to for take out since we moved to the area! Everything we have tried has all been delicious! We personally love the cheesesteaks, salads, burgers, and pizza of course. All fresh, large portions, and quick delivery! Thank you!“

“you guy did my sons law school graduation party's Saturday with the rain and all . the guy guys were excellent and the pizza was great THANK-YOU“

“We enjoyed our first dinner at Santini’s last night. It was very very good. 👍👍 Loved the salad bar and our entree choices. The staff were very friendly and accommodating. Menu was reasonably priced. Can’t wait to go back. You need to give it a try, you won’t be disappointed. ❤️❤️“

“Absolutely incredible customer service from the staff. The food was amazing. Definitely will be returning and telling my buddies about this spot!!!“

“Dynamite thin crust pizza top notch Key lime pie 14 on a one to ten“

“This is my #1 go to spot. Antonio and his crew make the best pizza! We enjoy everything on their menu, pizza, wings, salads and sandwiches. Great place reasonably priced and quality food. You have to try Capri! We even like Sal! 😂😂“

“I am obsessed with Gallery Pizza! Ever since I moved to south jersey I was scouting for the best local pizza joint and I am so happy I found Gallery. Every single order is done perfectly, fresh, hot, and on time! All the staff are very kind and attentive. The pizza is amazing! We have tried so many different items here and enjoy every last bite! Keep up the amazing work, this is definitely the best pizza in the area! 5 stars all around and you are missing out if you dont come here.“

“Best pizza in the whole area family owned and operated.we go here twice a week“

“Good food, friendly people“

“ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS PLACE food is great owner makes you like at home and their pizza is crispy and thin sooooooo delicious my new favorite place!!“

“Amazing pizza and the BEST service!! Every time we’re in the area, we are sure to stop by!!“

“The food was bad and sentient. Took me weeks to get and finish the food. The 4th floor was dirty and 5th was spooky, Italian man running through, with giant rats. At the top there was a laser thing and a face made of pizza. It was very weird but I loved the experience. 10/10 would recommend best indie restaurant“

“Man, let me tell you — Genova’s Pizza is hittin’! Soon as you walk in, they treat you like family, not just another customer. The vibe is cool, the people are down-to-earth, and the food? Straight fire.

That crust stay crispy, the sauce got that rich, homemade flavor, and the cheese pull is crazy. Every bite tastes fresh — you can tell they ain’t cuttin’ corners. Even the simple pepperoni slice go hard, but those specialty pies? Next level.

And the wings? Bruh… they don’t play about those. Juicy, seasoned right, crispy on the outside, tender on the inside — the kind that make you forget to grab napkins ’til it’s too late. Perfect with the pizza, perfect on their own.

Big portions, fair prices, fast service — Genova’s got it all. If you love pizza AND wings, this the spot. Period.“

“ALWAYS delicious and hands down the best pizza! Delicious food, prompt delivery and great customer service!! Thank you Epiros!“

“We recently moved to the williamstown area and had a hard time finding a pizza place until we came across Tuscan Pizza. They are fantastic and amazing customer service. We asked for paper plates the one time, the driver left without them but received a call from Tuscan apologized for this and said they sent another driver by to deliver the plates. They literally arrived minutes late almost the exact same time as the pizza. This is just a small sample of their service. Top notch and amazing pizza!“

“Love the bar. Great food and service, but the Techno music is is annoying!“

“Everything we have ordered has been fabulous. My personal favorite are the homemade soups--they are my go to dinner on a busy night or a chilly day. I felt under the weather today and ordered the chicken orzo soup. It came piping hot with warm fresh rolls....just what I needed! And of course...finish off with a cannoli!“

“Just ordered first time since moving here… they are fantastic! Fresh food, delicious, like you’re in your mom’s kitchen! The roast pork and broccoli rabe, omg!!! I called to tell them how awesome it was! Very nice young man delivered and even nicer manager, Nicky. We will make them our go to place and please try them, you will be very satisfied ! Outstanding food and service!“

“Always a good meal at Select! From their wings to their cheesesteaks to their lettuce wraps to their other sandwiches, we have not had a bad meal here so far.

I would really like their ordering system to be a little more robust to accept things like notes on a particular sandwich or extra meat or some things like that“

“food is always good big portions good help Price is Right I highly recommend Nick's tell Gene and April sent you“

“went three times- got the runs. maybe "clean out" would be better name“

“Amazing Pizza. Really well made. The Cheese was just right, the sauce was just enough to have taste but not overwhelming. The crust was soft yet not undercooked or chewy. It taste like it was made with care and love and not rushed unlike some places. I have had many pizzas over the years and the pizza from this place is top tier. Well worth the price. Highly recommend.“

“Overall 5 stars,This is their carnivore pizza without bacon. We also had their white Detroit pizza, I would rate 7/10, room for improvement for the price I think added ricotta would have been an amazing benefit. There is another establishment we usually frequent but I think I just found the best pizza in twp“

“Very delicious 😋 pizza and chicken sandwich“

“Ordered Rustica and was not disappointed. Pizza crust was perfect, crispy, and amazing. The best Tiramisu I have ever had. I was also able to order a bottle from local winery. I enjoyed watching them prepare the food also. It was like dinner and a show.“

“First time in. Was in the mood for pizza! Stopped in to order and then did some food shopping a couple stores down. Came back afterwards to pick it up. It was ready to go and it was DELICIOUS!!! Owner was very nice too. I will be back next time I go food shopping!“

“The pizza is out of this world good. We usually order a Sicilian or a regular large Pie.“

“sandwiches , pizza, wings done to your liking and quick!“

“Excellent food and a huge selection! The people are great!“

“I order from you guys every week just about. I really loved your plan pizza, but you seemed to have changed it. It used to be saucy on top, and now it’s just all cheese. your plain pizza was my FAVORITE. Please consider going back to what it used to be. No one else in the area had a pizza like that.“

“Went for the first time last night, it’s been on the “todo” list for a while. This place is clean, not overpriced at all, and the staff is incredibly friendly. The food was quite delicious as well. The wait for food was a little bit, but who cares when your little people are playing on the pirate ship.“

“Great pizza as always. Young man who took my order was great. Asked if they could bring the pizza to my car as I use a walker and would be difficult to pick up. He said no problem. Called when I arrived and he brought it right out to me. Great customer service.“

“We moved to the area 2 years ago and couldn't really find a stand out pizza place. We didn't know about this place at first because they don't deliver but we got recommended by some friends. I am so glad we did because this place makes great pizza! The kind of place that doesn't need to deliver because the food is amazing and worth picking up. We will be here a lot!“

“Best pizza in the area. Nice employees.

Please review your menu and online prices. It can be confusing for customers because on several products the prices are different. I even confirmed the price on a large Sicilian pizza. Yet was charged a different price when I picked up in-person.

Parking lot is strange.“

“The absolute Best thin crust pizza in all of South NJ. The sauce is very tasty, premium toppings and good portions of them. I have never been a fan of the crust on any pizza but this crust is a treat“

“Went here last night with 16 people and everything was amazing from service to main course, the main reason why I am writing this review is because my seafood Fra Diavolo was absolutely amazing I will go back and order this again and again and again what a great place I highly recommend this place“

“Not sure how I never gave them a review before but this place has by far my favorite pizza ever. I moved away a few years back but when I'm down visiting, I have to stop here for my pizza! Never had a negative experience at this place.“

“Saw this place on the slice app and decided to give it a try. I am totally addicted to their rice balls. The best I ever had! Service is fast the foods always hot and I highly recommend the rice ball platter“

“Ordered 2 cheeseburgers for delivery on 8/13/2025 at 2:02 pm. They arrived at 3:29! Ice cold burgers and French Fries! I called up and asked for refund . I was told baaically NO! We will give you $15 off your next COLD meal! $52 for meal plus delivery & $10 tip for 2 burgers & Fries! Very unhappy. Will never order from this place again!“

“Best pizza in Sewell Williamstown area not even close. Gravy is sweet, not acidic.“

“The pizza is divine! I love that I work around the corner from you. Your pizzas 🍕 helped us get through the Summer since I had no desire to cook in the heat. Highly recommend this pizzeria. The crust is the amazing.“

“The food here is amazing!!! I highly recommend their nachos and tacos. I know it's a pizza joint, but the quality and flavor of their Mexican dishes is a real hidden gem!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Danny's Pizza Pizzazz is a fantastic staple in Franklinville! The food is always fresh, and the traditional staff make the experience even more enjoyable with their warm hospitality. What I love most is the inviting atmosphere; it’s the perfect place to sit down and savor your slice in comfort.

They also offer delicious soups and desserts, which add to the overall dining experience. If you're looking for a great meal in a welcoming setting, I highly recommend Danny's Pizza Pizzazz!

Parking: Plenty of parking!

Kid-friendliness: Kid & family friendly!

Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible“

“We order from Sals 1-2 times every week and have tried pretty much everything on the menu. Our favorites are the cheesesteak, chicken parm sandwich, chicken Cesar salad and buffalo chicken pizza. The wings are very good too- Especially if you get the garlic buffalo sauce. They seem to have the most reasonable prices around too. Everyone that works there is friendly and the food is made quickly. I highly recommend Sals!“

“We had an incredible experience at Salvatore’s Pizza in Monroville! We ordered the eggplant parm sandwich, meat lovers pizza, and chicken wings, and each item was fantastic.The eggplant parm sandwich was perfect—was crisp on the outside, soft on the inside, flavorful, Not greasy!!The meat lovers pizza was packed with generous toppings and delicious!!!And the chicken wings? The chicken wings were a fantastic surprise. I didn’t expect wings this good from a pizza place! The food was prepared quickly, and the staff was super friendly. If you’re in Monroville and looking for great pizza and Italian comfort food, Salvatore’s is a must-try! Highly recommend!“

“It’s wild that I am just now reviewing Attilio’s Pizza! They are truly a staple piece in Pitman. Just a classic pizzeria! I love getting slices or candy to go as well dining in with my boyfriend. We can enjoy great food and people watch. It’s cozy as hell. I would choose Attilio’s any day over the “fancier” restaurants in town. Prices are totally affordable. Food is so good. I could go on & on about how amazing the sicillian pizza is, oh my god I’m actually obsessed. I also appreciate seeing kids have a place to go & grab a bite. What a dream, I would’ve killed to have a pizza place within walking distance that I could hit up with my friends as a kid/teen. Awesome place, awesome ownership, awesome workers, awesome food. Well done!“

“I am all about promoting and patronizing local businesses, and those who know me are aware of that and can verify that I never post negative anything about local businesses, until now. I received a menu with prices in the mail today offering delivery....I went on line to order and was taken to door dash which adds about $3.00 per item vs the menu I received plus charge a delivery fee. I then tried just going on Mannino's website which is powered by Slice and they also add an average of $2.50 per item vs the menu (I didn't get far enough into order to see if there is a delivery fee). Confused I called Mannino's and what a treat that was, I asked if they offered delivery from the store, well no one is here so use the on line ordering, I mentioned about being taken to Door Dash and Slice along with the price increases and delivery fees with a response of NOT their problem. I was also told to pick up my own food or don't order from them and was hung up on. This coming from the business that had a menu placed in my mailbox to solicitate more business. I can't testify to the quality of their food but can tell you they definitely lack in customer service and phone manners. Needless to say this is one local business I won't be patronizing.“

“Just tried the pizza for the first time and it did not disappoint! Can’t wait to order for the whole family!“