50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mullica Hill

“Amazing pizza and the BEST service!! Every time we’re in the area, we are sure to stop by!!“

“We’ve been going to this pizza shop for years, even before Alex took over. Alex has always been the friendly face that greets you when you walked in the door. He always says hello and asks how you are doing. On many occasions he will even tell you to grab yourself a 2 liter on your way out the door. No charge. Just an overall friendly guy and the pizza is delicious. Honestly, you will enjoy anything they make for you, and now if you have a taste for pizza and your hubby wants tacos, there’s no need to go anywhere else, he does it all. The girls he has working behind the counter and the other cooks are always lovely as well. A real neighborhood pizza joint.“

“Love the bar. Great food and service, but the Techno music is is annoying!“

“We like their food. For a restaurant in the middle of nowhere, they're fresh, unusual, and innovative. A great place for lunch after picking fruit at Mood's Farm.“

“Ella es muy amable,su pizza es sabrosa y sus ingredientes son naturales y habla español“

“I used America's Pie as the cater for my in laws 50th wedding anniversary. This place deserves 10 ⭐️. Mechele was great to work with! George the owner packaged our order and packed it so neat and loaded my car. My only regret is not taking pictures of the presentation. Food was delicious; presentation was straight out of a magazine presentation. The price so was reasonable- I almost feel like I robbed them for how good the food was and the price I paid. Easiest process from ordering to pick up. The guest at our party raved about the food. The desserts were so scrumptious everyone went for seconds! There isn't a bad thing I can say about this place-except that we got way too much food! I highly recommend them for your next party! You would be a fool to go anywhere else! Thank you America's Pie! You have a customer for life! ❤️“

“Finally stopped in after hearing good things about the pizza. It is a good pizza. Tight, thin crust with a good crisp. Flavor is on point. I would rate this pie a 7.7. I consider that to be a reputable score, as most DelCo pizza is in the 6's. I also got a cheesesteak. Also very good! Flavor of this steak is superb. Balanced amount of meat, cheese, onion. It's not huge, but this steak, an order of fries, and a drink, you will leave full. The staff are friendly, and everything looks clean. I mean, it is a shed basically. But a very clean shed. Lol. Prices are also very, very reasonable. Definitely worth a try!“

“My Favorite place to eat. know the owner since he bought the place from Papi.“

“Best Panzerotti and Pizza in NJ... Food is ALWAYS Hot and Delicious! Service is ALWAYS on point! The Atmosphere is welcoming to one and all! Sal, the owner, is an outstanding guy! Thank you Topo Gigio... Will be back again Very Soon! 😎👍🇺🇸

Parking: Family run and owned.

Kid-friendliness: Family and Kid Friendly!

Wheelchair accessibility: Disabilities accessible 😎👍🇺🇸♿️“

“The food here is great and the delivery syis even better. Their pizza is always fresh, with the perfect crispy crust and delicious flavor. The flavors are authentic and really capture the taste of classic Italian pizza. It had it's own vibe to it, awesome place for some Italian cuisine.“

“Highly recommend! Nick and his team went above and beyond to bring food to a family in need! I always love the food and now this family can enjoy too! 🍕 👍🏻“

“Pizza amazing. Tuesday special is such a deal. Thank you“

“We enjoyed our first dinner at Santini’s last night. It was very very good. 👍👍 Loved the salad bar and our entree choices. The staff were very friendly and accommodating. Menu was reasonably priced. Can’t wait to go back. You need to give it a try, you won’t be disappointed. ❤️❤️“

“Great food. Great people. I’ve been eating there since I was 10 years old and I don’t think I’ve ever been disappointed with my food. I don’t know if I can say that about anywhere else I’ve ordered food from multiple times. Take that for what you will, but it is the truth.“

“The food was different. Highly recommend the Buffalo chicken cheese steak.“

“Fantastic food and awesome service!“

“Thank you so much for helping me keep my Mom inside for food during this horrible weather. Your delivery service and food is the best. She especially loves the Glassboro special.“

“It was close to closing time and I placed a small order online when I went to pick it up the lady told my husband there was no order but we have the proof he showed her and they made it even though it was past 10pm the owner is so nice and friendly, the food was delicious. They definitely our their customers first.“

“Everything I’ve gotten there has been delicious. My favorite is chicken cutlet with long hots and sharpe provolone on a seeded roll, which isn’t on the menu but they will make for you. Also the breakfast sandwiches are the best around, nobody comes close.“

“I’m blown away. Seemingly nondescript pizza place in a strip mall. The staff is attentive and extremely nice. There’s not an empty seat in the house. About 12 tables all full. Chicken parm sandwich is delicious. Gem of a local spot where I hoped to get a quick bite.

One other thing about the staff is that there are a good number of special needs customers and elderly customers and the staff is accommodating and very sweet to all of them.“

“Just moved to town so trying out new places I haven’t yet before. This is a 5/5 place! They have amazing customer service. The owner is a retired firefighter. American respect signs all over the wall which was a nice touch! 🇺🇸 the pizza I got was delicious!!!! 🤤 🍕 we will definitely be back!“

“Consistently delicious food and the owner is a gem who does a lot for our community.“

“Just picked up 2 dinners and a Med pizza, the med pizza ticket didnt get printed, said will be 6-8 min. They said “you know what get him a lg and on his way” They were busy with the Deptford Spartan Marching Band fund raiser. Great customer service!! Ken S“

“YOUR BOARDWALK PIZZA👍👌😋IS THE ABSOLUTE BEST!! Delicious💥 I drive from Pa and there is NOTHING AROUND LIKE THIS!! So good!“

“Ordered Rustica and was not disappointed. Pizza crust was perfect, crispy, and amazing. The best Tiramisu I have ever had. I was also able to order a bottle from local winery. I enjoyed watching them prepare the food also. It was like dinner and a show.“

“After 32 years out of NJ pizza has been disappointing. So now that I am in NJ for work until July, my quest is to eat 2 slices of cheese pizza at every place the locals recommend. Today, it's Joe's, and they did not disappoint!!! Highly recommend to any visitor and other locals. The test of good pizza is the point folds off the plate and it leaves a nice red oily stain on the paper plate...both were spot perfect...the crust was perfect, the cheese was gooey and flavor top notch. if I work in the area tomorrow, it's calzone or stromboli!!“

“We stopped in for dinner and drinks.. They Did Not Disappoint! The customer service was amazing! We had Emily and she was super sweet, she keep checking to make sure we were okay and just made everything even more awesome. Our food .... I wanted to go back the next day! It was absolutely delicious. The appetizers just were the roll of red carpet greatness! Everything tasted great and left you wanting more. Everything has the fire grilled taste, and we had leftovers! I loved the drink menu! They had seasonal drinks and a bunch of cool cocktail drinks to order, i tried a few and they were all really good! But there is something about their espresso martini.... lol give me another! The bartender was on point!! Didn't get his name but I hope he's making my drinks when I get back there!“

“Delicious Food Wonderful staff“

“went three times- got the runs. maybe "clean out" would be better name“

“the best in the business 🍕“

“Today was our first time here.
Service: Wow! Amazing!
Food: Delish and well presented! We had pizza, Bavarian pretzel, BLT, wings wine and beer. Great prices which does not break your wallet.
Atmosphere: Great local bar but a tad too dark at the booths. They have billiards tables as well as a spot for a DJ. Highly recommend and definitely coming back.“

“Delicious food and very friendly staff. Thank You guys for everything 🙂“

“I love ordering their Italian hoagie. I’ve be in West Deptford for 17 years and Vinny’s hoagies are the best in West Deptford.“

“I typically order the Detroit style pizza, which is always fantastic from the sauce to the crust to the caramelized cheese edge- never disappoints! But, I have to throw the limelight of this review onto their cheesesteaks. All I can say is, “WOW!” I ordered the cheesesteak on their homemade, sesame seeded sub roll with cooper sharp, fried onions, and banana peppers. The meat, cheese, and veggies were spectacular (all in more than generous proportions), but that roll stole the show!!! I am a huge bread snob, and I cannot get over how great the bread is (flavorful dough, airy inside, crust baked perfectly, and enough seeds to happily feed a small village). I gotta give this family a ton of credit- they have carbs, among other things of course, figured out!!! Also, you should follow them on your favorite social media platform- the family is hilarious.“

“I had a menu in my mail from this place and decided to try them. I'm really glad I did. I ordered two cheese steaks and two orders of cheese fries. The cheesesteaks were very full of meat and the serving size of the french fries could have fed three people! Delivery was fast, food was hot and delicious.“

“Everything we have ordered has been fabulous. My personal favorite are the homemade soups--they are my go to dinner on a busy night or a chilly day. I felt under the weather today and ordered the chicken orzo soup. It came piping hot with warm fresh rolls....just what I needed! And of course...finish off with a cannoli!“

“The food was bad and sentient. Took me weeks to get and finish the food. The 4th floor was dirty and 5th was spooky, Italian man running through, with giant rats. At the top there was a laser thing and a face made of pizza. It was very weird but I loved the experience. 10/10 would recommend best indie restaurant“

“The food, service, and atmosphere are excellent. I highly recommend eating here. The prices are equally as good.“

“Love love love not only the food because everything was amazing...but let me tell you how the owner , her daughter, the other workers they all treated us like family. I felt like I was in my aunts house in Italy. they really go above and beyond. we will definitely come back again . ❤️“

“food here is so ....v2 the grill chicken with pesto arugula and fresh mozzarella is my favorite....people have said the workers are rude however I think they are just misunderstood....they are very nice people ...I think because they are Italian with accents people mistake them for being rude... they work very hard and provide great food“

“This Christmas Eve, I had the pleasure of dining at this Cicontes. The atmosphere was cozy and festive and our service was excellent. Their rolls are delicious, chewy and crusty with an olive oil dip. Dinners came with soup or salad. The salads were generous and fresh. The soup was a tasty large serving of Lentil soup. Everyone enjoyed their dinners. My Chicken Francese was so good! I was able to only eat half and save the rest for leftovers. Dessert was tasty as well, we tried the cannolis and ricotta cheesecake. Such a worthwhile place to enjoy a real meal. And don’t forget it’s BYOB! Looking forward to going back again!“

“food is always good big portions good help Price is Right I highly recommend Nick's tell Gene and April sent you“

“Always quick delivery and good food! My family enjoys it usually weekly.“

“Consistently on point, never disappoints. My husband and I always joke when we open the pizza box “They had the A team on again.”Best in the area. The pickle pizza is phenomenal. Quality ingredients, and a great tasting Honey Hot sauce.“

“Got invited here for a lunch meeting, walked in and realized that this is a special place! Sat at the booth, opened the menu and was blown away by selection.

Tried the beef sliders appetizer, those were amazing! And of course I had to try the Tuna Bowl, it was unreal! Loved the taste, the sauce was unreal!

Great job over all, this is a place that I must come back to! Highly recommend!“

“We had a great time with the grandkids. They enjoyed the food and the games.“

“I have been going to Santinos since they opened. There is a new manager named Bre. What a difference since she took over. The service on Sunday is unbelievable great. The servers Vanessa, Mylee, and Cant forget Shea. I will not go anywhere else!!!“

“Very delicious 😋 pizza and chicken sandwich“

“The pizza steak was really really good and the blt was good“

“Great good & quick service. Indoor and outdoor seating!“