Colonia Pizza
325 Inman Ave, Colonia
(732) 381-5150
Menu
Photos
+16 photos
+15 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Colonia Pizza is our family’s go-to spot! We order from here all the time, whether it’s pickup or delivery, and they never disappoint. The pizza is always fresh, delicious, and consistently great. My kids absolutely love it, which says a lot! The service is friendly, and our orders are always ready on time or delivered promptly. We’re so happy to have such a reliable local pizza place. Highly recommend!
Local place. Been going there for 20 years. And in those 20 years I can't say anything has changed, and I mean nothing. Same tables, same paint, same signs, with the exception of taped on price changes. Pizza is good for the most part, but that depends on who's behind the counter. They do have a really good vodka sauce, but the pizza is hit or miss. Sometimes its hot and cheesy, sometimes it's as if they warmed up a pie someone forgot to pick up. And then there's...
Colonia Pizza is seriously underrated on Google—I have no idea why it doesn’t have way more reviews. This place deserves at least 200+ reviews with a solid 4–5 star rating, minimum. Out of all the pizza spots in Colonia, this is hands-down my first choice. Growing up in Brooklyn, I know good pizza when I taste it, and I can assure you their pizza is top notch.
You May Also Like
Colonia Pizza - 325 Inman Ave
![]()
Pizza, Vegetarian
COLONIA BBQ - 330 Inman Ave
![]()
Portuguese, Barbeque
Filipino Foodmart - 322 Inman Ave
![]()
Filipino