50 Best Italian Restaurants near Columbus

“Great Pizza! Especially Their Chicken Ranch!“

“Food was amazing !! Must check out“

“Best Italian Food in All of Trenton/Mercer County“

“Amore is wonderful. I had an amazing dinner. Calamari was on point with perfect sauce. Onion soup was super delicious. Rich, thick broth was awesome. Crab ravioli and rack of lamb specials were incredibly enjoyable. Ended with the cheesecake. YUM! I can't wait to return and try more dishes.“

“Wonderful Italian food and beautiful atmosphere had take out plenty of times, and always good no matter what day of the week and we had a wonderful waiter Steven last night.“

“Last Friday I coordinated an event for 100 People at the Mayor's Ball. La Galleria did an amazing job from the initial set up, to catering an abundance of delicious food which everyone enjoyed. The servers were extraordinary. They truly went above and beyond to make the event special. Highly recommend La Galleria for anyone looking to cater their event!!!!!!“

“First time dining at Spigola's and it was terrific. Surprised to find a wonderful full service bar in a restaurant located among strip stores. Usually strip store restaurants are B.Y.O.B. Menu is quite varied and was accompanied by a special menu. My wife and I opted for entrees on the special menu which were superb. I love Halibut and it was prepared exquisitely. Dining experience deserved the five stars given. Our service was spot on.“

“My family and I have been coming to Non Solo for years for their authentic Italian delicious food. Recently I was diagnosed with Celiac disease and tried Non Solo's gluten free pasta at the owners suggestion. It was fabulous and I had no reactions. I can't wait to go back and try more. Thank you Jerry“

“This was one of the best crews that I have worked with…. All of the employees give customers the best possible experience… Authentic Italian food… everyone takes pride in doing what they do!!!!! Extremely clean, and serve things that is above average!!!!! Great restaurant all around“

“Have had dinner there several times with friends and everyone has always been most complimentary of meals served. I have personally enjoyed the shrimp and scallops as well as stuffed flounder. Also ordered for take out catering trays of chicken and penne vodka for a family event which were wonderful. Great place with a strong menu and terrific meals. Also ordered several catered dinners for my family including chicken Marcella and penne vodka.“

“Everything was amazing from start to finish. Well decorated upscale restaurant. The service was amazing, our waiter Jerry was simply overall the best. The menu has plenty to choose from and there were about 4 or 5 special appetizers and dinners. One of my favorite things is that the food courses came out spaced apart. We had time during each course to enjoy our food, finish and enjoy our drinks and talk before the next course. It was spaced out perfectly“

“I tell everybody this place is great. Try somthing new on the menue. You never know unless you try.“

“We got their menu in our mailbox last week. Tried them tonight and we enjoyed their food very much. Nice thin crispy crust, nicely seasoned sauce, nice amount of cheese and toppings. A definite "recommend" !“

“Visited here for lunch with my children as we were passing through NJ on our way home from a holiday visit with family. Saw the great reviews and decided to try it out. We got Italian subs and pizza. The subs were absolutely delicious. Crisp, toasted bread, fresh meat and veggies, yummy sauce. We all loved them. And the pizzas were great too! We will make this a regular stop whenever passing through NJ again.“

“We had a Birthday party here oct 5, 2024 in a private room and we were very pleased with everything from the food to the service. Our servers were fabulous!!!! would definitely recommend to everyone.“

“Had our reunion dinner there last night. The food was outstanding and our waitress was tremendous. She did a fantastic job.“

“First time dining at diamonds. Everything was absolutely delicious. The fried calamari had some spicy hot peppers in it with a marinara sauce. It was so good my husband had his favorite chicken Parmesan with Bolognese sauce super scrumptious, and I had the beef Wellington with pasta. it was absolutely outstanding. We will definitely be back . Thank you so much for a wonderful experience.“

“Best Pizza on town…Very friendly and Nice people“

“We ordered a tray of Chicken Parmigiana with vodka sauce for Christmas Eve dinner. It was absolutely amazing. We finished off with cannolis which were huge and so delicious! Romeo is the best, whatever you want, he will do!“

“great dinner with friends tonight. waitress actually remembered us from a few months ago. thank you for the great food and service. salmon was delicious!“

“The food is great; the owners are friendly, all around good people! I’d recommend this place for take out or private parties!! My husband loves the pizza 🍕 💕“

“You will always see this place full of happy returning patrons and we are two of them. Food quality is fresh, tasty and reasonably priced. You have to try their Brick Oven pizzas. If you crave an American cheese hoagie, that is prepared on the best tasting roll in New Jersey, delicious cheese, and crisp lettuce and onions, try one of theirs. The very best that we have ever judged.“

“Best Pizza in The Area!! 🙌“

“The pizza with shrimp garlic and mushroom was the best I ever had !!!“

“Once again, Mario and Franks II comes through for my family and me. We needed advice on a catering package for a funeral luncheon where we were very unsure of the number of people coming. They worked with over the course of the week as the numbers changed and could not have been nicer. Of course as always the food was amazing and I tell everyone that will listen that if they ever need a caterer they are by far the best. My wife and I also love coming in for a quiet dinner too and we always know it’s going to be great. Thanks to the whole team for helping us with our event.“

“Had a party for 30+ people. Everything was first class! Food was out of this world, service great, atmosphere nice. Manager was great to work with. All my guest raved about the food. I Just discovered this place in December and it is by far my favorite place!!“

“Celebrated my wife's birthday last weekend. Food was delicious, service was excellent...we will be back!!“

“Food is delicious and we had the best service ever there!!“

“this place has a amazing tomato pie“

“GREAT SERVICE/STAFF...GREAT FOOD. Good people all around.“

“Sunday bike ride then pizza for lunch“

“Pepperoni pizza was delicious. First time stopping in, the slices weren’t selling me but I ordered a plain & a pepperoni and my first bite I was sold I didn’t even have to add garlic!! Will be back“

“Food was cooked to perfection and staff are great! Perfect Thursday Night Jazz 🎵🎶 Guest with music and vocal talent are welcome to join in ❤️“

“Great Italian food and service.“

“Not the fanciest of places but definitely one of the friendliest . My wife and I were pretty hungry and heard really good things about the meatballs so we each ordered one . The portions were so big that one would have been enough and they didn’t disappoint ! We will be back ?“

“Huge shoutout to Angelo’s tonight. Only wish I would’ve remembered my server’s name, to give her extra recognition here. We went out for an important dinner tonight. We were celebrating something small, but meaningful. When we called they had no reservations available for the evening, but then called us back and squeezed us in at 4:30. The power went out in the entire city after we were served our first course. We were served our entrees in the dark, with the same elegance, as of nothing had occurred. Even with the unfortunate circumstances, we were treated like royalty by the entire staff, and had an exceptional dining experience. I will be dreaming of the escarole, until I have it again. Thank you Angelo’s! Great job! 👏🏽“

“We stopped at one of those amazing places that you see on Instagram yesterday and they had no selection . We stopped at Carluccis and they had a full case of pizza selections to choose from , the steak and pepper pizza was amazing as well as the chicken bacon ranch , usually places use too much ranch not here , the pizza was the focus . My wife had a traditional slice and said the sauce was excellent . Your staff was super friendly and what also who I believe was the manager was awesome and made us aware of your in house special . We will be back for sure .
Thank You“

“Great dishes Your son is incretable“

“What Amazing food and staff!“

“Excellent, food , Leonardo was great, thank you .“

“Best homemade Italian food We had the grandmom pizza, the eggplant parmigiana,the chicken parmigiana, the cheese steak and the homemade fresh mozzarella, was the best we never had!! Try Bella's you will be very impressed,“

“Love the food here! Friendly atmosphere and the service is always great 😊“

“Best 🍕 Pizza in So. Trenton !!!“

“i love their food. it never disappoints. everything is so good. pizza, sandwiches, chicken fingers, etc. everything ive tried so far is really good. sometimes the wait for delivery is an hour, but my food is still hot when it gets here! i really love this place!“

“One of the best around. I’m glad V&S was taken over by professionals!!“

“Everything was delicious. The pizza is so good! Food was served extremely quickly. Dinner for three, including an appetizer, two sodas, one glass of wine, and three pizzas was about seventy dollars.“

“Excellent food and service as always! Highly recommend“

“A local classic! Rocco's has been serving amazing pizza for decades. A staple of Florence Township!“

“What can you really say... It's Pizza, they do make a good pizza. The problem is the area has so many pizza shops around, it is hard to pick on a place. What I find is the place is small, and you really don't want to go here for lunch. Besides that, I find them to be fast, and the food is very good every time I come here.“