Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream

9314, 381 Main St, West Creek
(609) 294-2600

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Large Cup Soft Chocolate

Dipped Ice Cream Cone

Chocolate Ice Cream

Banana Split

Hot Fudge

Brownie

Sundaes

Our hand dipped "hard" ice cream sundae, including one topping and whipped cream and a cherry. Choose from over 30 flavors or if you can't decide, get crazy with it and mix it up! (For quality purposes, hot toppings and waffle bowl, if selected, will be served on the side. Additional toppings available for extra charge).

Brownie a la Mode

Sometimes, a large just doesn't do it! Our brownie Ala Mode comes in a large banana boat, includes 3 mouthwatering brownie bites, 3 mountains of ice cream (go ahead choose up to 3 flavors), and gobs of hot fudge, caramel or hot peanut. (For quality purposes, hot toppings will be served on the side. Waffle Bowl not applicable for Brownie a la Mode).

Banana Split

This, without a doubt is one of Americas favorite ice cream treats. Our classic banana split is "over the top" yummy. We start with a banana base, 3 mounds of ice cream (soft or hard), 3 toppings of your choice finished with whipped cream and a cherry. Remember, its healthy - there's fruit! (For quality purposes, hot toppings will be served on the side. Waffle bowl not applicable for Banana Split).

Specialty Sundaes

Salty Dog

The original Jeffreeze Specialty Sundae and our BEST SELLER! Vanilla Soft serve, caramel, peanuts, sea salt, hard chocolate dip, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

Nutty Buddy

Vanilla soft serve topped with hot fudge, hot peanut butter, butter fingers, Reese pieces, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

Dark Side

Chocolate soft serve topped with hot fudge, cake crunch, sea salt, chocolate dip, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

Samoa

Chocolate soft serve topped with caramel, hot fudge, toasted coconut, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

Cookie Castle

Vanilla Soft serve topped with hot fudge, chocolate chips, cookie dough bites, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

Dusty Road

Twist soft serve topped with malt powder, hot fudge, oreos, whipped cream and cherry!

Chunky Jeff

Chocolate soft serve topped with sliced banana, hot peanut butter, peanuts, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

PB+J

Throwing it back to your elementary school days! Banana ice cream, cold peanut butter, strawberry topping, whipped cream and a cherry.

Bake Shop

Twist soft serve, hot fudge, warm brownie, WARM chocolate chip cookies, m+m's, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

Drownie Brownie

Half Peanut butter brownie ice cream, half chocolate soft serve topped with brownie dough bites, chocolate chip cookies, hot fudge, hot peanut butter, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

Jersey Turtle

Chocolate soft serve topped with caramel, chocolate syrup, sea salt, pecans, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

Razzle Dazzle

Twist soft serve topped with chocolate syrup, raspberry syrup, chocolate chips, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

Kit-Katasrope

Twist Ice cream topped with warm marshmallow, hot fudge, kit -kats, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

'Pie' Sundae

Vanilla soft serve topped with caramel, graham crackers, your choice of fruit topping (pineapple, strawberry, cherry or apple), whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

Smores

Vanilla soft serve, topped with hot fudge, warm marshmallow, graham cracker, chocolate chips, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

Cup of Dirt

Chocolate soft serve topped with hot fudge, oreos, gummy worms, whipped cream and a cherry (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

Almond Joy

Hard Coconut Ice cream topped with hot fudge, almonds, whipped cream and a cherry. (**Waffle bowl is an upgrade and not included in standard sundae order**)

Blizzards

Blizzard

Our Blizzard is a blend of our delicious soft serve ice cream (Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist) mixed perfectly with generous scoops of a topping of your choice.

Apple Pie Blizzard

Vanilla Soft serve with crushed graham crackers, hot caramel, and apple pie topping mixed in!

Kit Kat Blizzard

Vanilla soft serve blended with strawberry syrup, white coconut flakes, and kit-kats!

Paddy Blizzard

Girl Scout Cookie Lovers, REJOICE! Vanilla soft serve mixed with mint syrup, chocolate chips, with crushed Thin a Mint cookies!

Banana-nana Blizzard

Jeffreeze's take on Chunky Monkey! Vanilla soft serve mixed with cold peanut butter, chocolate chips, and chopped up bananas.

Shakes

Soft Ice Cream Milk Shake

If we're honest, our milkshakes are the ROCKSTARS of our menu. Try one out for yourself...you'll see what we mean! Soft Ice Cream shake flavors are Vanilla, Chocolate, Twist, and Black and White.

Hard Ice Cream Milk Shake

If we're honest, our milkshakes are the ROCKSTARS of our menu. Try one out for yourself...you'll see what we mean! Pick any of our hard ice cream flavors!

Malt

Add some malt powder to your shake for some nutty, extra-milky flavor that is absolutely addictive!!!

Mango Tango Shake

Allow us to transport you to a tropical island with the Mango Tango! Mango water ice mixed with vanilla soft serve, bananas, strawberry topping, and pineapple topping, finished with whipped cream and a cherry! (20 oz)

Creamsicle Shake

Vanilla Soft serve mixed with orange soda.(20 oz)

Paddy Shake

Get your Irish on with our Paddy Shake. It is a delicious (20 oz) minty flavor shake that will be your "pot of gold" drizzled with fudge and topped with a thin mint cookie. Made with vanilla soft serve

Pina Colada

If you like getting caught in the rain, chances are, you're going to love Jeffreeze's Pina Colada Shake! Coconut ice cream & crushed pineapple. (20 oz)

Floats

Jefflati

Soft serve ice cream and Italian ice - the best of both worlds! Your choice of soft serve ice cream layered with your choice of water ice. Choose from Cherry, Rainbow, Cotton Candy-Bubblegum, Mango, Tropical Rainbow, and Watermelon Ice.

Shirley Temple Float

Jeffreeze's take on a classic! Soft Serve vanilla ice cream with sprite and cherry juice. (Float may be delivered with soda packaged separately for quality purposes)

Root Beer Float

This is the classic root beer float, a crowd pleaser.

Drinks

Soda

Water

Quarts

Soft Serve Quart

The best way to ensure you never run out of your favorite Jeffreeze flavors :) Your choice of vanilla, chocolate, or twist soft serve!

Hard Ice Cream Quart

The best way to ensure you never run out of your favorite Jeffreeze flavors :) Your choice of hard ice cream.

Pies

Soft ice Cream Pie

Grab a Jeffreeze Pie for your next celebration! Pie flavor availability subject to inventory levels. Flavors include Cookie Castle, Nutty Buddy, Fudge Crunch, Samoa, Dark Side of Spoon, and Cup of Dirt. Pies need very little thawing so dive right in. Serves 12 easily or 1, no judging here!!!

Sundae Boxes

Standard - 4 Servings Box

This "Make Your Own Sundae at Home" box includes either A. 4 small soft serve cups or B. 1 quart of ice cream (soft or hard) and any 3 toppings listed here: Rainbow Sprinkles, Chocolate Sprinkles, syrups, cake crunch, or gummies. Box includes 4 regular or sugar cones. Cherrys included in box.

Standard - 6 Servings Box

This "Make Your Own Sundae at Home" box includes either A. 6 small soft serve cups or B. 2 quart of ice cream and any 4 toppings listed here; Rainbow Sprinkles, Chocolate Sprinkles, syrups, cake crunch, or gummies. Box includes 6 regular or sugar cones. Cherrys included in box.

Premium - 4 Servings Box

This "Make Your Own Sundae at Home" box includes either A. 4 small cups (soft or hard) or B. 1 quart of ice cream (soft or hard) and any 4 toppings. Box includes 4 regular or sugar cones. Cherries included in box.

Premium - 6 Servings Box

This "Make Your Own Sundae at Home" box includes either A. 6 small cups or B. 2 quarts of ice cream (soft or hard) and any 5 toppings. Box includes 6 regular or sugar cones. Cherries included in box.

Gold - 4 Servings Box

This "Make Your Own Sundae at Home" box includes either A. 4 small cups (soft or hard) or B) 2 quarts of ice cream (soft or hard) and any 4 toppings. Box includes 4 cake, waffle, sugar, or specialty cones. Cherries included in box.

Gold - 6 Servings Box

This "Make Your Own Sundae at Home" box includes either A. 6 small cups (soft or hard) or B. 3 quarts of ice cream (soft or hard) and any 5 toppings. Box includes 6 cake, waffle, sugar, or specialty cones. Cherries included in box.

Photos

+59 photos

+58 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Grubhub

Dine

Recent Reviews

Best darn ice cream!!! Absolutely loved my Cinnamon Bun Sundae. I also tried their S'mores flovor and am absolutely coming back tomorrow for my fill of that summer deliciousness! A must grab if you're in the area!!!

June 2026

They don't make their own ice cream, but what makes them special is what they do with it. Their sundaes are excellent. My favorite is the Drownie Brownie. When I ant unique or innovative ice cream flavors, I will go somewhere else. But when I want to have the best and most satisfying sundae, this is where I go. The quality is excellent and it' just a fun place to visit.

December 2025

I love the place but I have issues with lactose intolerance wish they offered a lactose free alternative e just plain chocolate or vanilla so I could enjoy a Sunday . Love how they are open year round

February 2025

More Reviews

Jeffreeze Old-Fashioned Ice Cream

Customers' Favorites