I’ve got to be honest, I’ve been coming to Magnificos for decades with friends and my family. And we have always enjoyed their fantastic ice cream and friendly service. However, for some reason they recently took their only “sugar-free” option - no sugar added frozen yogurt, off of their menu. As a type 1 diabetic my sister and I can’t really order and enjoy anything else on their menu. I’m saddened to say I’m done doing business at their otherwise fine establishment…
Sanket Gandhi
This ice cream place is amazing and their flavor are very yummy! The only thing they lack is more seating to enjoy the yummy delicacy.
Gina Dipierro
Friendly staff. Lots of choices. Saw low-fat options but didn't notice suar free or low sugar. Not saying they don't have any, just didn't notice. Fair pricing given the current times. Also offer Dole whips and Italian ices.
Scott Allen
It is ok ice cream. I've had better New Jersey ice cream at Carmen's in Maryland. My wife got mint choc chip soft serve that does not have choch chips in it. I got a vanilla cherry dip in a cup, but there was too much cherry shell as it overpowered everything else.
Richard “Army Veteran”
Good local place for old school ice cream.. Good variety of flavors and always tastes fresh. Our goto place in the summer when we new a cool treat.. It can get busy but well worth the wait.
Jay Peine
Best ice cream in the area!
Daniel DeMiglio
Undeniably the finest ice cream in the entire state. Their vanilla soft serve is on another level, richer, smoother, and more flavorful than anything I’ve ever had. It’s clear why this place has been a beloved landmark since 1981. The secret? A product that speaks for itself, simply unmatched in quality.
William Petroski
Ice cream was very good. Only problem was they allowed an oversized dog into the ordering area and let him put his dirty paws on the counter and serving area. Not sanitary at all.
After passing this place for over a decade, my family finally decided to stop here. We felt it was a bit overpriced and confusing. The ice cream was mid, and the yogurt was watery. For me, it is not worth the 15-minute drive to return, but for a local, it is a decent place to get your frozen dairy dessert.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Halleigh
Vanilla soft serve was decent, but the pistachio and oreo cookie cone were not good at all. The waffle cone was okay. Good service by the people working there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Andy S
This is out-of-the-way for us, but we brought another couple with us for shopping about 15 minutes South. We all miss the toasted almond bars that Good Humor used to make and came upon this place doing a Google search. For those on a similar quest, please be aware that the toasted almond bars are only made to order in advance and in a quantity of 12 or more. We opted for the next best thing, which is the toasted almond crunch in a cup of soft serve vanilla. The texture is much more crunchy than the classic Good Humor version and the bits are a little larger, but the taste is very close. We all ran out of the toast almond crunch topping long before the ice cream. Our thought for a future visit is to get this in an Arctic Swirl to have it more evenly distributed. Would also be great if they had an almond flavored ice cream to go with this. Other items on the menu looked amazing, especially the cakes. The odd person out on this trip had a warm waffle sandwich. That thing was HUGE and she could only eat about half of it. Very messy, but thoroughly enjoyed. We will be back when the weather is warmer since there is no indoor seating.
Icecream is so good and service is great!
Best ice cream around!!!
I’ve got to be honest, I’ve been coming to Magnificos for decades with friends and my family. And we have always enjoyed their fantastic ice cream and friendly service. However, for some reason they recently took their only “sugar-free” option - no sugar added frozen yogurt, off of their menu. As a type 1 diabetic my sister and I can’t really order and enjoy anything else on their menu. I’m saddened to say I’m done doing business at their otherwise fine establishment…
This ice cream place is amazing and their flavor are very yummy! The only thing they lack is more seating to enjoy the yummy delicacy.
Friendly staff. Lots of choices. Saw low-fat options but didn't notice suar free or low sugar. Not saying they don't have any, just didn't notice. Fair pricing given the current times. Also offer Dole whips and Italian ices.
It is ok ice cream. I've had better New Jersey ice cream at Carmen's in Maryland. My wife got mint choc chip soft serve that does not have choch chips in it. I got a vanilla cherry dip in a cup, but there was too much cherry shell as it overpowered everything else.
Good local place for old school ice cream.. Good variety of flavors and always tastes fresh. Our goto place in the summer when we new a cool treat.. It can get busy but well worth the wait.
Best ice cream in the area!
Undeniably the finest ice cream in the entire state. Their vanilla soft serve is on another level, richer, smoother, and more flavorful than anything I’ve ever had. It’s clear why this place has been a beloved landmark since 1981. The secret? A product that speaks for itself, simply unmatched in quality.
Ice cream was very good. Only problem was they allowed an oversized dog into the ordering area and let him put his dirty paws on the counter and serving area. Not sanitary at all.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best ice cream sandwiches on the planet!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
After passing this place for over a decade, my family finally decided to stop here. We felt it was a bit overpriced and confusing. The ice cream was mid, and the yogurt was watery. For me, it is not worth the 15-minute drive to return, but for a local, it is a decent place to get your frozen dairy dessert.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 3
Vanilla soft serve was decent, but the pistachio and oreo cookie cone were not good at all. The waffle cone was okay. Good service by the people working there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
This is out-of-the-way for us, but we brought another couple with us for shopping about 15 minutes South. We all miss the toasted almond bars that Good Humor used to make and came upon this place doing a Google search. For those on a similar quest, please be aware that the toasted almond bars are only made to order in advance and in a quantity of 12 or more. We opted for the next best thing, which is the toasted almond crunch in a cup of soft serve vanilla. The texture is much more crunchy than the classic Good Humor version and the bits are a little larger, but the taste is very close. We all ran out of the toast almond crunch topping long before the ice cream. Our thought for a future visit is to get this in an Arctic Swirl to have it more evenly distributed. Would also be great if they had an almond flavored ice cream to go with this. Other items on the menu looked amazing, especially the cakes. The odd person out on this trip had a warm waffle sandwich. That thing was HUGE and she could only eat about half of it. Very messy, but thoroughly enjoyed. We will be back when the weather is warmer since there is no indoor seating.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Nice variety of homemade soft serve ice cream.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Soft Serve Ice Cream, Waffle
Loading...