We asked to sample a strawberry ice cream and was told they don’t give sample to “not new flavors.” Seems a bit unusual to me.
Paul Carlino
I had a really good hot fudge sundae here today. That's what I've been craving for a while. I like to get myself a treat every now and then. This hot fudge sundae hit the spot. The ladies working here are nice and the atmosphere is pleasant.
Eddgar Matos
Had an amazing experience at Magnifico Ice Cream! The ice cream was delicious, fresh, and full of flavor. Natali provided outstanding customer service she was friendly, welcoming, and made sure everything was perfect. Her positive attitude made the visit even better. I’ll definitely be coming back and highly recommend this place to anyone looking for great ice cream and excellent service.
vicky janoff
i ordered a cake batter cup, tasted so good and the worker natalie helped me, she was absolutely sweet and very patient when i was unsure on what to order. the ice cream was so good, and after this visit would definitely come back and recommend
Marlene Connors
Ice cream is always good well worth the trip
Google user
What kind of ice cream place of this? They have no hard ice cream
Mohamed Rashwan
((((Extremely)))) low quality and very expensive for no obvious reason. I think they just selling the family owned slogan , seriously disappointed and surprised how busy !!!!!
Jay
Great place, wide variety of ice creams and sundas
Thomas Abraham
I heard about the landmark business Magnificos in East Brunswick, NJ and on Wednesday May 13, 2026 right after I left the Bent Spoon in Princeton I drove to check out Magnificos.
There is no taste sampling as it comes out of a machine I was told, so I went ahead and order a Strawberry Milkshake, Lemon and Cherry Ice. I did not like the Strawberry Milkshake, but the Lemon Ice and Cherry Ice was outstanding! The Ice had a quality to it as having shaved ice with liquid fruit syrup poured on it, but it comes out of a machine.
I still give Magnificos 5 Stars because maybe it was me having the shake with the flavored ice. My plans are to make my own Ice Cream for myself, however I am going to go back and try their soft serve because from what I saw in Youtube videos online they are known for their soft serve ice cream. For certain, I want to try their other Ice flavors.
Plenty of parking. They take both Cash and Credit Card, but I recall there was a extra charge for credit card, but I could also be mistaken about that.
Dominica Augustyn
Order a milkshake and within 3 sips stomach started hurting so bad. My husband ordered a milk shake different flavor and same thing happened. Not sure if it was spoiled milk or what but what a waste of $16 dollars. Both of us threw our shakes away
The ice cream at Magníficos was actually really good, but the service was TERRIBLE. Me and my partner took a few minutes deciding what we wanted, but we made sure to let other people go ahead of us so we wouldn’t hold up the line. When we finally walked up to the window, one of the girls working there literally saw us coming and closed the window in our faces, leaving us standing there waiting just to place an order.
To make it worse, our order still wasn’t taken because the ONE window that was open had an employee standing there talking to a guy for almost 20 minutes straight. No orders were being taken. They were just having a conversation while customers were waiting. Completely unprofessional and honestly frustrating. Good ice cream doesn’t make up for rude service and a total lack of attention to customers.
Dania
unnecessary rude attitude. very overpriced, especially for ice cream that isn’t real. got my order wrong and tried to blame it on me.
Also, you’re not allowed to sample any flavors.
overall bad experience, the person I was with said they’re never coming back
Tony C
Consistently awesome ice-cream
Maria E. J.P.
The mango ice does not taste like mango it was orange. The vanilla ice cream tasted regular not like toasted coconut. Disappointed. Rita's is better
Natalia
The ice cream here is so good and it’s affordable I’m always coming back because it’s really that good I usually get the DOLE WIP NON-DAIRY ice cream 100/10
We asked to sample a strawberry ice cream and was told they don’t give sample to “not new flavors.” Seems a bit unusual to me.
I had a really good hot fudge sundae here today. That's what I've been craving for a while. I like to get myself a treat every now and then. This hot fudge sundae hit the spot. The ladies working here are nice and the atmosphere is pleasant.
Had an amazing experience at Magnifico Ice Cream! The ice cream was delicious, fresh, and full of flavor. Natali provided outstanding customer service she was friendly, welcoming, and made sure everything was perfect. Her positive attitude made the visit even better. I’ll definitely be coming back and highly recommend this place to anyone looking for great ice cream and excellent service.
i ordered a cake batter cup, tasted so good and the worker natalie helped me, she was absolutely sweet and very patient when i was unsure on what to order. the ice cream was so good, and after this visit would definitely come back and recommend
Ice cream is always good well worth the trip
What kind of ice cream place of this?
They have no hard ice cream
((((Extremely)))) low quality and very expensive for no obvious reason.
I think they just selling the family owned slogan , seriously disappointed and surprised how busy !!!!!
Great place, wide variety of ice creams and sundas
I heard about the landmark business Magnificos in East Brunswick, NJ and on Wednesday May 13, 2026 right after I left the Bent Spoon in Princeton I drove to check out Magnificos.
There is no taste sampling as it comes out of a machine I was told, so I went ahead and order a Strawberry Milkshake, Lemon and Cherry Ice. I did not like the Strawberry Milkshake, but the Lemon Ice and Cherry Ice was outstanding! The Ice had a quality to it as having shaved ice with liquid fruit syrup poured on it, but it comes out of a machine.
I still give Magnificos 5 Stars because maybe it was me having the shake with the flavored ice. My plans are to make my own Ice Cream for myself, however I am going to go back and try their soft serve because from what I saw in Youtube videos online they are known for their soft serve ice cream. For certain, I want to try their other Ice flavors.
Plenty of parking. They take both Cash and Credit Card, but I recall there was a extra charge for credit card, but I could also be mistaken about that.
Order a milkshake and within 3 sips stomach started hurting so bad. My husband ordered a milk shake different flavor and same thing happened. Not sure if it was spoiled milk or what but what a waste of $16 dollars. Both of us threw our shakes away
Restaurantji Recommends
The ice cream at Magníficos was actually really good, but the service was TERRIBLE. Me and my partner took a few minutes deciding what we wanted, but we made sure to let other people go ahead of us so we wouldn’t hold up the line. When we finally walked up to the window, one of the girls working there literally saw us coming and closed the window in our faces, leaving us standing there waiting just to place an order.
To make it worse, our order still wasn’t taken because the ONE window that was open had an employee standing there talking to a guy for almost 20 minutes straight. No orders were being taken. They were just having a conversation while customers were waiting. Completely unprofessional and honestly frustrating. Good ice cream doesn’t make up for rude service and a total lack of attention to customers.
unnecessary rude attitude. very overpriced, especially for ice cream that isn’t real. got my order wrong and tried to blame it on me.
Also, you’re not allowed to sample any flavors.
overall bad experience, the person I was with said they’re never coming back
Consistently awesome ice-cream
The mango ice does not taste like mango it was orange. The vanilla ice cream tasted regular not like toasted coconut. Disappointed. Rita's is better
The ice cream here is so good and it’s affordable I’m always coming back because it’s really that good I usually get the DOLE WIP NON-DAIRY ice cream 100/10
Loading...