Costello's Pizzeria & Wings

45 South New York Road, Smithville
(609) 652-0378

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Pasta Fagioli Soup
Mozzarella Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Buffalo Tails
Buffalo Pizza
Buffalo Wings
Waffle Fries
Stockton Bomb

Menu

Appetizers and Sides

Bagetta Bruschetta
Toasted Italian bread with chopped tomatoes, onions and fresh basil bruschetta. Add melted provolone cheese for an additional charge.
Jalapeno Poppers
Filled with Philadelphia cream cheese and served with a side of raspberry vinaigrette.
Cheesesteak Eggrolls
Served with side of Sriracha ketchup.
Buffalo Mac and Cheese Eggrolls
Mac and cheese mixed with chopped tails and mild sauce. Served with cheese sauce mixed with mild.
Buffalo Chicken Dip
Served with tortilla chips.
Chicken Fingers and French Fries
5 pieces. Served with your choice of honey mustard or BBQ dipping sauce.
Onion Rings
Served with a side of ranch dressing.
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with a side of homemade marinara sauce.
Fried Calamari
Served with side of homemade marinara sauce.
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
Served with tortilla chips.
Mussels
20 pieces. Farm raised mussels served in choice of homemade sauce.
Broccoli Cheddar Bites
Broccoli florets and cheddar cheese battered, fried and served with a side of ranch.
Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato
Slices of tomato and fresh mozzarella cheese with balsamic drizzle.
Stockton Bomb Nachos
Chopped tails in mild sauce, chopped mozzarella sticks, fries and bleu cheese.

Soups

Pasta Fagioli Soup
Soup made with pasta and beans.
Chicken Tortellini Soup
Broccoli Cheddar Soup

Salads

Garden Salad
A bed of mixed greens topped with garden fresh tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions and green peppers.
Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce with homemade croutons, imported Romano cheese and side of creamy Caesar dressing. Add fried calamari for an additional charge.
Antipasto Salad
Mixed greens, Genoa salami, capicola, prosciutto, Italian olives, and fire-roasted red peppers sprinkled with sharp provolone shavings.
Chef's Salad
Mixed greens, turkey, ham, American and provolone cheese, with tomatoes, cucumbers and red onins.
Buffalo Chicken Salad
3 mild Buffalo tails, served over mixed greens with sharp provolone cheese and black olives.
Crispy Chicken Salad
Warm crispy chicken tenders with mandarin oranges, tomatoes, cucumbers, and black olives over mixed greens.
Tuna Bruschetta Salad
A bed of mixed greens topped with a scoop of tuna salad, a scoop of fresh tomato bruschetta, and slices of fresh mozzarella cheese.
Blackened Chicken Bruschetta Salad
A bed of mixed greens topped with grilled blackened chicken, a scoop of fresh tomato bruschetta and slices of fresh mozzarella cheese.
Spring Mix Salad
Spring mix lettuce, sliced tomatoes, red onions, feta cheese, walnuts and dried cranberries. Try with our raspberry vinaigrette.
Cobb Salad
Mixed greens, with grilled chicken, bacon, hard-boiled egg, cucumbers, and tomatoes.
Chicken Cutlet Caprese Salad
Spring mix lettuce, sliced tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and chicken cutlet topped with a balsamic glaze.

Gourmet Pizza

Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Grillled chicken smothered in our famous wing sauce, topped with mozzarella and side of bleu cheese dressing.
Fuggeddaboudit Pizza
Pronounced (fa-ged-a-bout-it). Our traditional pie topped with mozzarella and bacon, mushrooms, green peppers, black olives and extra cheese.
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Grilled chicken smothered in a hickory smoked BBQ sauce, topped with mozzarella and bacon, served with a side of ranch.
Philadelphia Cheesesteak Pizza
Thinly chopped USDA beef with provolone cheese, American cheese and fried onions.
Da Veggie Pizza
An oil and garlic pie covered with slices of tomato, broccoli florets, spinach, button mushrooms, ricotta and mozzarella.
16" Pizza Palermo
Fresh plum tomato marinara sauce, mozzarella, Italian sausage, garlic and roasted red peppers.
16" Classic Tomato Pie
Fresh marinara sauce, olive oil and oregano.
16" Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
White pie with chicken, bacon and ranch dressing.
Stockton Bomb Pizza
Served with a side of bleu cheese.
16" Marghertia Pizza
Fresh plum tomato marinara sauce, sliced mozzarella cheese topped with basil.
Meat Lovers Pizza
Our traditional red pie topped with pepperoni, sausage and bacon.
Chicken Vodka Parmesan Pizza
Chicken cutlet smothered in cheese and our vodka sauce.
Crispy Pepperoni Hot Honey Pie
Our delicious pepperoni with a touch of Mike's hot honey oil.

Pizza

Cheese Pizza
Oil and Garlic White Pizza

Fries

French Fries
Fried potatoes.
Sweet Potato Fries
Fried sweet potatoes.
Curly Fries
Funnel Cake Fries
Waffle Fries
Lattice shaped fried potatoes.

Legendary Buffalo Style Chicken

Buffalo Wings with Bleu Cheese
Chicken wings fried crispy and tossed in choice of sauce.
24 Buffalo Wings with 2 Bleu Cheese
Chicken wings fried crispy and tossed in choice of sauce.
48 Buffalo Wings with 4 Bleu Cheese
Chicken wings fried crispy and tossed in choice of sauce.
100 Buffalo Wings with 2 Pint Bleu Cheese
6 Piece Buffalo Tails with Bleu Cheese
Boneless chicken breast, lightly floured, fried crispy and tossed in choice of sauce.
12 Piece Buffalo Tails with Bleu Cheese
Boneless chicken breast, lightly floured, fried crispy and tossed in choice of sauce.
24 Piece Buffalo Tails with 2 Bleu Cheese
Boneless chicken breast, lightly floured, fried crispy and tossed in choice of sauce.
48 Piece Buffalo Tails with 4 Bleu Cheese
Boneless chicken breast, lightly floured, fried crispy and tossed in choice of sauce.
100 Piece Buffalo Tails with 2 Pint Bleu Cheese
Boneless chicken breast, lightly floured, fried crispy and tossed in choice of sauce.
6 Piece Buffalo Ears with Blue Cheese
Breaded chicken fingers fried crispy and tossed in choice of sauce.
12 Piece Buffalo Ears with Blue Cheese
Breaded chicken fingers fried crispy and tossed in choice of sauce.
24 Piece Buffalo Ears with 2 Blue Cheese
Breaded chicken fingers fried crispy and tossed in choice of sauce.
48 Piece Buffalo Ears with 4 Blue Cheese
Breaded chicken fingers fried crispy and tossed in choice of sauce.
100 Piece Buffalo Ears with 2 Pint Blue Cheese
Breaded chicken fingers fried crispy and tossed in choice of sauce.

Calzone and Stromboli

Regular Calzone
Fresh dough stuffed with mozzarella and ricotta, baked until golden brown. Served with a side of homemade red sauce.
Steak Calzone
A baked or fried turnover of pizza dough stuffed with savory fillings.
Chicken Calzone
A baked or fried turnover of pizza dough stuffed with savory fillings.
Veggie Calzone
Spinach, onions, broccoll, mushrooms, tomato, green peppers, ricotta and mozzarella cheese.
The Works Calzone
Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers and mozzarella cheese.
Steak Stromboli
Chicken Stromboli
The Fatty Stromboli
Grilled chicken with our famous Buffalo sauce and mozzarella cheese.
Build Your Own Stromboli
Add any of our pizza toppings to create your own stromboli.
Small Stockton Bomboli
Boneless Buffalo tails, mozzarella sticks, french fries, and mozzarella cheese, served with a side of bleu cheese dressing.

Burgers and Chicken Sandwiches
The Basic Burger
Topped with lettuce, tomato, raw onion and choice of cheese.
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Topped with fried onions, sauteed mushrooms, and melted Swiss cheese.
Bleu Bacon Burger
Topped with crispy bacon, bleu cheese dressing, melted American cheese.
Cheddar Bacon Burger
Topped with bacon, melted cheddar cheese sauce.
Pizza Burger
Topped with homemade red sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
Italian Burger
Topped with ham, capicola and provolone cheese.
The Basic Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken breast with lettuce, tomato, onion and choice of cheese.
Grilled Chicken and Portobello Mushroom Sandwich
Grilled chicken breast with a sauteed portobello mushroom, spinach and melted provolone cheese.
Bruschetta Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken breast topped with horseradish tomato, basil and onion bruschetta and melted provolone cheese.
Chicken Avocado Sandwich
Grilled chicken breast topped with avocado, bacon, tomato, and served with a side of ranch dressing.
BBQ Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken with bacon and a shredded cheddar blend topped with BBQ sauce.

Cold Subs and Wraps

Regular Italian Sandwich
Capicola, Genoa salami, ham and provolone cheese,
Turkey Sandwich
Ham Sandwich
Genoa Salami Sandwich
Tuna Sandwich
Roast Beef Sandwich
Capicola, Salami and Cheese Sandwich
Tuna Melt Sandwich
Turkey Reuben Sandwich

The Galloway Clubs

Club I
Roast beef, coleslaw and Russian dressing with lettuce, tomato and bacon.
Club II
Thinly sliced turkey breast with lettuce, tomato and bacon.
Club III
Thinly chopped beef steak and melted American cheese with lettuce, tomato and bacon.
Club IV
Our homemade tuna salad with lettuce, tomato and bacon.
Club V
Bacon, lettuce and tomato.

Signature Subs and Wraps

The Roman Sandwich
Genoa salami, prosciutto ham, fire roasted red peppers, provolone and extra virgin olive oil.
The Milano Sandwich
Italian meats and cheese, roasted red peppers, prosciutto ham, and imported sharp provolone cheese.
The Godfather Sandwich
Chicken cutlet, breaded and golden brown, with spinach and melted sharp provolone cheese.
Grilled Chicken and Roasted Pepper Sub
Grilled chicken breast, spinach, roasted red peppers and melted provolone cheese.
Honey Turkey Sandwich
Sliced turkey breast, bacon, lettuce, tomato, honey mustard and provolone cheese. Try as a wrap!

Costello's Classics

The Fatty Sandwich
Grilled chicken steak mixed with our famous mild Buffalo sauce and bleu cheese. Add American cheese for an additional charge.
The Hail Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, imported Romano cheese, and creamy Caesar dressing served in a flour tortilla wrap.
The Big Biff Sandwich
Philly steak, bacon, pepperoni, seasoned curly fries and melted mozzarella cheese.
Stockton Bomb Sandwich
Boneless Buffalo tails, mozzarella sticks, french fries and bleu cheese dressing.
Buffalo Ranchero Sandwich
Crispy chicken tossed in mild Buffalo sauce with lettuce, tomato, ranch dressing. Try as a wrap!
Ranchero Wrap
Crispy chicken, lettuce, tomato, American cheese and ranch dressing served in a flour tortilla wrap.
Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla
Grilled chicken steak, our famous Buffalo wing sauce and melted American cheese served with a side of bleu cheese.
Blue Devil Sandwich
Chicken steak, bacon, french fries, melted sauce, mozzarella and bleu cheese dressing.

Hot Subs and Wraps

Cheesesteak
Chicken Cheesesteak
Pizza Steak
Thinly chopped steak with our homemade red sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Cordon Bleu Sandwich
Breaded chicken cutlet, ham, mushrooms, honey mustard and melted Swiss cheese.
Veggie Sub
Sauteed broccoli florets, mushrooms, spinach, tomatoes, green peppers and onions.
Sausage, Peppers and Onions Sandwich
Meatball Parmigiana Sandwich
Our homemade meatballs with red sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
Sausage Parmigiana Sandwich
Italian sausage with our homemade red sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Parmigiana Sandwich
Breaded chicken cutlet with our homemade red sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
Eggplant Parmigiana Sandwich
Sliced breaded eggplant with our homemade red sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.

Pasta

Basic Pasta
Our homemade marinara, Alfredo, vodka or rosa sauce.
Pasta with Meatballs
Our homemade meatballs and red sauce served over your choice of pasta.
Eggplant Parmigiana
Breaded eggplant with our homemade red sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
Sicilian Baked Ziti
Penne pasta baked with our homemade red sauce and mozzarella cheese.
Pasta with Meat Sauce
Our homemade meat sauce.
Pasta with Chicken and Broccoli
Sauteed chicken and broccoli in our garlic and oil sauce.
Pasta Alfredo with Chicken and Broccoli
Your choice of pasta with grilled chicken and broccoli in an Alfredo sauce.
Pasta Primavera
Broccoli, carrots, green and red peppers in our garlic and oil sauce. Add sauteed chicken for an additional charge.
Ravioli
8 pieces. Cheese filled ravioli in our homemade red sauce.
Pasta with Mussels
Mussels cooked in our homemade sauce (red white or fra diavolo).
Grown Up Mac and Cheese

Pollo

Chicken Parmigiana
Breaded chicken cutlet with our homemade red sauce and melted mozzarella cheese served over your choice of pasta.
Chicken Picante
Sauteed chicken in white wine, capers, peppers and lemon slices served over your choice of pasta.
Chicken Marsala
Sauteed chicken in our homemade Marsala sauce and mushrooms served over your choice of pasta.
Chicken Rosa
Sauteed chicken in our homemade rosa sauce with spinach and red peppers served over your choice of pasta.
Chicken Francese
Battered chicken in white wine and lemon slices served over your choice of pasta.
Chicken and Vodka Sauce
Sauteed chicken in our homemade vodka sauce served over your choice of pasta.

Kid's Menu
Kid's Mac and Cheese
Kid's portion of penne pasta with our homemade cheese sauce.
Kid's Pasta Meatball
Penne pasta served with your choice of red or butter sauce, and (1) meatball.
Kid's Ravioli
4 cheese filled ravioli in our homemade red sauce.
Kid's Hot Dog and French Fries
Kid's Chicken Fingers and Fries
3 pieces. Served with your choice of honey mustard or BBQ dipping sauce.
Kid's Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Your choice of toast (white, wheat or rye) with melted American cheese and side of french fries. Add extras for an additional charge.

Desserts
Cannoli
Served by the slice.
Classic Cheesecake
Rich creamy cake.
Chocolate Mud Pie
Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie

Beverages
Soda
Pure Leaf Iced Tea
Gatorade
Juice
Aquafina

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+45 photos
Photo credit: google
+44 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We used to look forward to visiting when we would go to historic Smithville. Unfortunately they moved and changed their menu a bit, gettimg rid of my wife's favorite bruschetta. Drove 45 minutes for that only to be dissapointed.

That being said., the food is very good but is it better than pizza we get at home 5 mons away? No. The poimt being this went from a destination place to a place we probably won't visit again

Folks were...
July 2026
I'll tell you what I was a little afraid when they left village on the green. Just ordered Philly cheesesteak Pizza from their new location.Not the one on chris gaup. This Pizza is magical.Great people always polite. Cook your order the way you want to go. 10 out of 10. You won't be sorry, order from this place. THE BOMB THEY ARE LOCATED IN THE SAME PLAZA AS J D'S PUB
April 2026
First time in here since the new location opened. I ordered a chicken parm sandwich, and a couple of slices of pepperoni pizza. The total came out to over $28.00, which seems crazy expensive for me. The sandwich was ok, but nothing out of this world and my wife said the pizza was just ok. I don’t think I’ll be back with those prices.
April 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Lakeside Grill - 615 E Moss Mill Rd
American, Wraps, Vegetarian, Pet Friendly
The Smithville Inn - 1 N New York Rd
American, Venues & Event Spaces, Bar, Vegetarian, New American
Smithville Peanut Butter Company - 615 E Moss Mill Rd #55
Bakery, Pet Friendly

Costello's Pizzeria & Wings

45 South New York Road, Smithville, NJ 08205
(609) 652-0378