For the amount we paid, we got a lot of slices of pizza. Plus, the pick-up time was at a reasonable time frame - actual dinner time and not at 9 PM. We got 4 slices (3 plain, 1 buffalo chicken), and 3 garlic knots. The slices were HUGE. It's probably 1.5x the size of a regular slice. It was only okay though. The crust was too thick for me. There are certain pizzas that are still good even when you reheat it but again, this one was just basic. But still, I can't complain since we got a great deal, and at the end of the day, pizza is pizza.
Sophia K
In New Jersey, it’s really difficult to find appealing vegan options. This shop blows every other option in NJ out of the water! The pizzas are delicious, my S/O and I have tried the buffalo, BBQ, pepperoni pizzas and the garlic knots and they are all so delicious! Most of all, ever since going vegan, I just came to terms with the fact that I would never be able to have a good calzone ever again. The VEGAN CALZONES HERE ARE SO DELICIOUS and they are HUGE!!! You have to try them! And I am sure that the non-vegan options are just as delicious as it’s not so easy to have a good vegan menu but they have it down pat! I should have written this review a long time ago and for that I apologize! The owners here are so sweet too. They are great people! Please try something from here you won’t regret it!
Found this place looking for vegan (dairy free) options in the area. Not sure how we haven’t found it before- but glad we did! The owners could it be nicer- they answered every question and were extremely welcoming. The pizza, both vegan and regular, was delicious and greatly enjoyed by the family. We will definitely be back!
Prob the one of the best vegan pizza spots ? in NJ. The owners are super friendly. They make their own plant based pepperoni. I’ll def be coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Earth.Angel
I had been looking for a pepperoni calzone for years and Mamma Mia's delivered big! It was fire ??. Great service too.
Uhsarp A
I had the vegetarian pizza. Just tastes amazing. Perfect crust and cheese to tipping ratio. Satisfying pizza without the guilt of grease. Owners are the sweetest people you can ever meet
Kenny N
As a fellow vegan in NJ, you don’t usually anticipate finding many options outside of the city, so to find that there was a pizzeria within my vicinity that sold vegan pizza and vegan calzones…I was stunned. The vegan pizzas were absolutely delicious. I’ve had the Vegan pepperoni, vegan buffalo chicken (my favorite thus far), and the vegan bbq chicken. May I just add, the vegan calzones are to DIE for. I’ve been vegan for 9 years and have yet to have find a vegan calzone that tasted like the real thing until this month when I stumbled upon Mamma Mia’s Pizza. If you’re vegan, please do yourself the favor and come straight here! I’m telling you, you won’t be disappointed. Portions are nice and big.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Holly “Hol”
Wow!! I am blown away. Probably the nicest people I’ve ever encountered. I’m vegan and my son isn’t I always struggle to find pizza places we can both go. This place is amazing. The vegan food is home made ! The pizza my son loved. Super reasonable prices. The family is so down the earth!!! They put on a show for my son to watch while we eat I highly recommend! Best pizza place around !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jose Flores
Good pizza
Arbion Guzi
truly friends with the workers they are very nice and my friends have crushes on the workers
New customer and will be back! Very happy with the pizza! Looking forward to trying other things soon
S.B.
New customer and will be back! Very happy with the pizza! Looking forward to trying other things soon
Amanda M
Nice mouth on whoever the delivery driver was tonight. Since I stopped on Ray Street to turn by Genevieve’s and he decided to lay it on his horn and when I yelled out to have some patience he told me to F off. Real nice way to treat Garfield residents who may or may not be customers of yours. Or whose children may or may not grab a slice at your pizzeria once in a while. I’ll make sure my kids never go there and give you business ever again.
Service: 1
Marie
Best Pizzeria in town!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie Encarnacion
Amazing Pizza right here in Garfield, NJ! I ordered a personal margarita pizza and my first bite was so tasty! Will definitely order more from
*TOO GOOD TO GO REVIEW*
For the amount we paid, we got a lot of slices of pizza. Plus, the pick-up time was at a reasonable time frame - actual dinner time and not at 9 PM. We got 4 slices (3 plain, 1 buffalo chicken), and 3 garlic knots. The slices were HUGE. It's probably 1.5x the size of a regular slice. It was only okay though. The crust was too thick for me. There are certain pizzas that are still good even when you reheat it but again, this one was just basic. But still, I can't complain since we got a great deal, and at the end of the day, pizza is pizza.
In New Jersey, it’s really difficult to find appealing vegan options. This shop blows every other option in NJ out of the water!
The pizzas are delicious, my S/O and I have tried the buffalo, BBQ, pepperoni pizzas and the garlic knots and they are all so delicious!
Most of all, ever since going vegan, I just came to terms with the fact that I would never be able to have a good calzone ever again. The VEGAN CALZONES HERE ARE SO DELICIOUS and they are HUGE!!! You have to try them! And I am sure that the non-vegan options are just as delicious as it’s not so easy to have a good vegan menu but they have it down pat! I should have written this review a long time ago and for that I apologize!
The owners here are so sweet too. They are great people! Please try something from here you won’t regret it!
Vegetarian options: VEGAN OPTIONS ARE AMAZING
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vegan Garlic Knots, Vegan Chick'n & Cheez Calzone, Vegan Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Vegan Pizza Half BBQ Chick'n Half Buffalo Chick'n, BBQ Chicken Pizza
Found this place looking for vegan (dairy free) options in the area. Not sure how we haven’t found it before- but glad we did! The owners could it be nicer- they answered every question and were extremely welcoming. The pizza, both vegan and regular, was delicious and greatly enjoyed by the family. We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Vegan Garlic Knots, BBQ Chicken Pizza
Prob the one of the best vegan pizza spots ? in NJ. The owners are super friendly. They make their own plant based pepperoni. I’ll def be coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had been looking for a pepperoni calzone for years and Mamma Mia's delivered big! It was fire ??. Great service too.
I had the vegetarian pizza. Just tastes amazing. Perfect crust and cheese to tipping ratio. Satisfying pizza without the guilt of grease. Owners are the sweetest people you can ever meet
As a fellow vegan in NJ, you don’t usually anticipate finding many options outside of the city, so to find that there was a pizzeria within my vicinity that sold vegan pizza and vegan calzones…I was stunned. The vegan pizzas were absolutely delicious. I’ve had the Vegan pepperoni, vegan buffalo chicken (my favorite thus far), and the vegan bbq chicken.
May I just add, the vegan calzones are to DIE for. I’ve been vegan for 9 years and have yet to have find a vegan calzone that tasted like the real thing until this month when I stumbled upon Mamma Mia’s Pizza. If you’re vegan, please do yourself the favor and come straight here! I’m telling you, you won’t be disappointed. Portions are nice and big.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wow!! I am blown away. Probably the nicest people I’ve ever encountered. I’m vegan and my son isn’t I always struggle to find pizza places we can both go. This place is amazing. The vegan food is home made ! The pizza my son loved. Super reasonable prices. The family is so down the earth!!! They put on a show for my son to watch while we eat I highly recommend! Best pizza place around !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza
truly friends with the workers they are very nice and my friends have crushes on the workers
Restaurantji Recommends
New customer and will be back! Very happy with the pizza! Looking forward to trying other things soon
New customer and will be back! Very happy with the pizza! Looking forward to trying other things soon
Nice mouth on whoever the delivery driver was tonight. Since I stopped on Ray Street to turn by Genevieve’s and he decided to lay it on his horn and when I yelled out to have some patience he told me to F off. Real nice way to treat Garfield residents who may or may not be customers of yours. Or whose children may or may not grab a slice at your pizzeria once in a while. I’ll make sure my kids never go there and give you business ever again.
Service: 1
Best Pizzeria in town!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing Pizza right here in Garfield, NJ! I ordered a personal margarita pizza and my first bite was so tasty! Will definitely order more from
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...