Wow!! I am blown away. Probably the nicest people I’ve ever encountered. I’m vegan and my son isn’t I always struggle to find pizza places we can both go. This place is amazing. The vegan food is home made ! The pizza my son loved. Super reasonable prices. The family is so down the earth!!! They put on a show for my son to watch while we eat I highly recommend! Best pizza place around !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jose Flores
Good pizza
Arbion Guzi
truly friends with the workers they are very nice and my friends have crushes on the workers
S.B.
New customer and will be back! Very happy with the pizza! Looking forward to trying other things soon
Amanda M
Nice mouth on whoever the delivery driver was tonight. Since I stopped on Ray Street to turn by Genevieve’s and he decided to lay it on his horn and when I yelled out to have some patience he told me to F off. Real nice way to treat Garfield residents who may or may not be customers of yours. Or whose children may or may not grab a slice at your pizzeria once in a while. I’ll make sure my kids never go there and give you business ever again.
Service: 1
Marie
Best Pizzeria in town!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie Encarnacion
Amazing Pizza right here in Garfield, NJ! I ordered a personal margarita pizza and my first bite was so tasty! Will definitely order more from
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stefany (Steph)
Very down to earth pizzeria. The people make it your usual spot. Relaxed atmosphere and very friendly! Lived in Garfield for 5 years and can definitely say we order from Mama Mia's as our place for pizza. Love the buffalo chicken pizza! What makes a place a spot, has a lot to do with the people who make it. This place...it's that spot. Thank you for the pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
June Cruz
Excellent pizza. The young man who delivered our order was so polite! ❤
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mahdey R.
The food is great and so are the owners. This business is run by a dedicated family that prioritizes customer satisfaction, this is evident in their service and high-quality food. I 100% recommend it.
Never stepped foot in here and probably never will. I usually wait outside for my relative to come out the middle school. On 11/16/23 around 12:15pm I hear a man yelling and screaming at a female worker. Cursing at her left and right calling her a bunch of names you don’t call a woman because she moved something of his. Not sure if he’s the owner but whoever he is should be ashamed of himself. After cursing her out he gradually goes back to running on his treadmill. Avoid this place.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
David Atkins
The pizza was great but to my surprise, they made a special quesadilla to die for and the chicken wings were amazing.
John Maher Jr
I will be honest these had to be the nicest people to ever serve a pizza. They were so nice and pleasant. Everybody should take lessons from how they were. The pizza was great don’t get me wrong, but the customer service and the atmosphere were tremendous do you ever having a bad day go get yourself a
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John M.
Do you ever have a customer service experience so great that you immediately went to Yelp to leave a review ? This is that experience. The only thing better than the Pizza were the people who made it. It had the nicest Pizza experience scratch that nicest experience I've had in a very long time. I should've got them their names because it was that good if you're having a bad day and want to have a great experience and feel a little bit better, go get yourself a slice from Mamma Mia.
Daniel Malave
After a Friday long day of work. What's better than a nice pizza. I visited Mamma Mia and I'm glad I did. The pizza was great but to my surprise, they made a special quesadilla to die for and the chicken wings were amazing. The service was venomous
Wow!! I am blown away. Probably the nicest people I’ve ever encountered. I’m vegan and my son isn’t I always struggle to find pizza places we can both go. This place is amazing. The vegan food is home made ! The pizza my son loved. Super reasonable prices. The family is so down the earth!!! They put on a show for my son to watch while we eat I highly recommend! Best pizza place around !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Good pizza
truly friends with the workers they are very nice and my friends have crushes on the workers
New customer and will be back! Very happy with the pizza! Looking forward to trying other things soon
Nice mouth on whoever the delivery driver was tonight. Since I stopped on Ray Street to turn by Genevieve’s and he decided to lay it on his horn and when I yelled out to have some patience he told me to F off. Real nice way to treat Garfield residents who may or may not be customers of yours. Or whose children may or may not grab a slice at your pizzeria once in a while. I’ll make sure my kids never go there and give you business ever again.
Service: 1
Best Pizzeria in town!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing Pizza right here in Garfield, NJ! I ordered a personal margarita pizza and my first bite was so tasty! Will definitely order more from
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very down to earth pizzeria. The people make it your usual spot. Relaxed atmosphere and very friendly! Lived in Garfield for 5 years and can definitely say we order from Mama Mia's as our place for pizza. Love the buffalo chicken pizza! What makes a place a spot, has a lot to do with the people who make it. This place...it's that spot. Thank you for the pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent pizza. The young man who delivered our order was so polite! ❤
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food is great and so are the owners. This business is run by a dedicated family that prioritizes customer satisfaction, this is evident in their service and high-quality food. I 100% recommend it.
Restaurantji Recommends
Never stepped foot in here and probably never will. I usually wait outside for my relative to come out the middle school. On 11/16/23 around 12:15pm I hear a man yelling and screaming at a female worker. Cursing at her left and right calling her a bunch of names you don’t call a woman because she moved something of his. Not sure if he’s the owner but whoever he is should be ashamed of himself. After cursing her out he gradually goes back to running on his treadmill. Avoid this place.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
The pizza was great but to my surprise, they made a special quesadilla to die for and the chicken wings were amazing.
I will be honest these had to be the nicest people to ever serve a pizza. They were so nice and pleasant. Everybody should take lessons from how they were. The pizza was great don’t get me wrong, but the customer service and the atmosphere were tremendous do you ever having a bad day go get yourself a
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Do you ever have a customer service experience so great that you immediately went to Yelp to leave a review ? This is that experience. The only thing better than the Pizza were the people who made it. It had the nicest Pizza experience scratch that nicest experience I've had in a very long time. I should've got them their names because it was that good if you're having a bad day and want to have a great experience and feel a little bit better, go get yourself a slice from Mamma Mia.
After a Friday long day of work. What's better than a nice pizza. I visited Mamma Mia and I'm glad I did. The pizza was great but to my surprise, they made a special quesadilla to die for and the chicken wings were amazing. The service was venomous
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings