Old Time Bagels
3253 NJ-35, Hazlet
(732) 203-9006
Customers' Favorites
Bagel
Menu
Photos
+9 photos
+8 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Just because it’s shaped like a bagel doesn’t make it a bagel. I am there every Wednesday morning where I buy 8 bagels. From the glass you can see the giant vat in the back where they ACTUALLY boil their bagels which is the correct way to make a bagel and not just round dough in the shape of a bagel. These bagels are the best bagels I’ve ever had in New Jersey since moving from New York. The woman behind the counter is always so nice. Their bagels for the quality are well...
Loved the friendly service! Giving only 4 stars for food simply because I've been spoiled by bagels from Union Hill Bagels (they closed at the beginning of the pandemic and still looking for anyone to match the quality, freshness, taste and selection of bagels)- very high bar to reach in my eyes... solid contender though
I was just a passed by yesterday for a quick b’fast and surprisingly enjoyed.
I had a plain butter bagel and smaller side compare to one I usually have in the City.
But this bagel was so high graded and good amount of tasty butter on it.
I also want to say my coffee with milk was great and the people there so good.
Small place and not cheap bagel place but they have done such a great breakfast for me.
I had a plain butter bagel and smaller side compare to one I usually have in the City.
But this bagel was so high graded and good amount of tasty butter on it.
I also want to say my coffee with milk was great and the people there so good.
Small place and not cheap bagel place but they have done such a great breakfast for me.
You May Also Like
Assaggini Di Roma - 3253 NJ-35
![]()
Italian, Vegetarian
Noches de Colombia Hazlet - 3253 NJ-35
![]()
Colombian, Cafe
Starbucks - 3201 NJ-35
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee