Sheepshead Baygels
$ • BagelsAbout Sheepshead Baygels
Customers' Favorites
Pork Roll & Cheese
Breakfast Sandwich
Everything
Sheepshead Baygels Reviews
155 ratings
Share your opinion about Sheepshead Baygels
the best bagels in the area!
Classic Pork roll, egg, and cheese on a bagel. Reduced one star for smaller bagel options, 10 styles or so. Baker's dozen for $18 is more than fair. Great quality, crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Cash only and very limited coffee options. Bring your own travel mug, so hot you might get burned with their cup. Old School Jersey service, great experience.
The best bagel in the area hands down. Has a nice crisp outside and soft inside, the BEC is a masterpiece. Everyone in the shop is super friendly and you feel like you’re part of a family. If you want a bagel that tastes like you got it in Brooklyn hands down this is the place.
Hours
| Monday | 6:30AM - 2PM |
| Tuesday | 6:30AM - 2PM |
| Wednesday | 6:30AM - 2PM |
| Thursday | 6:30AM - 2PM |
| Friday | 6:30AM - 2PM |
| Saturday | 7AM - 1PM |
| Sunday | 6AM - 12:30PM |
Sheepshead Baygels is a popular local spot known for its delicious and authentic bagels, which are described as meaty, crunchy, and crispy on the outside with a strong yeasty pillow-soft interior. The restaurant offers a variety of sandwiches and wraps, including the "Iron Man" and "Potatoes & Egg," which receive praise from customers. The atmosphere is welcoming and friendly, with staff who are very kind and entertaining. Customers appreciate the high-quality, homemade cream cheese and the fresh bagels, especially the French Toast bagel, which has a rich maple syrup flavor. The place is cash-only, but an ATM is available inside. The owner is attentive and considerate, sometimes going out of their way to meet customers’ needs, such as washing the grill for religious restrictions. Overall, Sheepshead Baygels provides great bagels in a cozy, nostalgic setting that keeps people coming back for more.