Over priced Not worth it Small scoop and charge an extra dollar for a regular sugar cone! Won’t go back
Kaitlyn Cuneo
We just moved to Sussex county and while we tried other ice cream shops nothing beats Jefferson Dairy. Their soft serve ice cream is the best and actually has flavor. It’s delicious!
Don Windrem
Good hard ice cream and a few soft ice cream flavors.
Brand Whack
Waaaaaaayyyy better than Cliff's! No doubt!!
Hussain Zaffer
I was very well taken care by the staff and the doctor. Did not had to wait for long.
John Dellamanna
The staff was so welcoming, cheery and helpfull. And the ice-cream was AMAZING
Lisa
Update.....they refunded me for the cake. Great customer service.
Ordered a cake (and me and my daughter had ice cream) a few weeks ago and paid cash. Ice cream server who was working the counter and eating her chipolte salad at the register said I didn't need a receipt. Picked up cake today and had to pay for it again because it wasn't marked 'paid'. Maybe take a 'break' and eat in the back room and pay attention to your customers. Not happy and will not return. Cake is nicely decorated and good but not worth paying double.
Sara
Been coming here for over 20 years and it's declined over the past few, losing its small town charm and turning more into a generic ice cream shop. I hope the charm and uniqueness can return, making it somewhere I'd recommend again! Visited an hour before close and they were out of both elephants never forget (a bestseller) and whipped cream.....
Growing up I used to go all of the time. The past few years quality has gone immensely. Past 2 times found hair deep in the ice cream. Once is bad enough but twice is just insane.
Steve Kosiba
Possibly the best ice cream in the state of NJ. The elite combination is a large cup with cake batter on the bottom, dirty diaper in the middle, and elephants never forget on top. You have peanut butter & chocolate on the top, then a chocolate iced cake on the bottom. Amazing. Elephants never forget is by far the best peanut butter based ice cream I've ever had, and the cake batter is probably top 3 for that flavor - and I've had a lot of cake batter ice cream. I even called in an order once as they were closing & got there at 10:03pm to pick it up.
Giggy LP
Yummiest black raspberry and peanut butter chocolate fudge ice creams weve had in a while!
Diego Rodríguez
Really good ice-cream, specifically the salted caramel. Best ever. Service was excellent
John L. Davis
This place has old-style class and it’s reminiscent of “The Freeze” that I grew up with. The flavors are delicious and the service was good. There was no line when I got there. Parking was easy.
My only problem is with the texture of the chocolate malt milkshake I got. It happens over and over when a place makes a malt with soft-serve ice cream. The whole thing takes on a homogenized version of itself like it’s melted. Why not dip a few scoops of the good stuff and make a real malt (the reason is the cost of the ice cream). But I would pay more if it didn’t sit in my gut and bloat.
Hometown staple!
Ice cream is very expensive
Over priced
Not worth it
Small scoop and charge an extra dollar for a regular sugar cone!
Won’t go back
We just moved to Sussex county and while we tried other ice cream shops nothing beats Jefferson Dairy. Their soft serve ice cream is the best and actually has flavor. It’s delicious!
Good hard ice cream and a few soft ice cream flavors.
Waaaaaaayyyy better than Cliff's! No doubt!!
I was very well taken care by the staff and the doctor. Did not had to wait for long.
The staff was so welcoming, cheery and helpfull. And the ice-cream was AMAZING
Update.....they refunded me for the cake. Great customer service.
Ordered a cake (and me and my daughter had ice cream) a few weeks ago and paid cash. Ice cream server who was working the counter and eating her chipolte salad at the register said I didn't need a receipt. Picked up cake today and had to pay for it again because it wasn't marked 'paid'. Maybe take a 'break' and eat in the back room and pay attention to your customers. Not happy and will not return. Cake is nicely decorated and good but not worth paying double.
Been coming here for over 20 years and it's declined over the past few, losing its small town charm and turning more into a generic ice cream shop. I hope the charm and uniqueness can return, making it somewhere I'd recommend again! Visited an hour before close and they were out of both elephants never forget (a bestseller) and whipped cream.....
Restaurantji Recommends
Growing up I used to go all of the time. The past few years quality has gone immensely. Past 2 times found hair deep in the ice cream. Once is bad enough but twice is just insane.
Possibly the best ice cream in the state of NJ. The elite combination is a large cup with cake batter on the bottom, dirty diaper in the middle, and elephants never forget on top. You have peanut butter & chocolate on the top, then a chocolate iced cake on the bottom. Amazing. Elephants never forget is by far the best peanut butter based ice cream I've ever had, and the cake batter is probably top 3 for that flavor - and I've had a lot of cake batter ice cream. I even called in an order once as they were closing & got there at 10:03pm to pick it up.
Yummiest black raspberry and peanut butter chocolate fudge ice creams weve had in a while!
Really good ice-cream, specifically the salted caramel. Best ever. Service was excellent
This place has old-style class and it’s reminiscent of “The Freeze” that I grew up with. The flavors are delicious and the service was good. There was no line when I got there. Parking was easy.
My only problem is with the texture of the chocolate malt milkshake I got. It happens over and over when a place makes a malt with soft-serve ice cream. The whole thing takes on a homogenized version of itself like it’s melted. Why not dip a few scoops of the good stuff and make a real malt (the reason is the cost of the ice cream). But I would pay more if it didn’t sit in my gut and bloat.
But, four stars. Thanks for a snack.
Loading...