Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop

394 Palisade Ave, Jersey City
(551) 222-4762

Recent Reviews

Liv Arts

I will definitely be back for more Earl gray fudge ice cream!

Mubarak Ahmed

Amazing one of a kind flavors, and great service!

Godiva0318

I was excited to take my two kids here recently after reading many great reviews. Maybe my expectations were too high. The shop is tiny which is fine, but I was thinking there would be more of a selection. Specifically, because this is also called a bake shop, I thought there would be more baked goods. As far as bakery items, there were only chocolate chip cookies and brownies. If you’re going just for ice cream, then there is enough of a selection. My son asked for an ice cream sandwich with some type of chocolate mocha ice cream. I thought his was very good. The ice cream iwas rich and creamy, and the cookies were excellent; although, he thought they were “too salty” (I like a salty chocolate chip cookie). I had a scoop of lemon olive oil ice cream. It was also, very good and unique, but not quite amazing. The one thing that turned me off -and, frankly, this is just a pet peeve of mine- is that they measure their ice cream scoops. I find that to be tacky. To me, it’s similar to when a bartender uses a shot glass to measure pours. It’s a cheap way to do business and, if you’re good at what you do, you should be able to eye-ball it. Anyway, I might come back if I’m in the area.

Ashley M.

The girls that work here are the sweetest ! And they're ice cream although pricey (keep in mind is homemade and organic) is worth every penny I'm obsessed w their strawberry and alfajores & cream ! My roommate got their chocolate and it's also bliss

sunghee kim

Ove this place. No food coloring or over uses of sugar. They also have weekend special flavors!

Terri Kinsella

By far the best homemade ice cream I have had in a long, long time. Their weekly specials are creative and delicious. When in Jersey City, this is a MUST visit.

escamillak

Absolutely love this place! Everyone is friendly and the ice cream so delicious. Always waiting for their next new seasonal flavors to try.

Jessika Olivares (Mizzo_theBookLady)

I love eating Ice Cream here ... it is located right next door to my childhood home and always has some new flavors to try!!! Shop is always clean and staff is always nice too.

Stefanie R.

So it was a little disappointing that for a place with such unique flavors that they don't offer samples because my concern happened and I personally did not love my matcha Oreo ice cream. BUT the rest of the crew loveddd their choices. We got a fruity pebble ice cream sandwich , strawberry sundae and scoops of the midnight flavor. They all loved it and when I tasted theirs it was great! I do also love the fact that you can make your own ice cream sandwich because the cookies baked there are quite yummy! Overall cute place, seemed clean- I will go back for redemption because of everyone raving about this place .

Mark Zozula

Delicious, very rich ice cream.

Julie M.

Amazing ice cream!! Honey lavender was super delish!! I'll be back! Delivery was on point as well!! Thanks

Matthew Owen

Best ice cream in the area, hands down, not as much selection all the time as the Hamilton Park location but still amazing

Adele E

The Honey Lavender and Earl Grey Fudge flavors were amazing! You can easily tell what the flavors are from the taste. Quality ice cream and the staff was nice. It is a small place, so if you see a line, don’t be surprised. Perfect for a hot day.

Conrad

Love it! Unique and tasty ice cream which has a local feel, plus it's organic!

Amir A.

Clean location, delicious products, friendly helpful staff. We enjoyed our individual treats and immediately returned to purchase four pints to take home and share

Load More

Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop

394 Palisade Ave, Jersey City, NJ 07307
(551) 222-4762