Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop
19 McWilliams Pl, Jersey City
(551) 277-8252
Customers' Favorites
Midnight Cocoa Ice Cream Mini
Lemon Olive Oil Ice Cream
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Strawberry Ice Cream
Earl Grey Fudge
Honey Lavender
Ice Cream Cone
Birthday Cake
Malted Cookie
Matcha Oreo
Menu
Photos
+63 photos
+62 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Pretty good ice cream. Very friendly staff. The only thing I didn’t like was the weighing of the ice cream before serving. I do not run a business. So take my ignorant opinion for what it is worth but I did not even look at the price of it until I saw that. I was buying it because it tastes good and I didn’t care but once I saw that I felt nickle and dimed so I looked up to see that I am paying $6 per scoop and I feel like it was not worth it. Years back during a customer...
Ice cream is delicious but my daughter accidentally dropped her scoop immediately after it getting handed over and instead of replacing it for us or giving me a discount on another scoop for her, I was charged full price for a second scoop with the cone and I didn’t even get the cone with it. She put it in a cup.
Good ice cream, questionable customer service.
Good ice cream, questionable customer service.
Solid choices, not too limited without being too expansive. 2 samples only per customer. No tiny/taster/kids sized scoops. It's cold inside. Nice that the service is quick and straightforward, but it's missing that friendly touch.
You May Also Like
Chickie's - 236 Pavonia Ave
![]()
Italian
The Belgian Plate by @waffleitandco - 232 Pavonia Ave
![]()
Belgian, Waffles, Pet Friendly
Rumba Cubana - 235 Pavonia Ave
![]()
Cuban, Bar, Caribbean, Vegan, Vegetarian