Tony Boys Sandwich House Livingston
10 E Mt Pleasant Ave, Livingston
(973) 994-1089
Customers' Favorites
American Chicken Cutlet Sandwich
Roast Beef Sloppy Joe
Shrimp PO Boy
Drunk Chicken
Bologna
10
Featured items
Drunk
Often imitated but never duplicated!!!Our famous vodka sauce and fresh mozz
#1
Turkey Provolone
American
American cheese , tomato , lettuce , Hellmans mayo
#10
Fresh Mozz , Roasted Peppers, Balsamic
#33
Cappicolla,Salami,Pepperoni,Provolone
#4
Homemade Solid White Meat Tuna.. The best!!!
Lancer
STUDENT FAVORITEMelted Cheddar , Bacon , Ranch
Parm
Ceasar
Shaved Parm , House Made Croutons
Buffalo
Romaine ,chicken,blue cheese tomato onion ranch dressing
Chipolte
Make sure you buy a drink!!Chipolte Mayo , Jalepenos , Provolone
Cobb
Romaine grilled chicken,blue cheese,bacon avocado tomato onion house dressing
#15
Turkey , Sous Vide Homemade Roast Beef , Swiss
Lumpy
Melted Mozz , Bacon , Coleslaw , 1k Dressing
The Angry Bird
Choice of cutlet.. Vodka Sauce, melted provolone, pepperoni, hot pepper spread with a honey drizzle
Mr. Goodbyte
Cheddar , Jalepeno , Sauteed Onion , Smashed Avocado , Bacon and Chipolte Mayo
Boardwalk
Peppers , Onions , American Cheese and Heinz Ketchup
California
American Cheese , Lettuce , Tomato Hellmans Mayo
MILKSHAKES!
Cannoli
Cookies & Cream
Chocolate
Vanilla
Strawberry
Reese's Blast
Reese's peanut butter cup with a blast of extra Peanut butter
Take Tony
Caramel, Crushed Pretzel, Reese's peanut butter cup, Peanut butter
Apple Caramel Crunch
Potato chip & caramel
Shake of the month- peppermint bark
Crushed candy cane, white and dark chocolate
Cold Subs
#1
Turkey Provolone
#4
Homemade Solid White Meat Tuna.. The best!!!
#33
Cappicolla,Salami,Pepperoni,Provolone
#23
Ham , Salami Provolone
#15
Turkey , Sous Vide Homemade Roast Beef , Swiss
#7
Turkey , Ham Swiss
#3
Sous Vide Rare Roast Beef and Cheese
#2
Ham Provolone
Phat Phil
Boars Head Turkey & Ham , Melted Swiss, Bacon , L/T/Oi Pickles, 1k dressing , oil vinegar topped with crushed potato chips!!
Hot Subs
Tony Boloney
Old School!!!Fried Boars Head Beef Bologna. ,Melted American , Lettuce, Tomato , Hellmans Mayo
Melt
Solid White Tuna , Melted American , Fresh Tomato
Dip
Roast Beef , Melted Mozz Au Jus Sauce
Dumpty
Pepperoni,Eggs
Humpty
Peppers, Eggs
Cutlets
Drunk
Often imitated but never duplicated!!!Our famous vodka sauce and fresh mozz
American
American cheese , tomato , lettuce , Hellmans mayo
#10
Fresh Mozz , Roasted Peppers, Balsamic
Lancer
STUDENT FAVORITEMelted Cheddar , Bacon , Ranch
The Angry Bird
Choice of cutlet.. Vodka Sauce, melted provolone, pepperoni, hot pepper spread with a honey drizzle
Parm
Nutty Pig
You think I'm nuts??? Try it!!Warm Peanut Butter Sauce , Bacon , Cool Jelly
Lumpy
Melted Mozz , Bacon , Coleslaw , 1k Dressing
Cordon Blue
Tonyboy's personal favorite!!Boars Head Ham , Melted Swiss and the absolute best Honey Mustard Sauce on the planet!!
Chipolte
Make sure you buy a drink!!Chipolte Mayo , Jalepenos , Provolone
Calzone
Boars Head Ham , Ricotta Cheese , Melted Fresh Mozz with a side of Marinara
Chop Chop (chopped salad on a sub)
Why choose between a salad and a sub when you can have both!!Chopped Romaine , Onion ,Tomato , Olives Balsamic dressing
Murph
Sauteed Peppers and Onion in Balsamic sauce
Stallone
Pepperoni , Melted Fresh Mozz , Extra Virgin Olive Oil
West coast
Smashed Avocado , Bacon , Swiss , Mayo
Ribeye Cheesesteaks
Boardwalk
Peppers , Onions , American Cheese and Heinz Ketchup
Mr. Goodbyte
Cheddar , Jalepeno , Sauteed Onion , Smashed Avocado , Bacon and Chipolte Mayo
The Dan Marino
Sliced ribeye, sweet and spicy secret slaw, provolone, fried red onion, potato chips, garlic aioli
Hangover
Vodka Sauce and Fresh mozz
California
American Cheese , Lettuce , Tomato Hellmans Mayo
Doozer
Fresh Mozz , Cherry Peppers EVOO
Mac
American Cheese , Lettuce , Tomato , Pickle and 1k Dressing
Not Just Subs
Roast Beef Swiss Sloppy Joe
Jersey Club
Turkey tripple decker , Swiss , Smashed Avocado, Bacon, Lettuce Tomato Hellmans Mayo Multi Grain
Turkey Swiss Sloppy Joe
Shrek Wrap
Vegetarians!!!Smashed Avocado , Fresh Mozz , Roasted Peppers , Lettuce , Tomato , Onion Italian Dressing in a Whole wheat wrap
Ham Swiss Sloppy Joe
Avocado Toast
Toasted multi grain, Marinated Tomato, Smashed Avocado Chilli Flakes
Salads
Ceasar
Shaved Parm , House Made Croutons
Buffalo
Romaine ,chicken,blue cheese tomato onion ranch dressing
Cobb
Romaine grilled chicken,blue cheese,bacon avocado tomato onion house dressing
Fruity Pebble
Romaine,apple,strawberry,feta,candied almonds tomato,onion balsamic
Simple
Tomato , Onion , Cucumber , Olives Italian Dressing
TonyBoy
Romaine,pepperoni,salami,provolone,tomato,onion,cucumber,olives house dressing
Marra
Romaine fresh mozz roasted peppers tomato onion olives balsamic
Chef
Romaine,turkey,ham,swiss tomato,onion,olives,cucumber house dressing
Santorini
Romaine,feta,cucumber,kalamata,tomato onion house dressing
Salon
Romaine,turkey,avocado,tomato,onion,cucmber honey mustard
Sides
Macaroni Salad
Pickle
Potato Salad
Italian Potato Salad
cherry peppers,garlic extra virgin olive oil
Coleslaw
Chips
Sour cream onion chips
Salt and Vineger
Sea Salt
Cool Ranch Doritos
Jalepeno chips
BBQ
Drinks
Diet Coke
Black Cherry
Lemonade
Ginger Ale
Vanilla Soda
Rootbeer
Orange Creamcicle
Sprie
Water
Unsweet Tea
Diet Peach Iced tea
Liquid Lancer
Powerade
Diet Iced Tea
Seltzer
Peach Iced Tea
Coke
Dessert
Fresh baked jumbo chocolate chip cookie
Tony-which
cannoli cream between 2 chocolate chip cookies
Cannoli
Appetizers !!!
Hotsty Totsty Shrimp
Homemade meatballs (3)
Savoy Wings (10)
Savoy wings (40)
Savoy Wings (20)
Burrata, fresh tomato, sicilian sea salt evoo
Longhots with fried potato
Fried Ravioli (4)
Fried Fresh Mozzarella
Mini Riceballs (4)
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Breaded Shrimp
Sauteed Broccoli Rabe
Macaroni !!!
Make your own pasta
Fresh Pappardelle Bolgnese with Burata
Hotsty totsty shrimp over spaghetti
Rigatoni, Rabe & Sausage Garlic oil
Penne ,Shrimp & Rabe Garlic oil
Entrees !!!
Parmesan
Choice cutlet melted mozz and marinara over penne
DRUNK
Rocky IV
Choice of Cutlet topped with pepperoni, melted mozz smothered in hot and sweet sausage sauce over penne!
Miss Valentina
Choice of cutlet, melted provolone, sauteed Broccoli rabe, fried potatoes longhots, fresh lemon
LiL Tony
Choice of cutlet, melted mozzarella, bolgnese , vodka and hotsty totsy sauce... over penne
chicken savoy
chicken giambotta
Grilled salmon over Broccoli rabe
Next Level
Choice of cutlet, sauteed peppers,onions and potatoes in a balsamic sauce
Fried Meatball Giambotta
Sausage Giambotta
Family Meal Special
Family Special
Party Trays ( Serve 5-7)
Rigatoni Bolgnese Tray
Drunk Chicken Tray
Simple Salad Tray
Ceasar Salad Tray
Santorini Salad Tray
Penne Vodka Tray
Rigatoni Tomato Basil TRAY
Cavatelli Pot Cheese Tray
Cheese Ravioli Tray
Chicken Parm Tray
Eggplant Parm Tray
Chicken Savoy Tray
Chicken Giambotta Tray
Sausage Giambotta Tray
Shrimp Parm Tray
Photos
+64 photos
+63 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
We stopped here for lunch. Both my husband and I ordered cutlet sandwiches. I got the American, but I don't remember what he got. In any case, both sandwiches were large to the point that we could have probably split a sandwich (We are older and don't eat like we used to!) We thought the fries we got and the sandwiches were tasty, and we would definitely stop by again for a cutlet sandwich.
June 2025
Weird place, maybe it's just jersey that makes these places. Not a deli, a strange sandwhich shop that runs like fast food. Prices are high. Sandwhich is pretty good but I can get the exact same sandwhich with chips and a drink for half the price on the better side of the river, NEW YORK!.
January 2025
Went to another tony boys location after eating at this one and I am sorry to report it did not hold a candle to this location. Had a kind of cheesesteak with guac I didnt expect to work but it really did.
October 2024
You May Also Like
Soy & Ginger Wok Grill - 14 E Mt Pleasant Ave
![]()
Asian, Chinese, Vegetarian
THAVMA Mediterranean Grill - 6230 Town Center Way
![]()
Greek, Mediterranean, Vegan, Vegetarian
QQ Asian - 4175 Town Center Way
![]()
Bistros, Chinese, Japanese, Asian Fusion, Sushi