Hail to the King, Baby. Hail to the King! Our family has been regular customers at the Dairy King for 40+ years. There are soft ice cream options (cones and sundaes) as well as hard ice cream. Both are delicious. During the season, they are usually open on afternoons and evenings. In the September/October shoulder season, they tend to be open more for late afternoons and evenings until 9pm. The Dairy King is popular, especially with families with kids and they will draw a crowd in the evening. They have been known to stay open past their published closing time, to make sure that all customers in line are taken care when of, before closing for the night.
Sarah Daniels
One of the best ice cream places I've ever been!!!
kCara stanley
Never open
Chelsea Koziar
I have been on lbi for the week and 3 times I have went around 915 pm or 4pm and it has been closed. Employees were inside and lights out telling us it is closed.
Tess Aaronson Hansen
My kid stole my malted milkshake. It was too delicious.
Gene Sirianni
More reasonable than the other places, larger portions, and most importantly tastes better !!
Christina Hess
Terrible service. It shows they're open til 11pm in season. I arrived at 10:40 and the little girl with red hair shut the open sign off and told us they were closed and have been closed for 20 minutes, even though there are people eating they're freshly served ice cream at the picnic tables outside. This is the second time this week they closed early. I can't imagine how many sales this business looses being so close to fantasy island AND it being peak season with these employees who are more concerned about getting out of work early instead for making money.
Krystal Hoffman
Great place, ice cream & service!! Loved it!!
Brittany Norton
Dairy King is a must-visit spot on LBI! The ice cream portions are super generous, the service is fast, and the prices are surprisingly affordable for a beach town. Whether you're after soft serve, a sundae, or a milkshake, everything is consistently delicious. Even when it's busy, the staff keep the line moving with a smile. It's the kind of place you find yourself going back to every night of your trip. Great for families, late-night treats, or just a quick stop after the beach. Can’t recommend it enough—definitely one of the best ice cream spots on the island!
Jeff Smith
A Beach Haven staple. Delicious and moderately priced.
Wheelchair accessibility: Everything is ground level no stairs if you can get out of the car, you can get your ice cream. And if not, they probably walk it to you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Create Your Own Sundae, Soft Ice Cream
Amanda Hahn
Go-to icecream spot in LBI! Always get the party cake- everything is great. Staff super friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Laurie Stenger
Love the
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ryan A
Best milkshake on lbi! Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Ross
Had the chance to meet the actual Dairy King. Super nice guy. Even let me take a picture of him.
Hail to the King, Baby. Hail to the King! Our family has been regular customers at the Dairy King for 40+ years. There are soft ice cream options (cones and sundaes) as well as hard ice cream. Both are delicious. During the season, they are usually open on afternoons and evenings. In the September/October shoulder season, they tend to be open more for late afternoons and evenings until 9pm. The Dairy King is popular, especially with families with kids and they will draw a crowd in the evening. They have been known to stay open past their published closing time, to make sure that all customers in line are taken care when of, before closing for the night.
One of the best ice cream places I've ever been!!!
Never open
I have been on lbi for the week and 3 times I have went around 915 pm or 4pm and it has been closed. Employees were inside and lights out telling us it is closed.
My kid stole my malted milkshake. It was too delicious.
More reasonable than the other places, larger portions, and most importantly tastes better !!
Terrible service. It shows they're open til 11pm in season. I arrived at 10:40 and the little girl with red hair shut the open sign off and told us they were closed and have been closed for 20 minutes, even though there are people eating they're freshly served ice cream at the picnic tables outside. This is the second time this week they closed early. I can't imagine how many sales this business looses being so close to fantasy island AND it being peak season with these employees who are more concerned about getting out of work early instead for making money.
Great place, ice cream & service!! Loved it!!
Dairy King is a must-visit spot on LBI! The ice cream portions are super generous, the service is fast, and the prices are surprisingly affordable for a beach town. Whether you're after soft serve, a sundae, or a milkshake, everything is consistently delicious. Even when it's busy, the staff keep the line moving with a smile. It's the kind of place you find yourself going back to every night of your trip. Great for families, late-night treats, or just a quick stop after the beach. Can’t recommend it enough—definitely one of the best ice cream spots on the island!
A Beach Haven staple. Delicious and moderately priced.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best ice cream place in Beach Haven
Wheelchair accessibility: Everything is ground level no stairs if you can get out of the car, you can get your ice cream. And if not, they probably walk it to you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Create Your Own Sundae, Soft Ice Cream
Go-to icecream spot in LBI! Always get the party cake- everything is great. Staff super friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love the
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best milkshake on lbi! Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had the chance to meet the actual Dairy King. Super nice guy. Even let me take a picture of him.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...