54 Main Bar & Grille

54 Main St, Madison
(973) 966-0252

Recent Reviews

Sort by
ikmarchini

Greek salad - not Greek nor a salad. $15 for a dessert plate half full of mostly diced cucumbers, 3, yes 3, cherry tomatoes, no onions, tiny feta crumbles, and 'Kalamata' olives from a can. Oil and vinegar AWOL. When I asked to add anchovies they looked at me like I asked for larks' tongues and , of course, unavailable. Stick to burgers and take 'Greek salad' off the menu. In Greece they'd burn the place down.

Billy Fraley

Went in the restaurant with my girlfriend for a date night. The staff was outstanding, no less than 5 minutes to get seated with amazing service. Waiters helped me with all my food options and recommended me their favorite food items. The food tasted excellent, no mixups at all! The general manager came up to us and made us feel very welcome! I will be coming back soon!

Thomas Kelly

Very long wait time for wings and nachos, both of which were bland and cold. Complained to GM who was extremely unpleasant and rude woman

Angelica Campos

I recently visited 54 Main, and the experience was notably different and much improved from my previous visits. We were greeted with a warm welcome by the new manager, and we immediately noticed the positive atmosphere. The food was consistent, and the staff seemed more motivated and attentive, ensuring a better dining experience than we experienced in the past. The ambiance of the restaurant seems more inviting and comfortable. It seems the new manager is committed to elevating the restaurant. I recommend 54 Main for anyone looking for a pleasant meal with great service. I'm excited to see how this restaurant continues to evolve under their new management!

Javier Isidoro

I haven’t been there for a couple months but when I got there couple days ago, I do love the new changes. Meeting the new gm that is very pleasant it was s nice change from what i have experienced in the past. For sure I’ll be back soon.

James Jaworski

🔥 54 Main Bar & Grille is the spot! 🔥 From juicy smashed burgers to fully loaded nachos, every bite hits different. 🍔🤤 The vibe? A perfect mix of lively and laid-back—whether you're out with friends or just unwinding. 🍻✨ Service was on point, drinks were flowing, and the energy was just right. If you haven’t been, you’re missing out! Who’s down for a trip back? 👀🙌 #FoodieFind #GoodVibesOnly

Steve Catanzaro

Decent spot to watch a game. Good food options and drinks menu.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kathy Barzal Real Estate

Great place to eat to watch the games. Always a good meal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 54 Nachos 1 2 Order, French Fries, Smashed Burger, Chicken Sandwich, Cobb Salad, Madison Burger, Chicken Wings

Carlo Dacumos

Great place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Zachary Davis

Stopped in for drink before dinner. Great vibe. Spirited and lovey conversations all around. Creative drinks and great service.

A neighborhood cornerstone.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

M J

Great place to eat and have some good food. Reminds of the TV show "Cheers" type atmosphere

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Classic Turkey Club

Victoria Wood

The service and food is good. The food is also affordable.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Classic Turkey Club, Smashed Burger, Chicken Sandwich, Avocado Toast, Cobb Salad

Ian Michael

Worst experience I've had at an eatery that came highly recommended. It was the Friday of Labor Day weekend, and it was not that busy. We (three of us) were able to get a table immediately and ordered drinks and food within 10 minutes of sitting. Then came the worst of it. Water came first, and there were bugs in the ice cubes in the water glasses. That was strike one. Then, we waited over 1.5 hours for food (wraps and mozzarella sticks). People sat, ate, and left by the time we got our food. That was strike two. Not once during that 1.5 to 2 hour time frame did our waiter come to us to give us an update. We had to ask several other staff members to figure out what was going on. Eventually, someone got back to us and let us know our food will be out shortly. The food took another 10 minutes before we received it. That was strike two. And strike three was the food arriving cold and bland. The fries had no seasoning or salt. The wrap was decent but not worth the wait or money, and the mozzarella sticks were cold and disappointing. We couldn't even finish the food. We paid and left to go across the street. I recommend going to any other establishment on the street over this one. I would NEVER recommend going to an establishment that treats their customers like this.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Rachel Lemon

The food was DELICIOUS!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kevin Tran

Food. Amazing. Atmosphere. Amazing. Service from our waiter, Kevin L. Trash. I always tip well everywhere I go but service was terrible. Be attentative to your tables more, it’s not that hard.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 2

Loading...