Madison Bagel Cafe
23 Waverly Pl, Madison
(973) 845-6008
Customers' Favorites
Taylor Ham and Cheese Bagel Sandwich
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Pastrami Egg and Cheese
Half Dozen Bagels
Egg & Cheese
Croissant
Donut
Menu
Photos
+7 photos
+6 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
My favorite bagel spot since moving out of Brooklyn. Been ordering here consistently over the past couple of months. Their Taylor ham egg and cheese is my go to but everything else I’ve tried (omelettes, bagels, lox, etc) has been incredible
Went 8 AM on a weekend morning purchased bagels, which were moist and obviously came out of a plastic bag. I’ve been buying bagels there for a long time and I’ve never had this experience. I called the store and told them that they seemed like they were a day old bagels and they denied it.
You May Also Like
Bottle Hill Tavern - 13 Waverly Pl
![]()
Bar & Grill, Bar, Seafood, Vegetarian
Blue Wazabi - 20 Waverly Pl
![]()
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Sushi, Asian
I got the sausage, egg, and cheese bagel, and it was excellent—simple, classic, and done right. You can tell everything is made with care, and the consistency really stands out.
The staff are friendly and efficient, and everything feels very well-run. The owner was also a...