McCools Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
26 Main St, Madison
(973) 301-0303
Customers' Favorites
Peanut Butter Topping
Flight of Ice Cream
Medium Soft Serve
Birthday Cake
Double Scoop
Banana Split
Hot Fudge
Gelato
Sundae
Menu
Photos
+32 photos
+31 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
McCool's is my family's go to for a wonderful cold treat and a relaxed and pleasant atmosphere. The flavors are absolutely delicious and consistently exciting, sure to please all taste buds. They are always coming up with innovative and delicious drinks, toppings and flavors! I would like to thank Paul the manager for always going above and beyond for my family. His service and kindness makes all the difference. He truly cares about each customers experience and ensures...
They have so many options it’s genuinely overwhelming, but the ice cream isn’t anything special, about as good as something you’d get at the grocery store—only more expensive. The staff is good and the interior is pretty cute. It’s definitely a good neighborhood spot but nothing fancy, perfect for a university town.
You May Also Like
Formaggio's Pizzeria - 36 Main St
![]()
Pizza, Italian
Butter & Jam - 30 Cook Plaza
![]()
Salad, Soup, Mexican
Il Goccino Ristorante - 33 Main St
![]()
Italian, Vegetarian
OK - back to the ice cream. They add new flavors regularly but always keep our favorites on tap (try the vanilla soft serve - seriously!!!) and have gluten-free and other varities. They're efficient and friendly and it's...