McCools Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
26 Main St, Madison
(973) 301-0303
Customers' Favorites
Peanut Butter Topping
Flight of Ice Cream
Medium Soft Serve
Birthday Cake
Double Scoop
Banana Split
Hot Fudge
Gelato
Sundae
Menu
Photos
+36 photos
+35 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Love this place! Jaclilyn decorates the cakes so well and she did an awesome job converting a premade cake into a ghost spider color scheme for my daughter’s birthday! Highly recommend!
Service was great! Staff are friendly and attentive. However I was very disappointed that they don’t make any of their ice cream! It’s all Hershey’s brand. I guess if you like the endless options, go for it! But if you’re looking for an authentic ice cream shop, this ain’t it.
You May Also Like
Formaggio's Pizzeria - 36 Main St
![]()
Pizza, Italian
Il Goccino Ristorante - 33 Main St
![]()
Italian, Vegetarian
Butter & Jam - 30 Cook Plaza
![]()
Salad, Soup, Mexican, Pet Friendly
Ice cream. ✔
Happiness restored.
McCool’s has what feels like 8,000 flavors, so naturally I spent way too long deciding between Peanut Butter Twist and Peanut Butter Pie.
Peanut Butter Pie won.
Oh. My. God.
Creamy. Rich. Melt-in-your-mouth amazing. This is the kind of ice cream that makes you pause after the first bite because...